Ducado
Well-Known Member
George Hannah said:
If it was serious or suspected they would not have left him on the pitch
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Negredo
- Thread starter mcfcstu
- Start date
If it was serious or suspected they would not have left him on the pitch
Zin 'messiah' Zimmer
Well-Known Member
George Hannah said:Alf still looked in pain after the game, couldn't lift his arm to shake hands. Looks like a dislocated or broken collarbone to me. Reporter told Manuel post match he was limping down the tunnel, Manuel shrugged and said "Alvaro has a pain in his shoulder - we will see tomorrow."
Bad news tomorrow I think.
And how does a broken collarbone look? Nonsense
If you'd experienced one or seen up close someone who has just received one, you'd know (a) he wouldn't be coming back on and (b) he certainly would be doing more than wincing!
Aguero was injured. Him and dzeko were all we had he couldn't really give him a rest to be honest. And Alvaro strikes me as a player that does not want rest he enjoy playing and scoring. Injuries happen it's parts of the game. He gets paid to play and obvious by Pelli not choosing weak team play they all shall.JoeVols said:This is exactly why I posted earlier in this thread that he's playing too many games. Why not give him a rest now and then? Now he gets hurt playing in a tie that we were already 6-0 up.
Am I the only one who sees this? Why keep playing him game after game, esp. this one? Madness.
Churchill123
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 10 Apr 2012
- Messages
- 2,965
celf said:George Hannah said:Alf still looked in pain after the game, couldn't lift his arm to shake hands. Looks like a dislocated or broken collarbone to me. Reporter told Manuel post match he was limping down the tunnel, Manuel shrugged and said "Alvaro has a pain in his shoulder - we will see tomorrow."
Bad news tomorrow I think.
the medical team would have had him off in a flash if there was anything serious…...
Agreed that i think if it was proper serious he would have come off for the last few mins - although it did worry me that after the game someone just tapped him on the shoulder when shaking hands, and he instantly flinched and went to hold his shoulder... :S
IF... it is a broken collar bone like a few have mentioned then he's fucked - collar bones are notorious for being slow to heal/difficult
Fingers crossed the lads ok - we need him for the up and coming games
Churchill123
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 10 Apr 2012
- Messages
- 2,965
celf said:George Hannah said:Alf still looked in pain after the game, couldn't lift his arm to shake hands. Looks like a dislocated or broken collarbone to me. Reporter told Manuel post match he was limping down the tunnel, Manuel shrugged and said "Alvaro has a pain in his shoulder - we will see tomorrow."
Bad news tomorrow I think.
the medical team would have had him off in a flash if there was anything serious…...
Agreed that i think if it was proper serious he would have come off for the last few mins - although it did worry me that after the game someone just tapped him on the shoulder when shaking hands, and he instantly flinched and went to hold his shoulder... :S
IF... it is a broken collar bone like a few have mentioned then he's fucked - collar bones are notorious for being slow to heal/difficult
Fingers crossed the lads ok - we need him for the up and coming games<br /><br />-- Tue Jan 21, 2014 10:34 pm --<br /><br />
celf said:George Hannah said:Alf still looked in pain after the game, couldn't lift his arm to shake hands. Looks like a dislocated or broken collarbone to me. Reporter told Manuel post match he was limping down the tunnel, Manuel shrugged and said "Alvaro has a pain in his shoulder - we will see tomorrow."
Bad news tomorrow I think.
the medical team would have had him off in a flash if there was anything serious…...
Agreed that i think if it was proper serious he would have come off for the last few mins - although it did worry me that after the game someone just tapped him on the shoulder when shaking hands, and he instantly flinched and went to hold his shoulder... :S
IF... it is a broken collar bone like a few have mentioned then he's fucked - collar bones are notorious for being slow to heal/difficult
Fingers crossed the lads ok - we need him for the up and coming games
George Hannah
Well-Known Member
My experience is pretty extensive after fracturing my own collar bone - the bones don't have to be sticking out of your shoulder and you can continue to play after a fashion - but perhaps you know better?Zin 'messiah' Zimmer said:George Hannah said:Alf still looked in pain after the game, couldn't lift his arm to shake hands. Looks like a dislocated or broken collarbone to me. Reporter told Manuel post match he was limping down the tunnel, Manuel shrugged and said "Alvaro has a pain in his shoulder - we will see tomorrow."
Bad news tomorrow I think.
And how does a broken collarbone look? Nonsense
If you'd experienced one or seen up close someone who has just received one, you'd know (a) he wouldn't be coming back on and (b) he certainly would be doing more than wincing!
I've broken my collarbone in a basketball game and continued for the last few minutes of the game before winding up being out for 8 weeks. And just as a recent story in the NFL-QB Aaron Rodgers broke his in a game and was throwing a football on the sideline trying to warm up and get back out on the field. He wasn't let back on but would up being out for 8 weeks as well. Obviously it's all speculation, but it is quite possible to carry on with a broken collarbone, especially with all the adrenaline pumping through your body.
Alan Oakes Shinpads
Well-Known Member
Could well be a "stinger"
Happens a lot in rugby, very painful initially due to shock to the nerves but usually clears after a few days. If broken, sprained or dislocated he wouldn`t have been able to have carried on
Happens a lot in rugby, very painful initially due to shock to the nerves but usually clears after a few days. If broken, sprained or dislocated he wouldn`t have been able to have carried on
trueblue1972
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 2 Jan 2007
- Messages
- 2,050
And there was of course Bert Trautman ;) but obviously in a game that was won I can't see him staying on if it was that bad
Thanks very much for posting that Cosmin. I've been sat here worrying. Just wish Pellegrini had said that. Perhaps he hadn't had time to talk to the player and medical staff at the time.Cosmin said:Ian Cheeseman @IanCheeseman 14m
#mcfc Negredo shoulder injury not a serious problem according to Pellegrini
prestonibbo_mcfc
Well-Known Member
FFS every thread tonight we have the amateur docs out. Lets just wait and see, instead of scaremongering.
You cannot tell what the problem is, until he's been PROFESSIONALLY examined.
You cannot tell what the problem is, until he's been PROFESSIONALLY examined.
Rammy Blue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 23 May 2008
- Messages
- 32,097
I think he may well have discomfribulated his shoulder.
GXCity
Well-Known Member
I was watching him when he walked off and he was shaking hands using his right which is the side he hurt. If he had seriously damaged his right shoulder he wouldn't have done that. Rest him on Saturday and he will be fine.
D
D
dronefromsector7g
Guest
I know, its so annoying.prestonibbo_mcfc said:FFS every thread tonight we have the amateur docs out. Lets just wait and see, instead of scaremongering.
You cannot tell what the problem is, until he's been PROFESSIONALLY examined.
Obviously a broken toe.
baildon blue
Well-Known Member
Negredo looked ok coming off the pitch . I think he might be rested for Watford . What a striker we have in the beast . This Guy is better than Tevez .
:))))dronefromsector7g said:I know, its so annoying.prestonibbo_mcfc said:FFS every thread tonight we have the amateur docs out. Lets just wait and see, instead of scaremongering.
You cannot tell what the problem is, until he's been PROFESSIONALLY examined.
Obviously a broken toe.
mancity111
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 28 Dec 2013
- Messages
- 1,423
George Hannah said:Alf still looked in pain after the game, couldn't lift his arm to shake hands. Looks like a dislocated or broken collarbone to me. Reporter told Manuel post match he was limping down the tunnel, Manuel shrugged and said "Alvaro has a pain in his shoulder - we will see tomorrow."
Bad news tomorrow I think.
If that was the case he would have been straight off down the tunnel.
Landed on his shoulder blade.
Be amazed if its more than a sore ac joint.