Kompany red card and appeal SUCCESSFUL
- Thread starter SuperYaya
- Start date
otherwise
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
As far as I could find this is the rule
"A player who jumps into a tackle two-footed is not in control of himself and therefore if he makes contact with the player, ball and player, or if the referee determines there to be excessive malice in the challenge, he will be dismissed"
It clearly shows from the side view that it wasn't a 2 footed tackle (1 footed, he hit the ball, the other player fell over by himself and I don't think there was malice). It should be overtuned. The ref had a poor view of it. It probably won't happen though.
I don't know why they would look at any other view, side view shows what happened best. The ref was at a poor angle to see what actually happened. Not his fault you can't be in the best place at all times.
As far as I could find this is the rule
"A player who jumps into a tackle two-footed is not in control of himself and therefore if he makes contact with the player, ball and player, or if the referee determines there to be excessive malice in the challenge, he will be dismissed"
It clearly shows from the side view that it wasn't a 2 footed tackle (1 footed, he hit the ball, the other player fell over by himself and I don't think there was malice). It should be overtuned. The ref had a poor view of it. It probably won't happen though.
I don't know why they would look at any other view, side view shows what happened best. The ref was at a poor angle to see what actually happened. Not his fault you can't be in the best place at all times.
welsh_andy
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
thats a bloody good point tbhPrestwich_Blue said:
B
B
blueinsa
Guest
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
I honestly think dean will have a look and say he got it wrong as well.
I honestly think dean will have a look and say he got it wrong as well.
deano ou812
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
When will we find out if sucessful or not with vinnie's appeal?
When will we find out if sucessful or not with vinnie's appeal?
Joga Bonito
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 21 Sep 2009
- Messages
- 2,585
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
Appeal
Appeal
Gabriel
Well-Known Member
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
All this hot air on Sky about it being a red card from different angles when one clearly shows it was not. In other sports,when they use video evidence, they look for the one example which shows that the try was scored, the ball was caught, the serve was in etc. Why on earth do we have to see three obscure angles when one shows one foot leading and winning the ball.
All this hot air on Sky about it being a red card from different angles when one clearly shows it was not. In other sports,when they use video evidence, they look for the one example which shows that the try was scored, the ball was caught, the serve was in etc. Why on earth do we have to see three obscure angles when one shows one foot leading and winning the ball.
B
B
blueinsa
Guest
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
Unfortunately, sky want him banned, it makes for good headlines and they can milk it for a few days.
Gabriel said:
Unfortunately, sky want him banned, it makes for good headlines and they can milk it for a few days.
Manc in London
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 6 Aug 2008
- Messages
- 8,493
Re: Kompany red card and appeal
The Bassong challenge on Nasri was far worse.
Regardless of whether it was a red or not, Vinny did not need to make such a challenge and give the ref the option to send him off.
The Bassong challenge on Nasri was far worse.
Regardless of whether it was a red or not, Vinny did not need to make such a challenge and give the ref the option to send him off.