franksinatra
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 25 Nov 2008
- Messages
- 10,648
sir baconface said:franksinatra said:Just having read the last couple of posts the reasons for signing him have become even more nonsenscial.
He will play in the early rounds of the Cup: Why would we want him too? Why should he block the opportunity for a Huws or a Zucculini? Is this really justification for paying his wages and blocking a place in the squad of a talented youngster?
He is an influence in the dressing room/role model for the youngsters: On the basis of what? Why don't Chelsea keep him as a role model then? Do City not have enough good role models such as Zaba, Kompany, Silva, Aguero etc. Ridiculous assertion to suggest we would pay him to act as a role model.
For me it is a poor move and gives more justification to the argument that City do not give opportunities to youngsters. Furthermore it is a slap in the face to the likes of Milner and Rodwell and will probably hasten their departures from the club.
By all earlier accounts, Zuculini was earmarked for a European loan well before the Lampard news.
For me it's a great piece of opportunism on the part of the club. He's become available on an internal loan so why not take advantage? A decent guy and a top pro with huge experience.
We'll be grateful in the event of availability problems in midfield through injury, suspension, ACON or loss of form.
Personally I think it is a shame. I am not sure just stockpiling players to cover every eventuality is the correct way forward. We have enough back up players already and if we do get some spare capacity to use younger players, the fact that Lampard is here will block this.
It seems a long time since a kid came through at City, probably Danny Sturridge and he has made his name elsewhere. It may be a fair argument the kids are not good enough in comparison to other sides, but our record in comparison to others is appalling. I am not sure how the signing of Lampard would encourage any promising young player to sign for City nor watching the likes of Rodwell, Milner, Nastasic pushed further back in the pecking order by new signings.