Most overrated City player ever?

[Lavinda Past]

If you don’t think VK was great footballs not for you

And you're an expert on football then?

You know bugger all lad. His calf injuries were 90% down to over-reaching in tackles due to his misjudgement. Similar to Jack Wilshere and (to a lesser extent), Aymeric Laporte.

Vinny was a reactive player. Great players read the game better and act proactively.

Vinny is a great leader, an inspirational figure. That's his strength.

 

[urban genie]

The thread title invites disrespectful comments about great for us players.

It invites opinion, this place isn't RAWK when negative comment is verboden.

We are not a cult after all ;-)

 

[hilts]

Robinho Sane Hart Cancelo

 

[Thenumber1blue]

Nigel Clough & Steve McManaman

Nobody rated either

 

[jimmygrimblesboots]

looking at the headlines today its Haaland , i am going to enjoy watching this lad ram the taunts down everyones throats this season , the reaction to his performance will only make him even more determined , they've poked the tiger and this is going to get messy for oppostion defences this season.

 

[NeilMcnabTwoFooted]

Nobody rated either

Real Madrid must of done for pointer at least

 

[bondsman]

And you're an expert on football then?

You know bugger all lad. His calf injuries were 90% down to over-reaching in tackles due to his misjudgement. Similar to Jack Wilshere and (to a lesser extent), Aymeric Laporte.

Vinny was a reactive player. Great players read the game better and act proactively.

Vinny is a great leader, an inspirational figure. That's his strength.

Are you a qualified doctor or physio? Do you have access to the reports the medical team had?

Great players of course are proactive but they’re also inevitably reactive and have to be. How else can you play the game?

Well done for making yourself look daft twice though

 

[Thenumber1blue]

Real Madrid must of done for pointer at least

Ahh I took it as for us

 

[Keeper!]

Anyone mentioned Rodney Marsh?

Great entertainer but a total arrogant cnut on and off the pitch

 

[Lavinda Past]

Are you a qualified doctor or physio? Do you have access to the reports the medical team had?

Great players of course are proactive but they’re also inevitably reactive and have to be. How else can you play the game?

Well done for making yourself look daft twice though

Give up lad. You're a biased fan who won't hear anything bad about their heroes. All players are overrated by fans and few are anywhere near as 'great' as giddy fans like to think they are/were.

Iconic players weren't necessarily great players.