John Guidetti

[Salar]

Guidetti should never come back to City. Personally if I were him, I'd stay at Feyernord for as long as I could. He is a legend there. Has gotten a bit arrogant though. Now he doesn't celebrate as much with his teammates when he scores anymore.

I watched this video of all his goals somewhere, and the transformation was interesting. From the ecstasy of scoring a penalty early, to celebrating with teammates. Now he pushes them off so he can do the hulk hogan "I can hear my Name" or the love sign. By the last few goals, fewer teammates were running over to celebrate with him, almost as if to say, "we know you have something planned, and we don't want to get in the way of you doing you!"

And not to diss an academy player, he is scoring a lot, but this isn't excess talent producing results. He just seems to be on a hot streak. Anyway either way he is a god over there, he can never be loved here like that, coz he will be at best a parttime starter. That is his talent level.

And players (especially strikers) simply don't get "Pre transfer request Tevez" kind of love, from parttime work. Their is a reason why Dzeko is not a god here.
Guidetti is like Tevez was 2 years ago over there. They love him, and he loves it that they love him.

I hope he stays there. And this has nothing to do with the fact that I know he is not good enough :P

Writing of a great youth prospect at the age of just 19,i thought someone else could have said it but not you Dax not you. sigh.

 

[Daveth]

How can you 'know' how good he will be when he's only 19?

 

[Dax777]

He doesn't want to stay there and has said so, because with Bayern, Milan, Real, and Arsenal all interested he has better prospects ahead whether at City or elsewhere.

Guidetti would be really well liked here, part-time player or not, as academy players always get special affinity from City fans. Even Ireland who trashed the club after leaving got a warm response when he came back with Villa.

He is 19 and can only develop so much in the Eredivisie. His improvement there has been tenfold so who is to say his improvement won't continue in the next stage of his career? Writing 19-year-olds off is ridiculous (may as well close the academy if we do), some of football's best players were on loan at 2nd division clubs at the same age with no extraordinary talent on show. Guidetti is delivering more at the same age than some high profile strikers were.

Not writing him off. Just saying I don't think he is good enough to start here yet. And if he is already chomping to start, better sell, than lose him for nothing.

-- Thu Mar 22, 2012 6:03 pm --

How can you 'know' how good he will be when he's only 19?

I don't know how good he will be. I am talking about how good he is now. At best he is a parttime starter for us now. I.e next season.<br /><br />-- Thu Mar 22, 2012 6:05 pm --<br /><br />

Guidetti should never come back to City. Personally if I were him, I'd stay at Feyernord for as long as I could. He is a legend there. Has gotten a bit arrogant though. Now he doesn't celebrate as much with his teammates when he scores anymore.

I watched this video of all his goals somewhere, and the transformation was interesting. From the ecstasy of scoring a penalty early, to celebrating with teammates. Now he pushes them off so he can do the hulk hogan "I can hear my Name" or the love sign. By the last few goals, fewer teammates were running over to celebrate with him, almost as if to say, "we know you have something planned, and we don't want to get in the way of you doing you!"

And not to diss an academy player, he is scoring a lot, but this isn't excess talent producing results. He just seems to be on a hot streak. Anyway either way he is a god over there, he can never be loved here like that, coz he will be at best a parttime starter. That is his talent level.

And players (especially strikers) simply don't get "Pre transfer request Tevez" kind of love, from parttime work. Their is a reason why Dzeko is not a god here.
Guidetti is like Tevez was 2 years ago over there. They love him, and he loves it that they love him.

I hope he stays there. And this has nothing to do with the fact that I know he is not good enough :P

Writing of a great youth prospect at the age of just 19,i thought someone else could have said it but not you Dax not you. sigh.

I am not writing him off!!!!!!!!

 

[Matt the Giant]

Why Dax... are you writing John G off????


:)


I agree with you by the way: Guidetti is nowhere near good enough to take a place among our regular strikers.

 

[Dax777]

Why Dax... are you writing John G off????


:)


I agree with you by the way: Guidetti is nowhere near good enough to take a place among our regular strikers.

Lol!

 

[jonmcity]

If we are not selling him he needs to go to a top league Spain or another Prem club to prove he can do it at the top table.

 

[avoidconfusion]

I don't understand how you can write him off already Daxx....






























;)

 

[Kurple]

Welbeck is no better than John IMO

 

[alky313]

We really don't know how good talented he is. You can compare goals, leagues and all of that but in the end he needs to play here or in England for that matter.

 

[FantasyIreland]

Welbeck is no better than John IMO

Far too early to make such a comparison/claim - Wellbeck is proven prem quality,besides,John is a completely different player.