You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Pantilimon vs Hart
- Thread starter Johnsonontheleft
- Start date
kippaxchris
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 21 Dec 2011
- Messages
- 2,482
pudge said:How many saves has he had to make in those 3 games?kippaxchris said:pudge said:So based on a hypothetical scenario in opposite land then
As i said Hart isn't playing well at the moment and Costel has waited for his chance so should get it. Add to that Panti's performances in the FA cup and his 3 clean sheets, quality distribution & calmness under pressure in the period where Hart isn't doing very well
Not to sure i think 2 proper saves against Watford 1 being a brilliant save 1v1 with Forrestieri against who was on fire at the time and had a clean run from the halfway line and time to pick his spot. He saved a Ross McCormack free kick with ease against Leeds and pushed it out of the box when Joe does wrong foot himself a lot when facing free kicks (NOT PICKING ON JOE HES BRILLIANT) and i think the commentator on the highlights show was Burley who said Panti fooled McCormack by not moving across to soon. Hes done well from corners and crosses particularly against Stoke and of course his distribution adds to what he has done its not all about saves.
He's had to do the bare minimum. Stoke, Watford and Leeds had very few shots on goal or an overall threat.kippaxchris said:pudge said:How many saves has he had to make in those 3 games?kippaxchris said:As i said Hart isn't playing well at the moment and Costel has waited for his chance so should get it. Add to that Panti's performances in the FA cup and his 3 clean sheets, quality distribution & calmness under pressure in the period where Hart isn't doing very well
Not to sure i think 2 proper saves against Watford 1 being a brilliant save 1v1 with Forrestieri against who was on fire at the time and had a clean run from the halfway line and time to pick his spot. He saved a Ross McCormack free kick with ease against Leeds and pushed it out of the box when Joe does wrong foot himself a lot when facing free kicks (NOT PICKING ON JOE HES BRILLIANT) and i think the commentator on the highlights show was Burley who said Panti fooled McCormack by not moving across to soon. Hes done well from corners and crosses particularly against Stoke and of course his distribution adds to what he has done its not all about saves.
And he's done it, fair play to him.
But he has done nothing in terms of "Wow, he should play ahead of Joe".
He's a solid backup. If people were willing to forget any mistake Joe made as quick as they are with Pantilimon's (howler in the CS) it wouldn't be an issue.
Some just want change for the sake of it. How will Joe regain his top form or confidence or improve if he get's dropped? There's not many teams with a constant goalkeeper rotation policy
kippaxchris
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 21 Dec 2011
- Messages
- 2,482
pudge said:He's had to do the bare minimum. Stoke, Watford and Leeds had very few shots on goal or an overall threat.kippaxchris said:pudge said:How many saves has he had to make in those 3 games?
Not to sure i think 2 proper saves against Watford 1 being a brilliant save 1v1 with Forrestieri against who was on fire at the time and had a clean run from the halfway line and time to pick his spot. He saved a Ross McCormack free kick with ease against Leeds and pushed it out of the box when Joe does wrong foot himself a lot when facing free kicks (NOT PICKING ON JOE HES BRILLIANT) and i think the commentator on the highlights show was Burley who said Panti fooled McCormack by not moving across to soon. Hes done well from corners and crosses particularly against Stoke and of course his distribution adds to what he has done its not all about saves.
And he's done it, fair play to him.
But he has done nothing in terms of "Wow, he should play ahead of Joe".
He's a solid backup. If people were willing to forget any mistake Joe made as quick as they are with Pantilimon's (howler in the CS) it wouldn't be an issue.
Some just want change for the sake of it. How will Joe regain his top form or confidence or improve if he get's dropped? There's not many teams with a constant goalkeeper rotation policy
Thats true he hasn't really had any wow moments away from the Arsenal League Cup game last season and maybe it wouldn't improve Joe's confidence if dropped but it my be a kick up the bum as if to say fix up you can be dropped. I would say Pantilimons mistake against Chelsea could have been avoided if Zaba would have done his job and run with his man but he just stood there and let Sturridge fire a shot in that of course Panti spilled but in all fairness it wasn't even nearly as bad as what Joe did against Southampton and we have seen Joe spill a lot of shots in his time but he has played more games. This is why i would like Panti to get a run so we could see in the Prem what he has to offer coz like you said he looks a solid keeper
whp.blue
Well-Known Member
pudge said:Based on?Robert Jordan said:Johnsonontheleft said:Does Costel deserve a run in the team ahead of Joe at the moment?
Yes!
if nothing else how about the fact that Hart is far too complacent and playing poorly and a spell on the bench may help him focus
stan horne
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 20 Dec 2011
- Messages
- 190
Joe's a top keeper but like anybody needs a wake up call and i think its about due. But i would pick the game maybe Vila in a week or so.
jollylescott
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 28 May 2012
- Messages
- 10,642
When the chips are down true champions rise to the occasion. Joe did that today. A mighty save from Lampards pen.
Yeah.......no.whp.blue said:pudge said:Based on?Robert Jordan said:Yes!
if nothing else how about the fact that Hart is far too complacent and playing poorly and a spell on the bench may help him focus
whp.blue
Well-Known Member
jollylescott said:When the chips are down true champions rise to the occasion. Joe did that today. A mighty save from Lampards pen.
that just masked the fact Hart gave away a penalty by making an unnecessary challenge in the first place
BoyBlue_1985
Well-Known Member
Why don't you just go and piss on his doorstep and get all your anger outwhp.blue said:jollylescott said:When the chips are down true champions rise to the occasion. Joe did that today. A mighty save from Lampards pen.
that just masked the fact Hart gave away a penalty by making an unnecessary challenge in the first place