Kompany red card and appeal SUCCESSFUL
- Thread starter SuperYaya
- Start date
bojinov29
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
do we have any idea on when a decision will be announced?
do we have any idea on when a decision will be announced?
Manc Born & Bred
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 7 Nov 2005
- Messages
- 11,684
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
Apart from arse licking red sympathisers everyone has said it was never a red and should be overturned but Sky start talking about it being frivolous. Oops forgot they are part of the arse licking.........
Apart from arse licking red sympathisers everyone has said it was never a red and should be overturned but Sky start talking about it being frivolous. Oops forgot they are part of the arse licking.........
A
A
Anonymous
Guest
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
Just seen another angle, wiltshere points at kompany and holds up two fingers to signal a two footed challenge.
Little twat.
Just seen another angle, wiltshere points at kompany and holds up two fingers to signal a two footed challenge.
Little twat.
Big Dave Watson
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 25 Aug 2009
- Messages
- 2,417
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
Definately wont be considered as a frivolous appeal as City genuinely believe a mistake has been made.
An example of a frivolous appeal was when Camel Gob appealed even though there was footage of him punching another player. The scum appealed so that Camel Gob would be available for their next game while the appeal was heard (cant remember which game). He was banged to rights so correctly got a 4th game on his ban for a frivolous appeal.
Definately wont be considered as a frivolous appeal as City genuinely believe a mistake has been made.
An example of a frivolous appeal was when Camel Gob appealed even though there was footage of him punching another player. The scum appealed so that Camel Gob would be available for their next game while the appeal was heard (cant remember which game). He was banged to rights so correctly got a 4th game on his ban for a frivolous appeal.
SWP's back
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 29 Jun 2009
- Messages
- 90,474
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
CC semi at OT against US!Big Dave Watson said:
MSP
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
Daily Mail adding deliberate pressure on FA claiming they have info it won't be rescinded and mentioning Souness and Redknapp backed Dean's decision.
However, no word about Schmeichel's and Hansen's thoughts.
Daily Mail adding deliberate pressure on FA claiming they have info it won't be rescinded and mentioning Souness and Redknapp backed Dean's decision.
However, no word about Schmeichel's and Hansen's thoughts.
MCFC BOB
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
Probably because the article gets published before Match of the Day airs.MSP said:
BoyBlue_1985
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
If the FA feels pressure from the Mail then really the human race has no hope. I would be shocked if they even read it or cared what any other fucker thinks when they come to the decision of whether the ref was correct or not
MSP said:
If the FA feels pressure from the Mail then really the human race has no hope. I would be shocked if they even read it or cared what any other fucker thinks when they come to the decision of whether the ref was correct or not
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
I doubt that the ban will be overturned, but it would be quite wrong for it to be deemed frivolous. Bans really should only be deemed frivolous if clubs play the system to avoid the player missing a particular match.
In an ideal world whenever a player is sent off the incident should be reviewed and the appropriate ban added to the punishment already incurred by virtue of the player being sent off. For practical reasons the FA doesn't do that but imposes automatic bans. That's fine, but such a system should also include a rigorous appeals process. The system shouldn't bully clubs into not appealing.
Kompany's challenge was borderline and he was sent off by a referee viewing the incident in real time. Its in the wider interest of the game that the challenge is reviewed and its legitimcy confirmed one way or the other. That would establish a basis for consistent decision making in the future. If the sending off isnt reviewed then it effectively establishes a benchmark which may or not be correct.
I doubt that the ban will be overturned, but it would be quite wrong for it to be deemed frivolous. Bans really should only be deemed frivolous if clubs play the system to avoid the player missing a particular match.
In an ideal world whenever a player is sent off the incident should be reviewed and the appropriate ban added to the punishment already incurred by virtue of the player being sent off. For practical reasons the FA doesn't do that but imposes automatic bans. That's fine, but such a system should also include a rigorous appeals process. The system shouldn't bully clubs into not appealing.
Kompany's challenge was borderline and he was sent off by a referee viewing the incident in real time. Its in the wider interest of the game that the challenge is reviewed and its legitimcy confirmed one way or the other. That would establish a basis for consistent decision making in the future. If the sending off isnt reviewed then it effectively establishes a benchmark which may or not be correct.
bojinov29
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
hearing tomorrow according to stuart brennan from twitter
hearing tomorrow according to stuart brennan from twitter
City Raider
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
our only hope was dean changing his mind after looking at it again, if there's a hearing - he hasn't
bojinov29 said:
our only hope was dean changing his mind after looking at it again, if there's a hearing - he hasn't
Vincents Tackle
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
I knew the day would come when my name would become significant on here.
I knew the day would come when my name would become significant on here.
Mr Ed (The Stables)
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
Time for Miss Moneypenny to get agent 009 on the case, the name is Bernstein, David Bernstein.
City Raider said:
Time for Miss Moneypenny to get agent 009 on the case, the name is Bernstein, David Bernstein.
nobody can eat fifty eggs
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 9 Sep 2011
- Messages
- 4,677
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
Let's cross our fingers for tomorrow.....and if unsuccessful, gradually unfurl the two fingers and stick em up to the FA.
Let's cross our fingers for tomorrow.....and if unsuccessful, gradually unfurl the two fingers and stick em up to the FA.
rushts
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
So the Rag loving FA have an opportunity to hand our captain a four match ban and you think they're not going to take it??
So the Rag loving FA have an opportunity to hand our captain a four match ban and you think they're not going to take it??
Bill
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
it will stay at three, that'll do them.
rushts said:
it will stay at three, that'll do them.
Hamann Pineapple
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
MATCITY said: