all good, i dont want to take over this thread with my thoughts on their new name, its not something i am a fan of but i am not from melbourne so its not really aimed at me, its going to be interesting how Melbourne city go crowd wise, there are a lot of eurosnobs in Australia who only watch the EPL and maybe a few other European leagues but refuse to watch the A-league but now that they are owned by a massive force in Europe then it should be interesting to see their demographic.Falastur said:1556 said:i agree i cannot really say because i never been to Melbourne, i might think it was amazing if i was from Melbourne, i am unsure about the number but it could make chants easier, i am actually from Sydney so since i got into football its been different as every team has a supporter group chosen by the fans so me it would feel very odd just to have "<name of team> F.C. Supporters Club".Falastur said:In fairness, they picked that name not because it was a super-fantastic-funny name or that it chants well but because it appeals to people from Melbourne, especially at a time when they're fighting the dominance of another club from the same city in a way that should echo with our own experience. They were consciously trying to avoid a "clever" name because they thought that down the line those kinds of names were likely to cause more embarrassment than good. Additionally, if you read the full statement, they did say that there had been a lot of support for a name including the date 1847 (the city's foundation year) and that they would be using 47 as a nickname for the group and its members, and 47 is much more quotable/singable, so it doesn't really matter how singable Melburnians is, surely?
Bearing in mind that most supporters groups in the UK are called "<name of team> F.C. Supporters Club", I wouldn't have thought that to a UK fan the name of a group needed to be non-generic and singable, anyway?
Hopefully its a good name for them though it does not really matter if i like it or not, i cant wait to see what style of active support they have, it should be interesting to watch from afar, also great post iHeartCity
Fair enough, I'll admit I didn't realise you weren't British. I don't think British people really give two hoots about the names of supporters clubs, it's just not something we even bother to give names to, hence why I find it weird that any name therefore becomes cringeworthy.
I dont want to ruin this thread with questions that cant be answered i am just going to look forward to see what happens next season crowd and active support wise