Man City's tactic, similar to Barca's?

Akira

Well-Known Member
Joined
10 Aug 2010
Messages
5,956
Last night, I watched a replay of the Panathinakos VS Barcelona Champions League match. As always, Barca played beautiful passing and provided a great flow towards their play. As I watched on, it suddenly struck me, "This is TOO similar to the City team at Fulham."

Which reminded me of a past blog post by someone analyzing Mark Hughes attempted 4-3-3 with Robinho, Ade and Tevez as the trident tip and the shape of the team being emulative towards Pep's formation. And it has been rumored this was the Shiekh's wish.

Then, I drew back to the Fulham game, the movement of our team is CLOSE to EXACT of Barcelona's. Taking man for man:

-------------Hart-------------
Zaba---Kolo---Kompany--Kolarov
---------De Jong-----------
------Yaya---------Barry------
---Silva----Tevez----Jo----


------------V.Valdes-----------
D.Alves---Pique---Puyol---Adriano
---------Mascherano--------
------Xavi---------Iniesta-----
---Messi----Villa----Pedro---

The movement was similar to Barca, taking Fulham's for example:

Like Alves, Zaba constantly bombs forward, occasionally cutting in for the extra man. Like Adriano, Kolarov again constantly bombs forward, giving the low cross or long shot. We do not have a centre forward of Pique's mould who would play the ball forward creatively, but we have a great defensive lineup.

NDJ and Mash, needless to say, both play the same style. Xavi acts as the passer, which is the role fufiled by Barry. Iniesta is the driving force of the team, playing the advanced role, which Yaya was made to play.

Silva plays very similarly to Messi, always drifting into different positions and provided the creative outlet. Jo, probably not exactly the Pedro role where Pedro is the inside forward, cuz Jo's left footed, but he's still a forward. And replacing Jo with Balo, we have the exact player. Tevez, is just like Villa, 'nuff said.

Taking this all into consideration, is it ACTUALLY the Shiekh's wish to emulate Barca? Am I even right to say we're going to play Barca's brand of football? I dunno, but if that's the case, we have an exciting squad in our hands. What do you Bluemooners think?

Cheers & CTID.

EDIT: Okay, maybe I gotta emphasize. I'm just comparing the shape and formation, NOT the quality nor the stature. This is more like a "we are gonna try and play like Barca rather than, we are Barca thing." Cheers.
 
We are a million miles off the likes of Barcelona, lets not kid ourselves.
 
Julie said:
We are a million miles off the likes of Barcelona, lets not kid ourselves.



i dont think he is saying we are as good as them or anything like that, just that our formation and players roles within it are similair to barca's.
 
Yeah comparing any prem team to Barcelona or Madrid right now is silly, both those clubs are far superior to anything in this league.
 
i couldnt stop smiling when i was comparing the 2 teams :) ...
maybe both teams have similar tactics but the gap in the quality of the players is huge lol .. city still needs more time ..

(Pique / puyol) > (kompany / toure)
(all day ..even though kompany is a beast but i would get pique in a heartbeat hes the best CB in the world .. and i think no one would argue puyol > toure )

(Xavi / Iniesta) >>> (Yaya / Barry)

no comment lol
 
b2b said:
i couldnt stop smiling when i was comparing the 2 teams :) ...
maybe both teams have similar tactics but the gap in the quality of the players is huge lol .. city still needs more time ..

(Pique / puyol) > (kompany / toure)
(all day ..even though kompany is a beast but i would get pique in a heartbeat hes the best CB in the world .. and i think no one would argue puyol > toure )

(Xavi / Iniesta) >>> (Yaya / Barry)

no comment lol

I'd have Kompany quicker than a heartbeat.
 
jonmcity said:
------Yaya---------Barry------

theory went wrong here

Dude, I was comparing the team at Fulham with Barca's team at Panak, do you even understand what I'm saying?
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.