Mancini

Status
Not open for further replies.
AlthamBlue said:
FantasyIreland said:
Marvin said:
Winning the Premier League was an enormous achievement for City and Mancini and it's shocking to see how quickly it's all forgotten and dismissed

Quite the opposite mate.

The fact we are reigning Champions and are surrendering the title in such a gutless way is why many of us are fuming - its soul destroying.

This is the issue. I said it during the match. I can handle defeat. It's the piss poor performances and the lack of fight that fucks me off.

Yes, as well as playing systems (3-5-2 anyone?) that we don't have the personnel to play, and which the players don't even understand. FFS, Bobby was drilling them in this system by playing it at the Bernabeu in CL group fixture !!!
 
Blue Heaven said:
smithy167 said:
BillyShears said:
Mancini left St Mary's without talking to a single player or going in the dressing room. That's tragic.
Prove it then.

No, you prove him wrong, and your sourcing for your info had better be impeccable.

I don't think that's the way it works, otherwise I could come out and say anything (e.g. Garcia was angry with Tevez after the game and punched him) and you would have to prove it wasn't true before anyone could say it was bullshit.
 
Pam said:
People should calm down, The title was lost weeks ago. Lets concentrate on the one trophy we can win. The FA Cup can salvage our season.

An FA cup win will be amazing but it will not salavage a shambolic league and European campaign.

Feel free to pretend otherwise.
 
Interesting quote from Mario today:

"I rarely hear from Mancini. I had fouled someone and he got angry, that’s all. We made up afterwards. Who do I prefer between Mancini and Mourinho? As a person Mancini, in football terms Mourinho."
 
smithy167 said:
Managers are judged on trophies won, not individual losses, get it?

I actually don't think you get it. Managers are judged on what they accomplish with what they have.

If they were judged on trophies, there would be, at most, three or four incumbent managers each season. Now we know why your logic is so flawed, you have a totally backwards view of reality.
 
Marvin said:
FantasyIreland said:
Marvin said:
Winning the Premier League was an enormous achievement for City and Mancini and it's shocking to see how quickly it's all forgotten and dismissed

Quite the opposite mate.

The fact we are reigning Champions and are surrendering the title in such a gutless way is why many of us are fuming - its soul destroying.
Again we're 2nd not mid-table. Today was very disappointing but the reasons why we are lost can't all be lain at Mancini's door

Bobby is the main culprit, but you're correct that we have many players who are also to blame, due to lack of effort, etc. Maybe this is why at season's end, there will be a MASSIVE clearout which will include Bobby and staff, and 5-7 players as well.
 
Pam said:
People should calm down, The title was lost weeks ago. Lets concentrate on the one trophy we can win. The FA Cup can salvage our season.

We're not going to win the FA Cup Pam. All confidence has been lost I'm afraid. Our cup run this season has been Watford, Leeds and Barnsley. I can't see us beating Chelsea/that lot.
 
Marvin said:
Winning the Premier League was an enormous achievement for City and Mancini and it's shocking to see how quickly it's all forgotten and dismissed
To be fair Marvin, its not forgotten, but it is history now, and looking at this season, we have gone backwards points wise, it can't be denied, no matter how much anyone likes or dislikes Mancini.

His team selection today was bizarre, there is no need to rotate anyone now, you pick your best team, and certainly your strongest available defence, especially at Everton, he failed to do that, and must cop some criticisim. On top of that as many have already pointed out, this "everton" thing is a painful problem, in all his time here, and he doesn't learn from it, and its not just everton. There comes a time when either he learns how to get it right with what's available to him, or he's gone as far as he can.

As soon as I saw the team, I feared the worst today, even more than I already had anyway, with it being Everton.
 
LoveCity said:
Interesting quote from Mario today:

"I rarely hear from Mancini. I had fouled someone and he got angry, that’s all. We made up afterwards. Who do I prefer between Mancini and Mourinho? As a person Mancini, in football terms Mourinho."

Mario isnt as daft as he acts after all......
 
Dethred said:
smithy167 said:
Managers are judged on trophies won, not individual losses, get it?

I actually don't think you get it. Managers are judged on what they accomplish with what they have.

If they were judged on trophies, there would be, at most, three or four incumbent managers each season. Now we know why your logic is so flawed, you have a totally backwards view of reality.
Managers at top clubs are judged on what they win no flawed logic, no reality bullshit thats how it is.
 
not read the thread...id imagine its just like it is most weeks...with afew more fence sitters realising that he isnt the man to take us forward

yes, it is also the players fault...but its not possible for so many class players to play this badly.

the tele clappers will respond with "his name was sang loud today" which means fuck all, as mancini is starting to lose the faith of even his biggest fans who follow us away
 
Dethred said:
Yet they're where in Europe? Oh that's right, they're IN EUROPE I believe there are other trophies on the cards for them as well. We've got a chance at the FA cup after failing miserably everywhere else... and spent more money to get here.

And the most ironic thing is that you suggest we need to re-shuffle the squad to achieve a new Manager's ambitions... Yet there is probably going to be a massive clearing out in the summer under Mancini.

So you suggest re-shuffling the squad only, and risk all the money that task requires... on a manager that has won us 3 wins out of 12 games in Europe, each of them rather meaningless. So what happens if we re-shuffle and are in the same fucking position this time next season? Sack Mancini and to a second consecutive shuffle? Good thing you don't own a business, because you would fail.

Any sane person with money on the line would not risk it. It would be much less risky to swap to a manager proven in European competitions, before doing this clear-out that's going to happen anyways.
So you would rather be in the champions league but 20 points behind the rags?

The "reshuffle" under Mancini will be a lot less extreme than what it would be under the other managers. Besides you will see this summer players brought in that Mancini may not have bought himself. Txiki isn't going to go out and spend money just on everyone Mancini want's. He will put his own stamp on the team.

Yes, what does happen if we re-shuffle by clearing out Dzeko, Nasri, Kolarov, Tevez, Barry, Milner and Mancini and replace them with Klopp and his backroom staff and another 150m on "his" players and we are in the "same fucking position this time next season".

Do we sack him?
 
Nothing should save Mancini, not even FA Cup.

The way how this team is inconsistent and how much it regressed from last season is appalling and if he keeps his job he probably knows some SM's secrets.

When other clubs, much weaker, have zero respect on the pitch to league champions with as quality squad as City are , than it's sign for all alarms. And that's exactly what's happening this year. Nobody doesn't give a shit who City are and think that they could take some points in those matches.
 
117 M34 said:
Blue Heaven said:
smithy167 said:
Prove it then.

No, you prove him wrong, and your sourcing for your info had better be impeccable.

I don't think that's the way it works, otherwise I could come out and say anything (e.g. Garcia was angry with Tevez after the game and punched him) and you would have to prove it wasn't true before anyone could say it was bullshit.

"Prove it then" is a standard tactic utilized to discredit anything claimed that anyone disagrees with. Global warming? Think it's true? Then prove it by citing the studies and computer modelling results and demonstrating exactly how that conclusion is justified. Would you be up for that? Neil Armstrong walked on the Moon? Prove then that it wasn't a simulation, as some claimed, filmed in a Hollywood studio...
 
smithy167 said:
sniff said:
smithy167 said:
While Mancini has been in charge, how many trophies have we won?

Its not really a realistic comparison is it... in fact its just plain silly.. Everton are an outside chance if they play at the top of their game and a genuine top side has an off day, they are in with a shout... on the other hand you have imo the best team in the leauge...

see the point
Managers are judged on trophies won, not individual losses, get it?

A very good point.
 
117 M34 said:
Blue Heaven said:
smithy167 said:
Prove it then.

No, you prove him wrong, and your sourcing for your info had better be impeccable.

I don't think that's the way it works, otherwise I could come out and say anything (e.g. Garcia was angry with Tevez after the game and punched him) and you would have to prove it wasn't true before anyone could say it was bullshit.
Or what blueheathen i dont have to prove anything billy shears come out with this bullshit statement he needs to prove it, but i call bullshit on it not for the first time either
 
FantasyIreland said:
samharris said:
FantasyIreland said:
While Mancini has been in charge,how many times have we played Everton now? and how many times have they embarrassed us with the same approach?

Played 7 won 1 drawn 1 lost 5....

yet in that time,what have Everton won ???

My point is about our(CITY...) approach,mindset and tactics.

I couldnt give a fuck about Everton,just City and only City.

Two years ago at Everton we put on the best first half display I have ever seen City do at an away game, yet we still lost the game to an Everton side going all guns blazing cos beating City is their cup final.

Shit happens,but mainly against Everton.
 
smithy167 said:
Dethred said:
smithy167 said:
Managers are judged on trophies won, not individual losses, get it?

I actually don't think you get it. Managers are judged on what they accomplish with what they have.

If they were judged on trophies, there would be, at most, three or four incumbent managers each season. Now we know why your logic is so flawed, you have a totally backwards view of reality.
Managers at top clubs are judged on what they win no flawed logic, no reality bullshit thats how it is.

Ah, I see what you did there. Nice try in saving your irrational argument. You added "top" before "clubs". But your argument still is just as flawed, as Everton isn't a "top club", therefore you cannot compare the winners medals of Moyes and Mancini.

Again:



If a 1000 quid second hand Fiesta can consistently beat a Ferrari Enzo around a circuit, you need to look at whose driving.

 
smithy167 said:
Dethred said:
smithy167 said:
Managers are judged on trophies won, not individual losses, get it?

I actually don't think you get it. Managers are judged on what they accomplish with what they have.

If they were judged on trophies, there would be, at most, three or four incumbent managers each season. Now we know why your logic is so flawed, you have a totally backwards view of reality.
Managers at top clubs are judged on what they win no flawed logic, no reality bullshit thats how it is.

Reality isn't bullcrap, it's reality. Dethred has cruelly but clinically dismembered your argument. Time to pick up the pieces...
 
LoveCity said:
Interesting quote from Mario today:

"I rarely hear from Mancini. I had fouled someone and he got angry, that’s all. We made up afterwards. Who do I prefer between Mancini and Mourinho? As a person Mancini, in football terms Mourinho."

Bingo, and that's from Mancini's son

I don't care if a manager's nice or not, I want a manager for his football abilities
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top