Jonny Evans

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thirteen defensive partners for Kompany and counting then.. In your opinion why would Hummels garuntee us missing the title? Do you seriously not rate him?

He is a big strong player great on the ball, great in the air & turns like a battleship.

The way we play, we would have to partner him with Usain Bolt, just to get a draw. Jonny Evans is like The Flash compared to him.
 
At times he had nobody, but still won the ball or held up the player, until they got back.

Barry by the way, had far better defenders around him, than we have now, but still got left for dead in europe.

He did mate, no argument there. But look at the teams we played and groups we were in compared to the ones Fernandinho has been up against.

I will not belittle Lescott contribution to us as he played a key part. Bobby had that team set up perfectly, power pace and the sublime genius of Yaya and Silva. The balance was perfect and that was down to the sum rather than the individual parts.

Good job we managed to sign Bernardo and not the rags. They now have the power and pace. Thankfully they have no sublime genius.
 
He did mate, no argument there. But look at the teams we played and groups we were in compared to the ones Fernandinho has been up against.

I will not belittle Lescott contribution to us as he played a key part. Bobby had that team set up perfectly, power pace and the sublime genius of Yaya and Silva. The balance was perfect and that was down to the sum rather than the individual parts.

Good job we managed to sign Bernardo and not the rags. They now have the power and pace. Thankfully they have no sublime genius.

Not tall enough for Utd.
 
He is a big strong player great on the ball, great in the air & turns like a battleship.

The way we play, we would have to partner him with Usain Bolt, just to get a draw. Jonny Evans is like The Flash compared to him.

Surely having Mendy and Walker and or Danilo and Sane and Sterling with the ability of the rest of the team to move the ball around so fast his defensive ability would be the rock the creative freedom is built upon. I guess we just have different priorities for what a central defender should be and as you clearly state his great attributes I dont see how his great ability on the ball and ability to win headers wouldnt benefit our counter attacking or more general attacking style.

Too be honest for the most part this season i see whichever one of the back 3 is unfortunately told to stay on the half way line as we will be battering teams that much that the other two centre halfs will be doing a David James.
 
Surely having Mendy and Walker and or Danilo and Sane and Sterling with the ability of the rest of the team to move the ball around so fast his defensive ability would be the rock the creative freedom is built upon. I guess we just have different priorities for what a central defender should be and as you clearly state his great attributes I dont see how his great ability on the ball and ability to win headers wouldnt benefit our counter attacking or more general attacking style.

When I've seen him in recent times, he's looked a liability to me.
 
When I've seen him in recent times, he's looked a liability to me.

Dont forget my original argument asked why from Hughes to Pep have we had 13 partners for Kompany yet Hummels seems never really to have been in contention even though he is a world cup winner and Bundesliga winner and a Champions League runner up.

Not to mention his price would not have been crazy, what have the 13 other centre halfs cost?
 
Dont forget my original argument asked why from Hughes to Pep have we had 13 partners for Kompany yet Hummels seems never really to have been in contention even though he is a world cup winner and Bundesliga winner and a Champions League runner up.

Not to mention his price would not have been crazy, what have the 13 other centre halfs cost?

I doubt he would have been worse, but imo, he would get his arse torn out over here, in an attacking team anyhow. Teams here go straight for the throat, as we found out with our pedestrian cbs last season.

Ok in a deep sitting team.
 
I did a while back. Clearly it didn't take off. Not sure why? ;-)

This is how it feels to be City
This is how it feels to be small
You sign Phil Jones
We sign who you let go, who you let go
shouldn't it be, "we sign whom you let go, whom you let go"?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top