You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
MCFC Player of the Year
- Thread starter Daz_Blue
- Start date
James23
Well-Known Member
Kompany for me, De Jong will be up there too, then Silva and Tevez closely following in 3rd and 4th.
Real-City said:Kompany is the best player on our team. Better than Tevez. After Kompany it is a toss up. Silva has gotten increasingly better as the season has gone on. His performance last night was incredible. Tevez's goals can't be ignored. De Jong's steady play can't be ignored. Hart's shot blocking can't be ignored. Kompany is it and after him it doesn't matter.
Tevez's goals cant be ignored but can his transfer request? Potentially de-railing our season? It just seems to me completely wrong that any player that submits a transfer request should be considered as a Player of the Year.
Kompany
Silva
De Jong
sir malcom
Well-Known Member
Kompany De jong, and David Silva is settling in just nicely.
Bluemoon dan
Well-Known Member
Kompany, De Jong and then just Tevez over Silva for me. No matter who it is though its just good that there are at least 6 or 7 players that you can make a good case for! Hasn't always been like that in my many years supporting city.
PSmyth07 said:1.Kompany
2.Tevez
3. Between Silva, De Jong and Johnson.
Huh? Dude played 15 games, and was effective in less than half of them. How can he be in consideration.<br /><br />-- Tue Apr 26, 2011 9:38 am --<br /><br />1. Kompany
2. Carlos Tevez
3. David Silva
4. Joe Hart.
Everyoneelse is a little behind that pack
Blumers Bloomers
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 25 Jan 2008
- Messages
- 7,029
sir malcom said:Kompany De jong, and David Silva is settling in just nicely.
I'm with you blue. Not sure about the order for NDJ, Silva and Tevez, but Kompany has won it at a canter for me.
And as for those people who havent got Kompany in the top three, I can only assume you are on drugs
AustinBlue
Well-Known Member
My votes:
Best Player: Silva
Best represents the heart of the club: Zab
Most Valuable: Kompany
Hart, De Jong, Barry, Yaya deserve consideration. AJ for the progress he's making as a professional.
For all his on field contribution, for me, Tevez doesn't deserve awards after his want-away antics and failure to show for the semi. Treatment in Milan? Couldn't take an afternoon and evening off and jump a private jet?
Best Player: Silva
Best represents the heart of the club: Zab
Most Valuable: Kompany
Hart, De Jong, Barry, Yaya deserve consideration. AJ for the progress he's making as a professional.
For all his on field contribution, for me, Tevez doesn't deserve awards after his want-away antics and failure to show for the semi. Treatment in Milan? Couldn't take an afternoon and evening off and jump a private jet?
1. Kompany
2. Tevez
3. De Jong/Silva
You can't really have someone score 24 goals and not have them up there for Player Of The Year.
As for Young Player Of The Year? What age does this cover? Richards? Balotelli?. Boyata hasn't done that much, but has played well in the games he's played in. If Richards can win it, it would probably be him.
2. Tevez
3. De Jong/Silva
You can't really have someone score 24 goals and not have them up there for Player Of The Year.
As for Young Player Of The Year? What age does this cover? Richards? Balotelli?. Boyata hasn't done that much, but has played well in the games he's played in. If Richards can win it, it would probably be him.