Milner [Merged]

[TonyM]

Milner will be our player of the season next year. I know it's a bold call but I honestly believe he will be that good. I hate to say it but he'll be like Fletcher is to the rags and we really need that type of player. Mancini supposedly wants to play the diamond formation and his signings clearly fit into this formation. Our midfield will have toure sitting just in front of the defence then Barry and milner ahead who will be expected to attack and defend and silva will play just behind the strikers. In this formation Ireland can cover for silva but isn't the type of player to play the same role as milner and Barry.

Honestly think milner will be a great buy

This makes sense and indeed your point about the diamond formation sounds plausible. We'll soon see what it will be in a few weeks.

On a point about Milner, I think he will give our midfield more steel and determination. Something we lacked at times last year. It's not always about the flair and creativity.

I don't agree that Ireland and Milner will be very different. I think both with battle it out for a role in the busy end midfield, Silva imo will be further forward or wider than both. But that said I think there will be a lot of versatility in our midfield- differnt players but hopefully a common theme of hard work, positive play and confidence.

 

[Johnny_on]

Ireland's best season was OK, still went missing a lot, had a lot of goals set up for him which made it look a whole lot better. Milner was the hub of a team that achieved a lot more than us in Ireland's best year. Finally Milner has everything right between his ears, Ireland is a complete fruit cake!

this!

I'm not against Milner, maybe the price is putting people off, but to say Ireland wasn't good that year is utter nonsense. Forget his goals, his assists were enough, plus his general alround play and passing was as good as anyone that year outside top 4.

Man that pass to Robinho against West Brom, his performances against Hull home and away , Everton away, Liverpool and arsenal at home, so many great performances. It was a treat to watch him.

 

[Danamy]

In agreement with a lot of posters on here, while Milner did not request to leave MON had the upper hand in negotiation could demand the 30m, the minute the lad said he wasn't signing a new contract the negotiation shifted, they could turn down an overinflated price for him and have a sulky player or take a compromise amount, I agree 25m sounds about right and allow MON to re invest in the team, he won't want to piss us off too much especially if he has eyes for one of our players (like Dunne deal last year) so I expect it to move quickly now, hopefully as everyone says in the next couple of days.

Player movement has been mentioned even at the start of proceedings in May and i haven't heard anything differant for this to change.
To be honest this might be what's held it up for so long as it's always waiting for one to go through to give the green light on the other..................

 

[LYNX]

I hope Milner comes.

 

[Rammyblues]

Danamy I agree with you that picking the team next year is going to be extremly difficult especially when we don't play in Europe, Kbbs competition is going to be a nightmare:-)

 

[PSmyth07]

Yeah but in that one season, Ireland showed much more than Milner has ever showed. I admit that he hasn't had a good year, but you don't go backwards as a player, we just have to encourage Ireland to push on and live up to his potential.

It would be a disaster if we bought Milner and got rid of Ireland imo.

Ireland's best season was OK, still went missing a lot, had a lot of goals set up for him which made it look a whole lot better. Milner was the hub of a team that achieved a lot more than us in Ireland's best year. Finally Milner has everything right between his ears, Ireland is a complete fruit cake!

His best season was OK? He got player of the year at City. To have an OK season and still pip it over the likes of Robinho is remarkable.

Its just so typical and easy to cast someone off when they have a bad season. Milner is no better Ireland, both have strengths and weaknesses. If you take a look at the bigger picture, Irelands strengths are exactly what we missed last year. The technical ability and skill to pick a pass. Milners strengths is what we've already got in Tevez's workrate and Adam Johnsons crossing.

 

[theevilweasel]

Ireland's best season was OK, still went missing a lot, had a lot of goals set up for him which made it look a whole lot better. Milner was the hub of a team that achieved a lot more than us in Ireland's best year. Finally Milner has everything right between his ears, Ireland is a complete fruit cake!

His best season was OK? He got player of the year at City. To have an OK season and still pip it over the likes of Robinho is remarkable.

Its just so typical and easy to cast someone off when they have a bad season. Milner is no better Ireland, both have strengths and weaknesses. If you take a look at the bigger picture, Irelands strengths are exactly what we missed last year. The technical ability and skill to pick a pass. Milners strengths is what we've already got in Tevez's workrate and Adam Johnsons crossing.

So if you take Tevez out who replaces him for work rate who is currently at our club?

Take Johnson out and is anyone capable of putting a decent cross in?

With your argument you could argue why do we need another forward when we have Ade and Tevez?

Teams do not win trophies ..................... squads win trophies.

 

[dadnlad]

Next season will be a nightmare to try and second guess Mancini's thinking on team selection..........
There's a pattern to all his signings and one word springs to mind and that's versatility.
I think it might be an idea to introduce a weekly guess the team comp as it'll be a hard one to win that's for sure!

ha ha i;ve just outed yer lol

we've a talks""t presenter onboard lol
today we had twentyfive midfielders ;p

 

[Shaelumstash]

Werder have publicly stated Ozil is available for 20 million euro's, around £17 million. However, Silva is better than Ozil and Ozil plays in Silva's posistion, not Milners. Personally i would increase our offer for milner to £20million plus 3 in add ons, i would also open talks with Everton to sign Arteta so Villa know that we have alternatives. think about it, if we don't budge from £23million Villa will either have to accept or have a player on there books who has publically stated he doesn't want to be with them any more. I hope we have learn't from the Lescott saga.

You're contradicting yourself here. You're saying Ozil plays in Silva's position, and Arteta plays in Milners?! The two most similar players there are Ozil and Arteta, both attacking midfielders who run games and always demand the ball. Silva is more of a modern day winger or plays just off a striker. Ozil is more of a midfielder and to me looks like Lampard but with more pace the way he dominates games. He would be perfect at Barca in a few years to replace Xavi.

Milner is just a waste of time signing for me, 30 is what we'll have to pay and that is just absurd for a hard working average ability player. He's ok, but he's not going to win us the league, Ozil has the potential to be the best midfielder in the world, I know where I'd prefer to spend the money.

 

[PSmyth07]

His best season was OK? He got player of the year at City. To have an OK season and still pip it over the likes of Robinho is remarkable.

Its just so typical and easy to cast someone off when they have a bad season. Milner is no better Ireland, both have strengths and weaknesses. If you take a look at the bigger picture, Irelands strengths are exactly what we missed last year. The technical ability and skill to pick a pass. Milners strengths is what we've already got in Tevez's workrate and Adam Johnsons crossing.

So if you take Tevez out who replaces him for work rate who is currently at our club?

Take Johnson out and is anyone capable of putting a decent cross in?

With your argument you could argue why do we need another forward when we have Ade and Tevez?

Teams do not win trophies ..................... squads win trophies.

I'm not saying that without Tevez there's no work rate at City and without Johnson there's no-one that can put a good ball in. Im using these as examples because this is what the excel at.

Yeah, it would be good to add more of this to the squad but whats the point when we're potentially lacking in other departments? We'll just fail in some games for the exact same reasons we did last season.