I didn't see anyone complaining about him overthinking when he played phil foden as a false 9 for the first time in his career against real Madrid in the biggest game of the season.
Or when he played KDB and Bernardo up front in a weird 442 against United and we humiliated him.
Playing Gundogan on the right had absolutely no bearing on the game we lost to Liverpool in 2018, bug individual mistakes in the back 4 ended that game before we ever got the chance to see what Pep was trying to do - apart from us being well on top before Walker fell over clearing a simple ball and passed it to Salah.
The "overthinking" line is just a really lazy and tired narrative pushed by the media and sadly picked up by some fans.
We lose games in our default 433 as well.