Kylian Mbappe

Status
Not open for further replies.
Top player but we are sorted in attack.I agree with Tevez City that attack has been a problem, but Sane and Jesus have since come in. I don't see us buying any forwards unless Aguero goes, and even then it's unlikely to be a top player as Jesus is nailed on to start
 
Dax777 said:
its not an either or proposition. And as A matter of fact attack is not the least our worries. Of all the teams in Europe that create chances at the rate we do, we are one of the lowest scoring: So attack is more of a need than people claim.

We will buy 2 fullbacks, maybe a goalie, after that Mbappe is as important as anyone else.

We will definitely get 4 players in. LB, RB, Keeper, then Mbappe could be targeted.
If we get
Ederson
Grimaldo
Perreira
Kimich
Isco
Mbappe.

I'll guarantee the league.
Click to expand...

The idea about priority was simply aboutwhat we are in more desperate need of

Would i not want mbappe ....of course not but he alone wont make a difference. We need that keeper and defenders....without them we wont win anything
 
Mourinho has made Kylian Mbappe his number one transfer target, ahead of Antoine Griezmann. [reports via men]. #mufc
 
simon23 said:
The idea about priority was simply aboutwhat we are in more desperate need of

Would i not want mbappe ....of course not but he alone wont make a difference. We need that keeper and defenders....without them we wont win anything
Click to expand...
I don't disagree. On saying we will get at least 4 players this summer. Mbappe should be 1 of the 4.
 
Dax777 said:
I don't disagree. On saying we will get at least 4 players this summer. Mbappe should be 1 of the 4.
Click to expand...
Can't agree tbh, he'd cost a fucking fortune and not even make our best 11. We've got bigger priorities, especially with Jesus coming back
 
Dax777 said:
I don't disagree. On saying we will get at least 4 players this summer. Mbappe should be 1 of the 4.
Click to expand...

i think we need more than 4

at least two full backs and at least one centre half if not 2 and a goal keeper.

Thats before you factor in the Yaya situation....if he leaves we need another midfielder and then Mbappe is the icing on the cake (along with Isco!)
 
Marvin said:
Top player but we are sorted in attack.I agree with Tevez City that attack has been a problem, but Sane and Jesus have since come in. I don't see us buying any forwards unless Aguero goes, and even then it's unlikely to be a top player as Jesus is nailed on to start
Click to expand...
Are we? If I were a betting man, I'd say Aguero goes and you bring in Mbappe

Jesus, Sane, Sterling, Mbappe. Rotate the 4 and interchange them. Buy an older backup striker with Size you can bring in late as a long ball option. Then we'll be set.

Sane and Sterling should work in the summer on improving their finishing. Now you have 4 players all likely to score 15 or more.
 
simon23 said:
i think we need more than 4

at least two full backs and at least one centre half if not 2 and a goal keeper.

Thats before you factor in the Yaya situation....if he leaves we need another midfielder and then Mbappe is the icing on the cake (along with Isco!)
Click to expand...
I agree it will be more, I'm simply saying outside of fullback, none of the other positions are any more important than the others. Keeper if Willy is not resigned. But CB, CM etc are actually not more important than forward.
 
BigOscar said:
Can't agree tbh, he'd cost a fucking fortune and not even make our best 11. We've got bigger priorities, especially with Jesus coming back
Click to expand...
We need a core 15, not 11. And I think he'll make the 11 by the way. Just don't want to suggest who he'll beat out. Thays the shot that gets me in trouble here :p

So now I just suggest who will should get. Once they become a City player the rest works itself out.
 
Dax777 said:
We need a core 15, not 11. And I think he'll make the 11 by the way. Just don't want to suggest who he'll beat out. Thays the shot that gets me in trouble here :p

So now I just suggest who will should get. Once they become a City player the rest works itself out.
Click to expand...
My top 4 players would be Weigl (or someone to do that job), 2 fullbacks and a keeper. That's all for the starting 11 and absolutely crucial. Once that's sorted out, we can look at luxuries like depth in the wide/striker areas, but for me the biggest difference will come from getting the midfield and fullback areas right. Mbappe would be a very expensive icing on the cake, that I don't think we need. If we sell Aguero then it's different, but that wouldn't be anywhere near as high on my list of priorities as the other areas (as we are absolutely desperate for those other 4 positions)
 
BigOscar said:
My top 4 players would be Weigl (or someone to do that job), 2 fullbacks and a keeper. That's all for the starting 11 and absolutely crucial. Once that's sorted out, we can look at luxuries like depth in the wide/striker areas, but for me the biggest difference will come from getting the midfield and fullback areas right. Mbappe would be a very expensive icing on the cake, that I don't think we need. If we sell Aguero then it's different, but that wouldn't be anywhere near as high on my list of priorities as the other areas (as we are absolutely desperate for those other 4 positions)
Click to expand...
You are right. At this time and based on who is out of contract and projected needs, I'd agree we need the 4 you mentioned. Don't think we need a DM though as a starter. In the current middle 3, we simply replace Yaya with Gundogan. Garcia replaces Nando and Delph. We add Isco and we are set at midfield. With 6 players.


Fullback and Goalie are the only real needs. An LB, an RB and a Goalie decision.. And our starting 11 is set.
 
Dax777 said:
You are right. At this time and based on who is out of contract and projected needs, I'd agree we need the 4 you mentioned. Don't think we need a DM though as a starter. In the current middle 3, we simply replace Yaya with Gundogan. Garcia replaces Nando and Delph. We add Isco and we are set at midfield. With 6 players.


Fullback and Goalie are the only real needs. An LB, an RB and a Goalie decision.. And our starting 11 is set.
Click to expand...


I like to read your post Dax - but Central defence must also be an absolute must - We need someone with the leadership qualities of Komps to play alongside stones, wish it was komps but afraid he is gone and Otta is just not good enough for prem as ill disciplined positionally. Other than that I agree, I do think we will let Aguero go and another forward will come in (hope I'm wrong).
 
onceabluealways said:
I like to read your post Dax - but Central defence must also be an absolute must - We need someone with the leadership qualities of Komps to play alongside stones, wish it was komps but afraid he is gone and Otta is just not good enough for prem as ill disciplined positionally. Other than that I agree, I do think we will let Aguero go and another forward will come in (hope I'm wrong).
Click to expand...
I think Ota is grossly underrated. I know I'm amongst a very few who think he is very good. But I reckon with fuctional fullbacks Stones, Otamendi and Kolarov will be very good Centerbacks. Stones is the leader of that defense. Kolarov and Ota may be more Senior but Stones is its leader.

Leading comes to him more naturally. So I'm not so worried about CB unless we are looking for an Left footed upgrade to Kolarov. I don't think we need one.
 
Saw some footage of him (I think it was against Caen) and he's absolutely rapid, just shrugging off players whilst dribbling at full speed. Reminded me a bit of that Ronaldo goal where the defenders were pulling him back and he doesn't even break a sweat. That being said, I still think we should reinforce the defence and try and get Sanchez on the cheap/pre-contract and see how the kid pans out. We might have to pay an extra £30mil later, but he's 18, no-one knows how he'd handle the pressure.

On a side-note, would people say he's still developing physically?
 
Think He is soooo good and he is only 18. I think we need to go for him , just imagine him with Sane, Sterling and Jesus. But in my opinion he will replace Benzeme in Real Madrid
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top