Mancini

Status
Not open for further replies.
it's football and even the best team in the world will lose games and have periods of inconsistency

the best manager in the world will make mistakes and get his tactics wrong sometimes

Mancini should be judged on his record and his record so far is excellent (Europe aside). Europe may well ultimately be his undoing but he has earned another shot at it for me and many others. If next season panned out the same as this then I would understand the view that he may have taken us as far as he is able and would understand the owners thinking that a Mourinho, or similar, might take us up another gear.

But not before and even then I personally would need to be persuaded that a Chelsea-esque managerial rotation policy is the best way forward for the club and change brings no guarantees. I think he's earned some patience and we've earned some stability.
 
Balti said:
it's football and even the best team in the world will lose games and have periods of inconsistency

the best manager in the world will make mistakes and get his tactics wrong sometimes

Mancini should be judged on his record and his record so far is excellent (Europe aside). Europe may well ultimately be his undoing but he has earned another shot at it for me and many others. If next season panned out the same as this then I would understand the view that he may have taken us as far as he is able and would understand the owners thinking that a Mourinho, or similar, might take us up another gear.

But not before and even then I personally would need to be persuaded that a Chelsea-esque managerial rotation policy is the best way forward for the club and change brings no guarantees. I think he's earned some patience and we've earned some stability.


this
 
Balti said:
(Europe aside)

He's a great architect. Unless he needs to build a building with more than one floor.

Absolutely tragic the way some people brush aside Mancini's incompetence in Europe as some inconsequential thing which isn't at all important.
 
The cookie monster said:
OB1 said:
The cookie monster said:
P'b of course everyone is entitled to their opinion on mancini
I just think the abuse he has had on here is unwarranted.


But you think it is warranted to effectively abuse people on here by completely misrepresenting their views and taking the p!ss? Just because they do not share your view.

Also, what do define as abuse? I've not seen much abuse of Mancini but I have seen plenty of considered criticism.

Are you serious?


I'll answer your question if you answer mine.
 
I've said all along that I think he should get another year and I can't help wondering what sort of season this might have been had the summer window gone the way Mancini wanted it to. I don't think we've been bad this season but neither have we hits the heights we did at times last year.Given the total exhilaration we all felt last year perhaps this season was always going to have an element of comedown about it. We hurt Utd and they have come out fighting and it seems we were not able to stay the pace this time around ( I can't totally give it up though...always the optimist) so if we end up with nothing or even a cup I still would like to see what Roberto could achieve with the type and quality of players he wants.
 
BillyShears said:
Balti said:
(Europe aside)

He's a great architect. Unless he needs to build a building with more than one floor.

Absolutely tragic the way some people brush aside Mancini's incompetence in Europe as some inconsequential thing which isn't at all important.

I believe I said that Europe may ultimately be his undoing.

Hardly brushing it aside.

I just don't subscribe to the instant success philosophy that some people preach.
 
Balti said:
it's football and even the best team in the world will lose games and have periods of inconsistency

the best manager in the world will make mistakes and get his tactics wrong sometimes

Mancini should be judged on his record and his record so far is excellent (Europe aside). Europe may well ultimately be his undoing but he has earned another shot at it for me and many others. If next season panned out the same as this then I would understand the view that he may have taken us as far as he is able and would understand the owners thinking that a Mourinho, or similar, might take us up another gear.

But not before and even then I personally would need to be persuaded that a Chelsea-esque managerial rotation policy is the best way forward for the club and change brings no guarantees. I think he's earned some patience and we've earned some stability.

I understand where you are coming from. His record with trophies for us so far, is, very good. We had a brilliant spell which spanned the end of the 10/11 season to half way through the 11/12 season. This was about 25 games, and we played fantastic football. He's got to be congratulated for that.



I don't know why getting rid of Mancini would be Chelsea esque...? Especially if it was to happen next season. Recently Chelsea had Ancelotti for 2 years, AVB for a matter of months, Di Matteo for a matter of months, Rafa for a matter of months.

We are not sacking Mancini, like Chelsea sack managers.
 
dancity19 said:
I don't know why getting rid of Mancini would be Chelsea esque...?

It's another nonsensical over exaggeration to try and give his opinion more perceived gravitas.

I've got plenty of time for people who think Mancini deserves more time. You only need to say that "he's won 2 trophies, he deserves another season" and I find it hard to argue. I disagree but I can't argue against it. It's the random application of nonsense about Chelsea, or about Europe being unimportant, or that those who want Mancini out do so because they want "instant" anything. It's just all a big pile of horseshit piled on top of an opinion to give the effect of the moral high ground.
 
BillyShears said:
dancity19 said:
I don't know why getting rid of Mancini would be Chelsea esque...?

It's another nonsensical over exaggeration to try and give his opinion more perceived gravitas.

I've got plenty of time for people who think Mancini deserves more time. You only need to say that "he's won 2 trophies, he deserves another season" and I find it hard to argue. I disagree but I can't argue against it. It's the random application of nonsense about Chelsea, or about Europe being unimportant, or that those who want Mancini out do so because they want "instant" anything. It's just all a big pile of horseshit piled on top of an opinion to give the effect of the moral high ground.

"Horseshit" or you just find it diifficult to argue against? Afteralll Europe is your big stick. Perhaps some of us are willing to wait a little longer for success - doesn't mean it's "horseshit."
 
BillyShears said:
Balti said:
(Europe aside)

He's a great architect. Unless he needs to build a building with more than one floor.

Absolutely tragic the way some people brush aside Mancini's incompetence in Europe as some inconsequential thing which isn't at all important.

Out of interest BS, how many campaigns has the man had in Europe?? Genuinely interested

I'd say the club in itself is far to wet behind the ears, however there's no doubt in my mind he'll win a champions league trophy within the next 6/7 years, the only problem is it probably won't be here!!!! A manager of his ilk improves because of the motivation they take from failure, he's made many mistakes this year granted but for achieving the ultimate goal of winning the league he should be afforded another crack, IMO he'll win the league if still here next year!!!!
 
I'm on the fence. I wouldn't be unhappy to see Mancini get another season, with some backing in the summer transfer window, to see if he can improve in Europe & get the team challenging for the league again next season. I think there are some players that need shipping out & that might improve things.

Alternatively I'm alarmed by some of the performances this season & that some of the players look uninspired. I'm not sure if that is down to the manger or not. If we could get a better manager than we have already then I would be in favour of making a change. I don't see the likes of Laudrup as an improvement on what we have though. Mourinho would be IMO.
 
BillyShears said:
Balti said:
(Europe aside)

He's a great architect. Unless he needs to build a building with more than one floor.

Absolutely tragic the way some people brush aside Mancini's incompetence in Europe as some inconsequential thing which isn't at all important.
The thing that gets me is its not just European games. Teams have been finding us out for months.

Before the season kicks off you might as well forget games like Everton (h & a), Liverpool (a), Stoke (a), Sunderland (a) because they know how to play against us.

So that's 5 games we know we can't win before we kick a ball.
 
BillyShears said:
dancity19 said:
I don't know why getting rid of Mancini would be Chelsea esque...?

It's another nonsensical over exaggeration to try and give his opinion more perceived gravitas.

I've got plenty of time for people who think Mancini deserves more time. You only need to say that "he's won 2 trophies, he deserves another season" and I find it hard to argue. I disagree but I can't argue against it. It's the random application of nonsense about Chelsea, or about Europe being unimportant, or that those who want Mancini out do so because they want "instant" anything. It's just all a big pile of horseshit piled on top of an opinion to give the effect of the moral high ground.


That is what a lot of it is about in my opinion. Like you say, a lot of 'inners' have arguments that are difficult to counter.

But I think, just as many, want Mancini in because they are perceived to be the better fan. They are, in their head, getting behind the team more than those who want him out. They are the moral ones, the ones who are 'patient' etc.

Anyway, even if that's not true, if they come out with something as infantile as those who want him out have only just become fans, I'll come out with above....
 
Zin 'messiah' Zimmer said:
BillyShears said:
Balti said:
(Europe aside)

He's a great architect. Unless he needs to build a building with more than one floor.

Absolutely tragic the way some people brush aside Mancini's incompetence in Europe as some inconsequential thing which isn't at all important.

Out of interest BS, how many campaigns has the man had in Europe?? Genuinely interested

I'd say the club in itself is far to wet behind the ears, however there's no doubt in my mind he'll win a champions league trophy within the next 6/7 years, the only problem is it probably won't be here!!!! A manager of his ilk improves because of the motivation they take from failure, he's made many mistakes this year granted but for achieving the ultimate goal of winning the league he should be afforded another crack, IMO he'll win the league if still here next year!!!!

Honestly his record is average. He might be a relative novice, but just as City weren't prepared to wait for Mark Hughes how to figure out how to manage at the level they wanted at the time, I'm not sure they will wait for Mancini to grow into a top European manager.

I've also said quite a few times that he probably will win the CL one day. He's not a shit coach, far from it. He's a very good manager who's record of trophies speaks for itself. He's just not at that level required to make an impact both domestically and in Europe. This was proven at Inter, and has subsequently been proven at City so far.
 
Zin 'messiah' Zimmer said:
BillyShears said:
Balti said:
(Europe aside)

He's a great architect. Unless he needs to build a building with more than one floor.

Absolutely tragic the way some people brush aside Mancini's incompetence in Europe as some inconsequential thing which isn't at all important.

Out of interest BS, how many campaigns has the man had in Europe?? Genuinely interested

I'd say the club in itself is far to wet behind the ears, however there's no doubt in my mind he'll win a champions league trophy within the next 6/7 years, the only problem is it probably won't be here!!!! A manager of his ilk improves because of the motivation they take from failure, he's made many mistakes this year granted but for achieving the ultimate goal of winning the league he should be afforded another crack, IMO he'll win the league if still here next year!!!!
He has had 7 champions league campaigns.

His record stands

Group Stage, Quarters, Quarters, Last 16, Last 16, Group Stage, Group Stage.
 
Zin 'messiah' Zimmer said:
BillyShears said:
Balti said:
(Europe aside)

He's a great architect. Unless he needs to build a building with more than one floor.

Absolutely tragic the way some people brush aside Mancini's incompetence in Europe as some inconsequential thing which isn't at all important.

Out of interest BS, how many campaigns has the man had in Europe?? Genuinely interested

I'd say the club in itself is far to wet behind the ears, however there's no doubt in my mind he'll win a champions league trophy within the next 6/7 years, the only problem is it probably won't be here!!!! A manager of his ilk improves because of the motivation they take from failure, he's made many mistakes this year granted but for achieving the ultimate goal of winning the league he should be afforded another crack, IMO he'll win the league if still here next year!!!!


I really don't understand this argument to be honest. How, as a club, can we be too inexperienced to perform well in the Champions League. I would understand if our players were equally 'wet behind the ears' as the club as a whole is. But they aren't?

So what is it that is holding us back.....the fact that us, as fans, are new to the champions league?

It just doesn't wash with me, we have World Cup winners, Euro winners, Europa League Cup winners, and Champions League Winners in our squad. They aren't wet behind the ears.

Why does the fact that Manchester City, as a name, are new to the Champions League, affect us. It didn't affect Harry Redknapp and Tottenham, and nor did it affect Napoli.

The argument just doesn't wash with me- we have a team of experienced players, who aren't wet behind the ears.
 
Paulmcfc2703 said:
BillyShears said:
Balti said:
(Europe aside)

He's a great architect. Unless he needs to build a building with more than one floor.

Absolutely tragic the way some people brush aside Mancini's incompetence in Europe as some inconsequential thing which isn't at all important.
The thing that gets me is its not just European games. Teams have been finding us out for months.

Before the season kicks off you might as well forget games like Everton (h & a), Liverpool (a), Stoke (a), Sunderland (a) because they know how to play against us.

So that's 5 games we know we can't win before we kick a ball.

This is the part that gets me, surely a great manager would have worked out a way to overcome this?

My fear is next season will be much of the same if Mancini stays.
 
Fuck it-lets just go back to the Alan Ball,Stuart Pearce days of utter mediocracy and winning jack shit hey because Mancini has made a few mistakes in europe and against the blue dippers.

Mancini gets unwarranted abuse on here. I know many a rag who hopes he does get the chop because they know he has rattled Fergie and they think with a little more backing he will come strong again next year.
This year hasn't exactly been a disaster has it?

I would say if a straw poll was taken re Mancini the outers would be approx 10% and the inners 90%
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top