nobody can eat fifty eggs
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 9 Sep 2011
- Messages
- 4,677
Based on what?Blue Hefner said:
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Joe Hart or Willy Caballero
- Thread starter Zizi4City
- Start date
Blue Hefner said:I think Willy looks shit to be honest
Yeah, beyond me how he didn't save both goals yesterday.
SWP's back
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 29 Jun 2009
- Messages
- 89,078
Why?Blue Hefner said:I think Willy looks shit to be honest
Willy is 33 today. Why the heck are we replacing settled young good gk with newcomer old good gk? We could have a decade more from hart as our team backbone. And it's not as if we're replacing him with renowned world class gk! If it was, say, neuer, we wouldn't be protesting much, but willy caballero??
And that '8games in 32days' seems like weak excuse. All other top gk who play in cl do it without being rotated. Surely hart can handle that much.
And that '8games in 32days' seems like weak excuse. All other top gk who play in cl do it without being rotated. Surely hart can handle that much.
Blue Hefner
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 11 Jul 2009
- Messages
- 14,627
Craig said:Blue Hefner said:I think Willy looks shit to be honest
Yeah, beyond me how he didn't save both goals yesterday.
The parry out into the box didn't fill me with confidence and he was flat footed on a couple of occasions
I also thought he was poor in the Charity Shield
It's early days and I'm hoping he turns out to be very good for us, I'm just not that optimistic
nobody can eat fifty eggs
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 9 Sep 2011
- Messages
- 4,677
Unbelievable.Blue Hefner said:Craig said:Blue Hefner said:I think Willy looks shit to be honest
Yeah, beyond me how he didn't save both goals yesterday.
The parry out into the box didn't fill me with confidence and he was flat footed on a couple of occasions
I also thought he was poor in the Charity Shield
It's early days and I'm hoping he turns out to be very good for us, I'm just not that optimistic
Blue Hefner
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 11 Jul 2009
- Messages
- 14,627
nobody can eat fifty eggs said:Unbelievable.Blue Hefner said:Craig said:Yeah, beyond me how he didn't save both goals yesterday.
The parry out into the box didn't fill me with confidence and he was flat footed on a couple of occasions
I also thought he was poor in the Charity Shield
It's early days and I'm hoping he turns out to be very good for us, I'm just not that optimistic
What exactly is 'unbelievable'?
Could you expand
nowantads said:Willy is 33 today. Why the heck are we replacing settled young good gk with newcomer old good gk? We could have a decade more from hart as our team backbone. And it's not as if we're replacing him with renowned world class gk! If it was, say, neuer, we wouldn't be protesting much, but willy caballero??
And that '8games in 32days' seems like weak excuse. All other top gk who play in cl do it without being rotated. Surely hart can handle that much.
That was just an excuse to give to the media. He wants Caballero to be pushing Hart, doesn't want Hart to think he's safe in the job and that Caballero will only play in the domestic cups. And he wants Caballero to be ready if Hart has another bad spell. But if he says that to the media they'll distort it, make it seem like Hart is barely hanging on to the job.
Its just easier to tell the press that a player needs a rest or has a minor injury.
RACHACE
Well-Known Member
cibaman said:nowantads said:Willy is 33 today. Why the heck are we replacing settled young good gk with newcomer old good gk? We could have a decade more from hart as our team backbone. And it's not as if we're replacing him with renowned world class gk! If it was, say, neuer, we wouldn't be protesting much, but willy caballero??
And that '8games in 32days' seems like weak excuse. All other top gk who play in cl do it without being rotated. Surely hart can handle that much.
That was just an excuse to give to the media. He wants Caballero to be pushing Hart, doesn't want Hart to think he's safe in the job and that Caballero will only play in the domestic cups. And he wants Caballero to be ready if Hart has another bad spell. But if he says that to the media they'll distort it, make it seem like Hart is barely hanging on to the job.
Its just easier to tell the press that a player needs a rest or has a minor injury.
Whatever Pellegrini's reasons are, I personally think he's wrong and he's playing with fire regarding the goalkeeper rotation. Joe Hart comes across confident, sometimes even cocky but goal keepers have confidence fragilities and this will do him no good whatsoever, we could possibly suffer from this.
Like already said, Hart has been our number one for a fair few seasons now, he got the message last season when Pantilimon was put in for a spell but he's not done anything of note that justify's him being on the bench for a Premier League game.
For me your 1st choice keeper plays all the league games & European games too, Caballero will get enough game time in the domestic cups and when Hart is either injured or playing badly. I think from a defensive point of view it could be very dangerous, a settled back 4 and keeper is essential. Kompany will be more that used to having Joe behind him, surely he'd have a period of adjustment having a keeper that he's not used to behind him, different language, different approach to dealing with corners or balls over the top etc. Add to that the rotation at left back between Kolorov and Clichy, plus the introduction of Mangala and it all begins to look a bit strange in my opinion.
Manuel know's best though but I can't help but feel that it's a bit dangerous messing with your keeper.