Most overrated City player ever?

[Lavinda Past]

Couldn’t have lead the way he did without being a great player.

Yes he could. It's quite common in team sports. Great leader, good player.

 

[ctwrd]

Kompany overrated. Dear me. Colossus. Could step in fresh from injury lay off and like he had been playing all season. Walking red card? He was fierce, committed. Like football should be and isn’t anymore (see pawson today letting nothing go. Basketball)

 

[uwerosler28]

The crowds expectations of Kolarovs left foot at set pieces or long shots were way over rated, can think of less than 5 occasions he didnt just smash it into the stand taking power over accuracy , not great at defending either, yet everyone was on their feet as he wound up for a shot expecting the net to bulge.

 

[bondsman]

Yes he could. It's quite common in team sports. Great leader, good player.

If you don’t think VK was great footballs not for you

 

[Jack74]

Top players score big goals , Yaya , Aguero ( big balls ) and Kompany , what a spine of a team that is .

 

[SebastianBlue]

Waiting for one of the megaflappers to say Haaland.

 

[Petetheblu]

Waiting for one of the megaflappers to say Haaland.

3....2.....1......

The most operated thing about City is the fan that shouldn't follow football and should jusy stick to Lego or some other form of child's play.

 

[East Level 2]

If you don’t think VK was great footballs not for you

VK was a great player. However he was also a red card waiting to happen as his style of tackling gave refs an easy option. He wasn't dirty, he wasn't dangerous, he wasn't out of control, but the current interpretation of the law left him at risk with over-zealous officials.

 

[alexmcity]

The thread title invites disrespectful comments about great for us players.

 

[Gazza]

The thread title invites disrespectful comments about great for us players.

As does every thread.