Middle East Conflict

[robbieh]

Stolen?
War is about land. It’s not like they sneaked in and ran off with it!

At what point is enough enough? Do you think Oct 7th was an act of war? Invading territory to kill innocents?

If so, the prosecution of that war is ongoing. We can discuss who is at war with whom, and why, if you like, but Iran gave Netanyahu the excuse he was looking for…and he’s going to take it to HIS conclusion. We can discuss that, too, if you like.

But, you don’t go to war, lose people and equipment, then when it ends everyone goes back to their corners and all land is ceded. We cannot discuss that.

So you're suggesting that Palestinians will have to keep fighting in order to get their land back.

 

[Cheadle_hulmeBlue]

Ducado you seem to be the only Jewish voice who talks sense. Can I ask what your thoughts are on the Occupation/Settlers in the West Bank. As most of the other Pro Israeli folk are denying and land grabs or Occupation. Which seems at odds to the UN and just about every nation in the world.

That’s a bit of a sweeping statement for all Jewish people.

 

[The blue phantom]

I do wonder if this should become a job for a UN coalition peacekeeping force? I suspect any western boots on the ground would not be seen as neutral by Muslim Arabs though.

Israel can't stand the UN. In fact theve just barred the head of it from their country for posting this tweet.

 

[The blue phantom]

That’s a bit of a sweeping statement for all Jewish people.

On this Forum. He tells it as it is.

 

[Cheadle_hulmeBlue]

On this Forum. He tells it as it is.

And all other Jewish people don’t?

I’d argue it’s the government making the decisions not all Jewish people. Plenty I know who only want peace.

 

[Mazzarelli's Swiss Cheese]

Israel can't stand the UN. In fact theve just barred the head of it from their country for posting this tweet.

Probably not going to happen then!

 

[Big Joe Corrigan]

Is "Stop Hatred" really that simple？
In China, it's National Day holiday now. It's so peaceful. You can see how relaxed people are.
There isn't much hatred here. We don't hate CCP, Mao, the west, minority ethnics, uyghurs, tibetans...

What about the rags?

 

[The blue phantom]

Probably not going to happen then!

There wasn't enough condemnation for Iran in his Tweet so they have now Banned him.

 

[Mazzarelli's Swiss Cheese]

There wasn't enough condemnation for Iran in his Tweet so they have now Banned him.

I'm beginning to wonder if the Israeli govt have been infiltrated by rawk - always offended, never ashamed.

 

[Vic]

Stolen?
War is about land. It’s not like they sneaked in and ran off with it!

At what point is enough enough? Do you think Oct 7th was an act of war? Invading territory to kill innocents?

If so, the prosecution of that war is ongoing. We can discuss who is at war with whom, and why, if you like, but Iran gave Netanyahu the excuse he was looking for…and he’s going to take it to HIS conclusion. We can discuss that, too, if you like.

But, you don’t go to war, lose people and equipment, then when it ends everyone goes back to their corners and all land is ceded. We cannot discuss that.

So at what point does Israel think they have enough land?

When they occupy all the West Bank?

When they occupy east of the Jordan?

When they reclaim the extent of Solomon's biblical kingdom? (Whether or not those biblical borders were true or just an optimistic "history".)

Discuss what land you want who to cede to whom.