As someone that does pop on there (probably more frequently than is healthy) I recognise all these factors, but these really stood out to me:
- There is a degree of intellectual limitation, so outside ideas or interaction with non members are not encouraged Definitely no outside ideas allowed
- There is also a system of repercussions, such as shunning, "time out" or isolating or demotion. RAWK bans and threads locked
- There is a system of development, so a person may be groomed or encouraged to go towards certain roles, or assist in various ways. There's all the levels on RAWK - Legacy Fan, Kopite, Main Stander - depending on the number of posts
There is zero tolerance of any alternative views being posted and if someone does stray - even slightly - then it is like the 'special agents' are summoned and they are resoundingly hounded until they are off the thread or banned - or they offer a full retraction (in which case they are on a form of probation until they have been proven to be sufficiently subservient)
It is really sickening behaviour and not something I have seen any other fans forums - at least not on mainstream football threads