Neil McNab
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 7 May 2009
- Messages
- 3,371
That he was shit and had fell lucky with a couple of signings, no real aptitude for the job and that whatever job he got from there would be the big payday of his career!robbieh said:Neil McNab said:Surely that's the best way to judge a player or a manager. If you tell people what you think of a player just after he's had a stinker you may not not, at that moment in your life, remember all the posetive stuff he's done in other games, your opinion is tainted.
Don't get me wrong i think Winter is a fuck wit of the highest order but I wouldn't call him for sticking to his guns and remaining consistent in an opinion of someone.
I for example thought Adebayor was over rated, lazy and fortunate Arsenal made him look good. After the first few games of the season my long term unbiassed assessment had been tainted by a couple of goals and the excitement of a new player up front. Over time it's always that first impression that's nearer to the truth!
And what was your first impression of MH at Blackburn? Mine were not that favourable and things have gone downhill since then.
Like I said I think Winter is a tit and is totaly wrong about Hughes but he's right to stick to his initial assessments, if he was intelligent those initial assessments would serve him well!