Mancini

Status
Not open for further replies.
jimharri said:
ban-mcfc said:
@BluePhil8 said:

might work under tixi and sorino but who knows?

mancinis CV is a lot more impressive.
If Mancini is sacked in the summer, and we were to go down the route of a young manager, I wouldn't mind Laudrup. He had a tough act to follow at Swansea, but he's done well in pushing Rodger's team forward and winning them a major trophy.

he's a good manager but it would be a gamble.

i wanted pep or to stick with mancini but i think mancini might leave due to the pressure, saldy because i love him.
 
jimharri said:
ban-mcfc said:
@BluePhil8 said:

might work under tixi and sorino but who knows?

mancinis CV is a lot more impressive.
If Mancini is sacked in the summer, and we were to go down the route of a young manager, I wouldn't mind Laudrup. He had a tough act to follow at Swansea, but he's done well in pushing Rodger's team forward and winning them a major trophy.


Don't want to assume he is going at all but if we had a new manager i would like Laudrup to.

It could so easily have gone badly wrong, second season syndrome, teams working you out etc etc.

He has done fantastically well imo.
 
ban-mcfc said:
@BluePhil8 said:

might work under tixi and sorino but who knows?

mancinis CV is a lot more impressive.

Did Pep have a better CV than Mancini when Barcelona appointed him manager?

What about Mourinho when Porto appointed him?

Or Ferguson when United appointed him after Aberdeen?

We don't need an established manager. We can make the next great manager.

Let's face it, Laudrup would have alot more respect from the players than Mancini does, has won it all at Barca and winning Swanseas first ever cup is quite an accomplishment.
 
For the third time on this thread i'm gonna make the point that i'm not sure I want Jose here. I still want Mancini to lead us to more glory. However theres a part of me that is shit scared of Jose turning up at Old Trafford when the pisscan retires.

Stick or twist and try to get him to stop that happening?
 
Laudrup gets my vote,he comes across as very classy and approachable,his eye for a player also looks good.

Could he have done worse than Mancini with this squad...?
 
TCIB said:
jimharri said:
ban-mcfc said:
might work under tixi and sorino but who knows?

mancinis CV is a lot more impressive.
If Mancini is sacked in the summer, and we were to go down the route of a young manager, I wouldn't mind Laudrup. He had a tough act to follow at Swansea, but he's done well in pushing Rodger's team forward and winning them a major trophy.


Don't want to assume he is going at all but if we had a new manager i would like Laudrup to.

It could so easily have gone badly wrong, second season syndrome, teams working you out etc etc.

He has done fantastically well imo.

laudrup would probably be in the run up if mancini is to go in the summer

someone with a good scouting knowledge or network as with fifas rules we will need to be more shrewed with signings, not just buying other clubs best players, abit like michu
 
Blue2112 said:
For the third time on this thread i'm gonna make the point that i'm not sure I want Jose here. I still want Mancini to lead us to more glory. However theres a part of me that is shit scared of Jose turning up at Old Trafford when the pisscan retires.

Stick or twist and try to get him to stop that happening?


he is certainly one of the two best managers in the world.....like him or hate him you cant deny that
 
FantasyIreland said:
Laudrup gets my vote,he comes across as very classy and approachable,his eye for a player also looks good.

Could he have done worse than Mancini with this squad...?

jesus christ! compare managerial cv's will you
 
Ardwick Green Blue said:
I'm not sure Bob wants to be our manager any longer. For large parts of the season he has looked disengaged & totally pissed off. My abiding memory of him this season is of him being sat on the bench moaning to Platt.

This is the only way Mancini will go, if he goes, he will walk himself not the other way round.

I personally think Txiki has let Mancini have free reign for the rest of this season to do what he wants and play whatever formation he wants. When Txiki brings in the players both he and Mancini want, that's when he will get more involved in formations, tactics, etc.

I think Txiki along with Soriano are building the foundations right now for the new season i.e. New Signing Negotiations, New strategy and training focus for PL & CL and formations/playing style. Hence not involving themselves too much with the current season except behind the scenes financially, social media, marketing, partnerships, revenue etc.
 
@BluePhil8 said:
ban-mcfc said:
@BluePhil8 said:

might work under tixi and sorino but who knows?

mancinis CV is a lot more impressive.

Did Pep have a better CV than Mancini when Barcelona appointed him manager?

What about Mourinho when Porto appointed him?

Or Ferguson when United appointed him after Aberdeen?

We don't need an established manager. We can make the next great manager.

Let's face it, Laudrup would have alot more respect from the players than Mancini does, has won it all at Barca and winning Swanseas first ever cup is quite an accomplishment.

if you want to take a huge gamble then laudrup is the one.

IF!!! we're going to replace mancini it needs to be for a guaranteed winner and a winner of european football.
 
ban-mcfc said:
@BluePhil8 said:
ban-mcfc said:
might work under tixi and sorino but who knows?

mancinis CV is a lot more impressive.

Did Pep have a better CV than Mancini when Barcelona appointed him manager?

What about Mourinho when Porto appointed him?

Or Ferguson when United appointed him after Aberdeen?

We don't need an established manager. We can make the next great manager.

Let's face it, Laudrup would have alot more respect from the players than Mancini does, has won it all at Barca and winning Swanseas first ever cup is quite an accomplishment.

if you want to take a huge gamble then laudrup is the one.

IF!!! we're going to replace mancini it needs to be for a guaranteed winner and a winner of european football.

Laudrup is a a winner of european football. As a player he is one of the all time greats.
 
SuperSilva said:
Ardwick Green Blue said:
I'm not sure Bob wants to be our manager any longer. For large parts of the season he has looked disengaged & totally pissed off. My abiding memory of him this season is of him being sat on the bench moaning to Platt.

This is the only way Mancini will go, if he goes, he will walk himself not the other way round.

I personally think Txiki has let Mancini have free reign for the rest of this season to do what he wants and play whatever formation he wants. When Txiki brings in the players both he and Mancini want, that's when he will get more involved in formations, tactics, etc.

I think Txiki along with Soriano are building the foundations right now for the new season i.e. New Signing Negotiations, New strategy and training focus for PL & CL and formations/playing style. Hence not involving themselves too much with the current season except behind the scenes financially, social media, marketing, partnerships, revenue etc.


All well and good as long as we dont finish lower than 2nd this season
 
Playing against Everton seems to be his kryptonite. It's almost unacceptable that Mancini doesn't seem able to beat Everton with the squad that we have in quite a few attempts at their place. You can lose at any ground with a great squad but to consistenly get beat every year at Everton with the players we have is shocking IMO.
 
ban-mcfc said:
@BluePhil8 said:
ban-mcfc said:
might work under tixi and sorino but who knows?

mancinis CV is a lot more impressive.

Did Pep have a better CV than Mancini when Barcelona appointed him manager?

What about Mourinho when Porto appointed him?

Or Ferguson when United appointed him after Aberdeen?

We don't need an established manager. We can make the next great manager.

Let's face it, Laudrup would have alot more respect from the players than Mancini does, has won it all at Barca and winning Swanseas first ever cup is quite an accomplishment.

if you want to take a huge gamble then laudrup is the one.

IF!!! we're going to replace mancini it needs to be for a guaranteed winner and a winner of european football.

Agreed ban - there is no way Mansour has ploughed so much money to get us this far to then employ a relatively unproven manager at this level. Too much of a gamble at this stage. I can't fathom how some City fans still don't get we are now dining at the top table and here to stay. Thats not an arrogant or conceited statement but a fact of life and we will be aiming for the best on all fronts to stay there.
 
meeesh said:
SuperSilva said:
Ardwick Green Blue said:
I'm not sure Bob wants to be our manager any longer. For large parts of the season he has looked disengaged & totally pissed off. My abiding memory of him this season is of him being sat on the bench moaning to Platt.

This is the only way Mancini will go, if he goes, he will walk himself not the other way round.

I personally think Txiki has let Mancini have free reign for the rest of this season to do what he wants and play whatever formation he wants. When Txiki brings in the players both he and Mancini want, that's when he will get more involved in formations, tactics, etc.

I think Txiki along with Soriano are building the foundations right now for the new season i.e. New Signing Negotiations, New strategy and training focus for PL & CL and formations/playing style. Hence not involving themselves too much with the current season except behind the scenes financially, social media, marketing, partnerships, revenue etc.


All well and good as long as we dont finish lower than 2nd this season
And there's no guarantee of that now.
 
SuperSilva said:
Ardwick Green Blue said:
I'm not sure Bob wants to be our manager any longer. For large parts of the season he has looked disengaged & totally pissed off. My abiding memory of him this season is of him being sat on the bench moaning to Platt.

This is the only way Mancini will go, if he goes, he will walk himself not the other way round.

I personally think Txiki has let Mancini have free reign for the rest of this season to do what he wants and play whatever formation he wants. When Txiki brings in the players both he and Mancini want, that's when he will get more involved in formations, tactics, etc.

I think Txiki along with Soriano are building the foundations right now for the new season i.e. New Signing Negotiations, New strategy and training focus for PL & CL and formations/playing style. Hence not involving themselves too much with the current season except behind the scenes financially, social media, marketing, partnerships, revenue etc.

I think you are misguided I think he is borrowed and time and tixi and ferran minds are elsewhere
 
Blue2112 said:
ban-mcfc said:
@BluePhil8 said:
Did Pep have a better CV than Mancini when Barcelona appointed him manager?

What about Mourinho when Porto appointed him?

Or Ferguson when United appointed him after Aberdeen?

We don't need an established manager. We can make the next great manager.

Let's face it, Laudrup would have alot more respect from the players than Mancini does, has won it all at Barca and winning Swanseas first ever cup is quite an accomplishment.

if you want to take a huge gamble then laudrup is the one.

IF!!! we're going to replace mancini it needs to be for a guaranteed winner and a winner of european football.

Agreed ban - there is no way Mansour has ploughed so much money to get us this far to then employ a relatively unproven manager at this level. Too much of a gamble at this stage. I can't fathom how some City fans still don't get we are now dining at the top table and here to stay. Thats not an arrogant or conceited statement but a fact of life and we will be aiming for the best on all fronts to stay there.


Can you just address the point i made instead of acting like a smart ass?

Porto, Barcelona and United (All huge clubs, "dining at the top table") Didn't just go for established managers and look how it turned out for them.

*EDIT - sorry "blue2112", you are not acting like a smart ass. That was aimed at someone else.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top