Kalvin Phillips | Joins City on a 6-year deal

Status
Not open for further replies.
Rice and his camp have wanted Chelsea to move in for 3 windows now. United have asked and gotten put on the long finger.

If Pep called rice would run, but there’s very little interest our end due to money and expectations of playing time considering Rodri is our guy.
I think Rice would turn us down for Chelsea if he had offers from both. Sure we are a better and more attractive club for almost any player, but the difference between our clubs is not big enough for him to turn his boyhood club down. Chelsea may not be on the same level as us, but they are not exactly Leeds, Villa or even Spurs/Arsenal. They won a CL just a year ago. I could be wrong of course, but thats my guess:)
 
I think Rice would turn us down for Chelsea if he had offers from both. Sure we are a better and more attractive for almost any player, but the difference between our clubs is not big enough for him to turn his boyhood club down. Chelsea may not be on the same level as us, but they are not exactly Leeds, Villa or even Spurs/Arsenal. They won a CL just a year ago. I could be wrong of course, but thats my guess:)

As I said, they are waiting. But they can’t wait forever and Rice thought he’d be in Chelsea blue by now. Agents were all throwing potential replacements at west ham but a bid never materialized.
 
Apart from anything he is currently injury prone and not worth it for this alone. Feels like it would be a similar transfer to Delph where he is unreliable to be fit.
 
Gus taking over another transfer thread I see…

Surely we’re past caring who United sign? Everytime they sign someone we get the ‘fuck he’ll actually improve them’ only for United to completely destroy said player.

We even had people say Ragnick appointment was worrying as he’d actually improve them, that went well.

Law of averages say at some point something will click I guess but I’m not remotely worried about them signing FDJ or Rice.
 
If you guys don’t want him he can stay where he’s appreciated.

Honestly I think he’d be great cover for Rodri and would suit your system very well. If he has to leave I think City would be the most tolerable destination (compared to say the rags). Problem of course is he’s worth more to us than he would be to you.
I think he'd be a quality signing for us. He's already a very good player and I've no doubt given 18 months / 2 years he'd go up another level once Pep has worked with him.

Ignore some on here. No doubt some thought we overpaid for the likes of Stones, Walker, Dias etc too.

The cost doesn't really concern me. If City are willing to pay £50m-£60m and Pep wants him then that'll do for me.
 
Funnily enough if Pep wants the bloke so do I. Really some on here got to stop playing Championship manager

I think this is largely where I am. In the last recruitment has frustrated me, particularly last summer but ultimately the club have earned the right to pursue and do what they want. They're the elite club in the country and their policy always works.

They deserve our full trust.
 
Doyle for me is far better than Lavia
I'd honestly rather we buy nobody if neither of them are ready, I should have clarified. Doyle is more proven at senior level, whilst Lavia from what I hear has the higher ceiling but that's all opinions and predictions with young players. All I know is, Phillips could physically do a job for us(proved that much under Bielsa and with England) but I'm not really sure how much Pep could improve him, the more I think about it. He just doesn't seem a very technical player, that's not to say he's a bad player.

If Pep does want him though, I'm not going to complain, he's earned the right to make some calls like this. Hope we don't pay over the odds for him though.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.