You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
James McAtee
- Thread starter Shaelumstash
- Start date
Otamendi's Beard
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 11 Jul 2007
- Messages
- 3,928
Could be an exciting 2nd half of the season for him.
Many were slating this loan a month or so back but it's looking like the perfect situation at the moment. The main thing is having a manager who has faith in him.
Whatever we think about the style of play, Heckingbottom has persisted with playing James and took him out when needed / deserved. That's starting to pay dividends for both the player and club.
Many were slating this loan a month or so back but it's looking like the perfect situation at the moment. The main thing is having a manager who has faith in him.
Whatever we think about the style of play, Heckingbottom has persisted with playing James and took him out when needed / deserved. That's starting to pay dividends for both the player and club.
shroom
Well-Known Member
fyi, Sheff United plays Blackpool tonight, Blackpool has Arsenal teenager Charlie Patino and City's Lewis Fiorini - Pool has GK Grimshaw and Ian Poveda-Ocampo [Leeds], too
BlueMoonRisin’
Well-Known Member
Thanks for the heads up, I'll watch that now. Not seen Sheff United this season so haven't seen how Macca or Doyle are playing. Just wondering if they're good enough to force their way back into our squad at the end of their loans, or it it too early to say?fyi, Sheff United plays Blackpool tonight, Blackpool has Arsenal teenager Charlie Patino and City's Lewis Fiorini - Pool has GK Grimshaw and Ian Poveda-Ocampo [Leeds], too
Lovebitesandeveryfing
Well-Known Member
Watched his 70 mins - played well, got Motm. Almost stunning how much more comfortable he is after the horrendous start in the Championship. This iso video below is from a month ago vs Cardiff, looked good. Looks even better now.
His spacing is sooo much better than early season - he's always open. He's grown really efficient with his movement, conserving energy against mostly more athletic opponents. But his athleticism has improved, faster, stronger. Protects the ball with his body much better. It looks like he's accepted the limitations of his teammates and remains calm and patient while they trip over their shoelaces or shank passes - better mentality. Welcome back, Macca - hubba hubba.
Fascinating seeing those highlights. He's got the skills. But we knew that. It's striking, though, how he's building the physical side of his game. Not shy about mixing it, not pulling out of fifty-fifties. Not prepared to be bullied by the cloggers in the Championship (they're not all cloggers, to be fair).
I would really like to see him back at the Etihad.
Otamendi's Beard
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 11 Jul 2007
- Messages
- 3,928
Ability-wise he's up there with Rico and Cole. So hopefully he comes back and gets a squad role next season.Fascinating seeing those highlights. He's got the skills. But we knew that. It's striking, though, how he's building the physical side of his game. Not shy about mixing it, not pulling out of fifty-fifties. Not prepared to be bullied by the cloggers in the Championship (they're not all cloggers, to be fair).
I would really like to see him back at the Etihad.
Might be wishful thinking though with the competition in midfield.
Lovebitesandeveryfing
Well-Known Member
Ability-wise he's up there with Rico and Cole. So hopefully he comes back and gets a squad role next season.
Might be wishful thinking though with the competition in midfield.
Kev will have to be rotated more. It's just a natural progression. He gives so much when he's on the pitch, you can see in the interviews that he's dead on his feet. He's thirty-one and Ilkay's thirty-two.
And there's still this terrible question mark about Bernardo.
James, at 20, is probably a couple of years off showing what he can really do at the highest level. The club have to plan ahead. As I'm sure they are doing.
Of course, if we actually do get Bellingham that changes the game.
Bear in mind that the last time we took on a hot young talent was Ben Woodburn from Liverpool and he was surprisingly poor. Like a rabit in the headlights, low confidence and hardly played for us and every time he came on as sub you could see he couldn't adapt to the Championship level. So when we heard great things about McAtee...there were plenty of Blades thinking...."probably another Ben Woodburn".
Update on your players:
Tommy Doyle
He is more of a consistent engine room type of midfielder, decent with the ball but also excellent without the ball.
He doesn't stand out as anything special but he's a solid 7 out of 10 most matches. He's an asset at Championship level but due to his style of play but I'm not sure he'll ever be anything special at PL level. Not seen anything to suggest he's good enough to play for Man City, good all-round midfielder though so maybe we can sign him?
James McAtee
In early matches McAtee did the odd trick and flick but was generally ineffective, also he looked really poor when out of possession. He came across as more of a show pony/ flair player with potential but didn't like defending/ tackling.
His 1st start in an away match was at Luton and he very much looked like a lost little boy playing against the men of Luton. Hence the early comments from our fans that McAtee won't hack it at this level, yes, he might have some talent but there's more to football than mere talent. However gradually he's improved his performances, worked harder when out of possession showing fight and effort, this is a good way to win over our fans. His general performances were pretty average/ acceptable but we noticed he'd pop up with a moment of skill/ class to create clear goal scoring chances.
However since the World Cup break he's now played 3 matches, and he's improved again, he seems physically stronger and easily able to ride tackles and challenges, his confidence seems higher because he's now demanding/ seeing more of the ball. He playing for us like a poor mans Phil Foden, good 1st touch, nice awareness with good passing but what makes him stand out is like our other player (N'Diaye) he's capable of short busts of speed and dribbling/ ghosting past defenders causing opposition defences to panic.
The beauty for Sheff Utd is we can be playing quite poorly in a match but N'Diaye and McAtee are 2 players who might also be playing poorly doing very little, then they'll produce a moment of PL level skill/ class from nothing, dribbling past their defenders to set up a goal.
Although McAtee is quality he's currently no where near Man City squad level. He's just an above average Championship player with moments of high quality. However he's gradually improving each match so it does make you wonder what his ceiling is and where his improvement will end? Towards the end of this season he might end up being one of our star players and far too good for Championship level.
Conclusion
My honest opinion is that Doyle is a good player who, if he develops might have a career as an average PL player, so doubt he'll ever be good enough for City. Would think Sheff Utd might try to sign him if we gain promotion back to PL.
Regards McAtee, if he continues to progress this season then next season he needs to be loaned out to a PL club where he's sees plenty of game time. He's clearly a talent and massively improved his game this season when out of possession. So think he will forge a career in the PL but being around the City squad is a different prospect, pretty sure he won't be good enough for your squad next season but after gaining experience in the PL then in 2 or 3 years who knows how good he'll be.
Update on your players:
Tommy Doyle
He is more of a consistent engine room type of midfielder, decent with the ball but also excellent without the ball.
He doesn't stand out as anything special but he's a solid 7 out of 10 most matches. He's an asset at Championship level but due to his style of play but I'm not sure he'll ever be anything special at PL level. Not seen anything to suggest he's good enough to play for Man City, good all-round midfielder though so maybe we can sign him?
James McAtee
In early matches McAtee did the odd trick and flick but was generally ineffective, also he looked really poor when out of possession. He came across as more of a show pony/ flair player with potential but didn't like defending/ tackling.
His 1st start in an away match was at Luton and he very much looked like a lost little boy playing against the men of Luton. Hence the early comments from our fans that McAtee won't hack it at this level, yes, he might have some talent but there's more to football than mere talent. However gradually he's improved his performances, worked harder when out of possession showing fight and effort, this is a good way to win over our fans. His general performances were pretty average/ acceptable but we noticed he'd pop up with a moment of skill/ class to create clear goal scoring chances.
However since the World Cup break he's now played 3 matches, and he's improved again, he seems physically stronger and easily able to ride tackles and challenges, his confidence seems higher because he's now demanding/ seeing more of the ball. He playing for us like a poor mans Phil Foden, good 1st touch, nice awareness with good passing but what makes him stand out is like our other player (N'Diaye) he's capable of short busts of speed and dribbling/ ghosting past defenders causing opposition defences to panic.
The beauty for Sheff Utd is we can be playing quite poorly in a match but N'Diaye and McAtee are 2 players who might also be playing poorly doing very little, then they'll produce a moment of PL level skill/ class from nothing, dribbling past their defenders to set up a goal.
Although McAtee is quality he's currently no where near Man City squad level. He's just an above average Championship player with moments of high quality. However he's gradually improving each match so it does make you wonder what his ceiling is and where his improvement will end? Towards the end of this season he might end up being one of our star players and far too good for Championship level.
Conclusion
My honest opinion is that Doyle is a good player who, if he develops might have a career as an average PL player, so doubt he'll ever be good enough for City. Would think Sheff Utd might try to sign him if we gain promotion back to PL.
Regards McAtee, if he continues to progress this season then next season he needs to be loaned out to a PL club where he's sees plenty of game time. He's clearly a talent and massively improved his game this season when out of possession. So think he will forge a career in the PL but being around the City squad is a different prospect, pretty sure he won't be good enough for your squad next season but after gaining experience in the PL then in 2 or 3 years who knows how good he'll be.
Mad Eyed Screamer
Moderator
Thanks for taking the time to write that.Bear in mind that the last time we took on a hot young talent was Ben Woodburn from Liverpool and he was surprisingly poor. Like a rabit in the headlights, low confidence and hardly played for us and every time he came on as sub you could see he couldn't adapt to the Championship level. So when we heard great things about McAtee...there were plenty of Blades thinking...."probably another Ben Woodburn".
Update on your players:
Tommy Doyle
He is more of a consistent engine room type of midfielder, decent with the ball but also excellent without the ball.
He doesn't stand out as anything special but he's a solid 7 out of 10 most matches. He's an asset at Championship level but due to his style of play but I'm not sure he'll ever be anything special at PL level. Not seen anything to suggest he's good enough to play for Man City, good all-round midfielder though so maybe we can sign him?
James McAtee
In early matches McAtee did the odd trick and flick but was generally ineffective, also he looked really poor when out of possession. He came across as more of a show pony/ flair player with potential but didn't like defending/ tackling.
His 1st start in an away match was at Luton and he very much looked like a lost little boy playing against the men of Luton. Hence the early comments from our fans that McAtee won't hack it at this level, yes, he might have some talent but there's more to football than mere talent. However gradually he's improved his performances, worked harder when out of possession showing fight and effort, this is a good way to win over our fans. His general performances were pretty average/ acceptable but we noticed he'd pop up with a moment of skill/ class to create clear goal scoring chances.
However since the World Cup break he's now played 3 matches, and he's improved again, he seems physically stronger and easily able to ride tackles and challenges, his confidence seems higher because he's now demanding/ seeing more of the ball. He playing for us like a poor mans Phil Foden, good 1st touch, nice awareness with good passing but what makes him stand out is like our other player (N'Diaye) he's capable of short busts of speed and dribbling/ ghosting past defenders causing opposition defences to panic.
The beauty for Sheff Utd is we can be playing quite poorly in a match but N'Diaye and McAtee are 2 players who might also be playing poorly doing very little, then they'll produce a moment of PL level skill/ class from nothing, dribbling past their defenders to set up a goal.
Although McAtee is quality he's currently no where near Man City squad level. He's just an above average Championship player with moments of high quality. However he's gradually improving each match so it does make you wonder what his ceiling is and where his improvement will end? Towards the end of this season he might end up being one of our star players and far too good for Championship level.
Conclusion
My honest opinion is that Doyle is a good player who, if he develops might have a career as an average PL player, so doubt he'll ever be good enough for City. Would think Sheff Utd might try to sign him if we gain promotion back to PL.
Regards McAtee, if he continues to progress this season then next season he needs to be loaned out to a PL club where he's sees plenty of game time. He's clearly a talent and massively improved his game this season when out of possession. So think he will forge a career in the PL but being around the City squad is a different prospect, pretty sure he won't be good enough for your squad next season but after gaining experience in the PL then in 2 or 3 years who knows how good he'll be.
In your conclusion you say McAtee should be loaned out to a PL side next season.
How about the Blades? ;)