I said commercially as in sales rather than quality.Or unlike you they may like the music and arent stuck up there own arse
And you mentioned commercially so let me understand this
Did morning glory result in a commercial downturn after definitely maybe or did it become one of the biggest selling albums in U.K. history
It’s like city
We don’t need 100 points each season to have a good season do we
I said commercially as in sales rather than quality.
WtSMG was always going to be a huge seller as Britpop was the theme of that period of time.
So, which of their albums are better than Definitely, Maybe in your opinion?
Morning Glory is nowhere near as good as Definitely, Maybe. Don't get me wrong, it's above average, just.Morning glory on a par
Other than that none
Doesn’t make him an average songwriter
He set the bar very high very early
As I said same as city this year
Doesn’t mean everything that follows is crap
Morning Glory is nowhere near as good as Definitely, Maybe. Don't get me wrong, it's above average, just.
Seeing as you are comparing Noel's career to football, I'll ask this..... Are Leicester City a great football team because they won the Premier League once?
Uneducated comparison? I was just going along with the last poster's comment.Quite an uneducated comparison really. Noel has hardly been a one hit wonder as Leicester were has he. He's been knocking out number one songs and albums for 20+ years not just one year. He's been selling stadiums out for 20+ years both as a songwriter and a front man. Ive been fortunate enough to meet both brothers and while I would choose to have a pint with Liam all day long it does not take away from the fact that Noel is one of the best songwriters of the last 20 years. If Leicester have won multiple titles in 20 years time ill be the first person back on here apologising to you.....
Uneducated comparison? I was just going along with the last poster's comment.
Also, Robbie Williams has numerous number ones and sells out stadiums.
Uneducated comparison? I was just going along with the last poster's comment.
Also, Robbie Williams has numerous number ones and sells out stadiums.
Apples and Pears? Can tell you're a Londoner ;-)Different audience. You like comparing apples to pears.
Apples and Pears? Can tell you're a Londoner ;-)
Different audience maybe but it's like you're trying to put Oasis in some kind of elite group of songwriter/musicians and they are nowhere near.
Bands like Blur, Pulp, The Charlatans, Embrace and so on have all made at least one great album that can compare to Oasis' best but they didn't go around banging on about how they are the 'greatest band in the world' at every chance they could grab.
I have watched Supersonic and enjoyed it.all great bands agreed, as for the Gallaghers attitude, it is mainly tongue in cheek and they like to take the piss, at there height i'd say they was the greatest band on the planet - but it's all subjective. i wouldn't put them in a elite group of songwriter/musicians but that still didn't stop them making great music - i cant think of many bands since them to have the same impact they did.
out of interest - have you watched Supersonic ?