James McAtee

[r.soleofsalford]

We got him because United were absolute shite. They had his brother and released him and only then when he went to a new club did his father realise how badly coached he had been and couldn’t have James going through the same. Nothing to do with form for moving.

His Dad and his brother are United fans. James is a City fan. That doesn`t mean money wont sway his decision on where he eventually plays.

 

[SWP's back]

again that makes no sense. you make no points to contradict me. he has no individual skills on his own to make a difference. he needs a good coach and system to stand out. put him in a burnley side and see what difference mcatee makes. he is not like KDB or Foden who can stand out in any team

^
the fuck is this clueless thing?

 

[oldius]

Some strange posts here and it's hard to believe that some people have seen him play. He has vision, technique, balance, finishing ability and dribbling skills. Allied to that, he is scoring goals and lots of them. He clearly is on the cusp of becoming a very good professional and he already has suitors that we know of. In my view, he has earned his chance, as has Palmer, and I hope that he is given it as there will be a time when his patience, or probably his family/agent's patience will wear out and that is always a risk because we are pursuing trophies at the highest levels of the game.

I have always said that it means a little more to me to bring through top-quality local players than to guarantee trophies. I suspect it's because I was born in Moss Side in 1968 and we won nothing for most of that time. Regardless, there is something special about 'one of your own' becoming a star.

 

[Agueroooo9320]

^
the fuck is this clueless thing?

unfortunate you have no reading comprehension.

 

[Agueroooo9320]

Some strange posts here and it's hard to believe that some people have seen him play. He has vision, technique, balance, finishing ability and dribbling skills. Allied to that, he is scoring goals and lots of them. He clearly is on the cusp of becoming a very good professional and he already has suitors that we know of. In my view, he has earned his chance, as has Palmer, and I hope that he is given it as there will be a time when his patience, or probably his family/agent's patience will wear out and that is always a risk because we are pursuing trophies at the highest levels of the game.

I have always said that it means a little more to me to bring through top-quality local players than to guarantee trophies. I suspect it's because I was born in Moss Side in 1968 and we won nothing for most of that time. Regardless, there is something special about 'one of your own' becoming a star.

palmer has more individual standout qualities than mcatee and that is a fact.

 

[FantasyIreland]

palmer has more individual standout qualities than mcatee and that is a fact.

Apples and Oranges......both are incredibly talented and both bring different qualities.

I'm not sure you have ever watched an EDS game.

Stop fucking digging would be my best advice.

 

[SWP's back]

unfortunate you have no reading comprehension.

Unfortunate that seem to have no fucking clue.

 

[Cobra]

palmer has more individual standout qualities than mcatee and that is a fact.

Palmer isn’t as skilful as Messi, as fast as Sterling or a physical beast so presumably he doesn’t have any individual ability either.

 

[oldius]

palmer has more individual standout qualities than mcatee and that is a fact.

That is opinion, not fact. Palmer is a great talent, however.

 

[Man_City_Loyal]

i notice some of the same posters saying Pep should be playing him etc are also the same posters talking about his way of introducing Phil Foden into the 1st team

 

[Man_City_Loyal]

We do seem to loan players out to clubs who then don't play them often enough to gain experience , which is a waste of time for the player.

There surely are better loan options than we have used .

Look at Tommy Doyle barely playing for Hamburg

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

Look at Tommy Doyle barely playing for Hamburg

So bloody frustrating for these players .

Other than paying the clubs to play them ( and I assume we are paying their wages whilst on loan ) how do we ensure that they get playing time ?

Sending them to lower level clubs in the FL seems to be the only way they get to play regularly.

 

[Man_City_Loyal]

So bloody frustrating for these players .

Other than paying the clubs to play them ( and I assume we are paying their wages whilst on loan ) how do we ensure that they get playing time ?

Sending them to lower level clubs in the FL seems to be the only way they get to play regularly.

was thinking that myself

 

[Tim of the Oak]

Some strange posts here and it's hard to believe that some people have seen him play. He has vision, technique, balance, finishing ability and dribbling skills. Allied to that, he is scoring goals and lots of them. He clearly is on the cusp of becoming a very good professional and he already has suitors that we know of. In my view, he has earned his chance, as has Palmer, and I hope that he is given it as there will be a time when his patience, or probably his family/agent's patience will wear out and that is always a risk because we are pursuing trophies at the highest levels of the game.

I have always said that it means a little more to me to bring through top-quality local players than to guarantee trophies. I suspect it's because I was born in Moss Side in 1968 and we won nothing for most of that time. Regardless, there is something special about 'one of your own' becoming a star.

Excellent post. James is an excellent player and a big prospect for the future. Palmer is ahead of him in the pecking order by probably being a year further along in terms of development and, from what I’ve seen, is currently more suited to the possession based football we play.

Hopefully, both lads will be top players for us and it’s impossible to say which of them will have the better career at this early stage.

 

[domalino]

Look at Tommy Doyle barely playing for Hamburg

So bloody frustrating for these players .

Other than paying the clubs to play them ( and I assume we are paying their wages whilst on loan ) how do we ensure that they get playing time ?

Sending them to lower level clubs in the FL seems to be the only way they get to play regularly.

Tommy's played in each of hamburg's last 5 games, it's pretty clear to anyone following it that he's being gradually integrated into the team after moving to a new club in a new country where he doesn't speak the language only 8 weeks ago.

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

Tommy's played in each of hamburg's last 5 games, it's pretty clear to anyone following it that he's being gradually integrated into the team after moving to a new club in a new country where he doesn't speak the language only 8 weeks ago.

Thank you for the update. I don't follow other leagues and it seemed that he wasn't getting much game time.

Smarminess is such an unattractive charcteristic imo

 

[Delphinho]

he could be a great prospect. but without good coaching he will never realize his full potential. he is not some great individual talent. he needs a team playing around his strengths like sancho. lets see where he chooses to go.

absolutely not. what is his individual talent. does he dribble like messi? has pace like raheem? is he a physical beast? no to all that. his game relies on passing. he needs a good coach to develop him and set up the team to play the correct passing game.

again that makes no sense. you make no points to contradict me. he has no individual skills on his own to make a difference. he needs a good coach and system to stand out. put him in a burnley side and see what difference mcatee makes. he is not like KDB or Foden who can stand out in any team

palmer has more individual standout qualities than mcatee and that is a fact.

Haha, jesus wept. Did McAtee murder your family or something? If that`s your opinion on him you clearly have never seen him play, so I`d suggest you either educate yourself or stop talking bollocks

 

[r.soleofsalford]

EDS and U18`s players are playing none contact league football. When they go out on loan and have to play in the more physical men`s game of the lower leagues, its very hard for them to adapt.

 

[McfcK]

absolutely not. what is his individual talent. does he dribble like messi? has pace like raheem? is he a physical beast? no to all that. his game relies on passing. he needs a good coach to develop him and set up the team to play the correct passing game.

You could say the exact same about David silva, iniesta, Xavi, Fabregas the list goes on.

 

[McfcK]

nope he is refusing to sign the contract.

As of right now he is. He hasn’t left yet but that’s what it seems like people have already decided is happening.