Joe Hart or Willy Caballero

Len Rum said:
without a dream said:
Len Rum said:
I never criticized him for the Roma goal.
Maybe the case for Krul is arguable.
Aerial ability and distribution are still Joe's major "areas for improvement".

I can only assume you've literally never seen Krul play if you think he's an improvement on Hart in either of those areas.
He isn't an improvement in those areas he's about the same, but his shot stopping ( particularly his reflex saves) is IMO better than Joe's which on balance arguably makes him the better keeper.
Krul is a level below Hart, at least.
 
BlueTG said:
Len Rum said:
without a dream said:
I can only assume you've literally never seen Krul play if you think he's an improvement on Hart in either of those areas.
He isn't an improvement in those areas he's about the same, but his shot stopping ( particularly his reflex saves) is IMO better than Joe's which on balance arguably makes him the better keeper.
Krul is a level below Hart, at least.

That's being kind.

Fans see far more of their own team and analyse their own players in great depth and some are perhaps often over critical.

Len takes it to a different level. I can't believe he thinks the 6 keepers he's mentioned are better than Hart (I'll reserve judgement on Courtois until I've seen how he fairs for a season).

I can only assume that:

A)He's on the Wum
B)Knows nothing about keepers (which I doubt)
C)He's Willy Cabellero


The smart money's on 'A'
 
@BluePhil8 said:
Who plays today?

Hull
15:00
Crystal Palace
Leicester
15:00
Burnley
Liverpool
15:00
West Brom
Sunderland
15:00
Stoke
Swansea
15:00
Newcastle
Aston Villa
17:30
Man City




Blackburn v Huddersfield
Bolton v Bournemouth
Brentford v Reading
Charlton v Birmingham
Derby v Millwall
M'boro v Fulham
Norwich v Rotherham
Watford v Brighton
Wolves v Wigan



Chesterfield3 - 1Sheff Utd
L
BradfordvCrewe
15:00
CoventryvCrawley
15:00
FleetwoodvPort Vale
15:00
Leyton OrientvSwindon
15:00
Notts CountyvGillingham
15:00
PeterboroughvOldham
15:00
PrestonvColchester
15:00
RochdalevBarnsley
15:00
ScunthorpevDoncaster
15:00
WalsallvBristol City
15:00




BuryvTranmere
15:00
CheltenhamvWimbledon
15:00
HartlepoolvCarlisle
15:00
MansfieldvAccrington
15:00
Oxford UtdvNewport
15:00
PlymouthvShrewsbury
15:00
SouthendvMorecambe
15:00
StevenagevLuton
15:00
WycombevNorthampton
15:00

BuryvTranmere
15:00
CheltenhamvWimbledon
15:00
HartlepoolvCarlisle
15:00
MansfieldvAccrington
15:00
Oxford UtdvNewport
15:00
PlymouthvShrewsbury
15:00
SouthendvMorecambe
15:00
StevenagevLuton
15:00
WycombevNorthampton
15:00


AldershotvAlfreton
15:00
BarnetvEastleigh
15:00
Bristol RoversvDover
15:00
ChestervWelling
15:00
DartfordvGrimsby
15:00
HalifaxvAltrincham
15:00
GatesheadvBraintree
15:00
KidderminstervTelford
15:00
MacclesfieldvForest Green
15:00
NuneatonvLincoln City
15:00
SouthportvWoking
15:00



Hope this helps.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.