Pantilimon vs Hart

[Whitefield Blue]

i like joe, he is a good keeper no doubt

i know it probably wont happen, i would just like to see the extent to which panty's distribution would have on our team.

Give panty a run of 3-4 games see how benificail the increased distribution could be . Could be the difference you never know.

Where has this absolute fucking myth come from that Pantilimon is some kind of king distributor of the ball?

God knows. Some kind of myth has developed that Hart's distribution isn't great but nothing could be further from the truth. I've seen some keepers clear it further than Hart, but very few distribute it as accurately as he does.

Opposing teams know that City like to pass the ball our of defence so some respond by closing our defence down and make it difficult for Hart to pick a man out

Dead right! He's absolutely 100% comfortable with the ball at his feet, which was a pleasant change from Given and unlike the shaky Pantilimon who can barely reach half way.

Hart gets stick when he doesn't throw the ball out after catching it but the vast, vast majority of the time the throw out isn't on - which the loud minority of fans haven't got the knowledge to see.

 

[Kippax Street 1880]

Stop saying Harts distribution is accurate. He just smashes long high balls in the general direction of Aguero and hopes for the best or passes it 5 yards to Kompany. 1 in 100 times he will throw it out quickly to a fullback. I have no idea why this hasn't been coached out of him as he seems pretty handy with his feet for a keeper, but it needs to stop.

 

[taconinja]

Stop saying Harts distribution is accurate. He just smashes long high balls in the general direction of Aguero and hopes for the best or passes it 5 yards to Kompany. 1 in 100 times he will throw it out quickly to a fullback. I have no idea why this hasn't been coached out of him as he seems pretty handy with his feet for a keeper, but it needs to stop.

Hart's distribution is better when Nastasic is playing on the left side of defense. Much, much better to be honest.

 

[kippaxchris]

i like joe, he is a good keeper no doubt

i know it probably wont happen, i would just like to see the extent to which panty's distribution would have on our team.

Give panty a run of 3-4 games see how benificail the increased distribution could be . Could be the difference you never know.

Where has this absolute fucking myth come from that Pantilimon is some kind of king distributor of the ball?

I take it you haven't watched any of the games Costel has played in? As that's where this fact is coming from. Even the people who don't agree that Panti should be put in for a run of games have noticed and commented on the fact that he has brilliant distribution.

 

[alky313]

Pretty much anything is better than Hart's distribution. Don't give % I can kick it to a fullback to. Costel sees the field much better.

 

[blue wang]

i like joe, he is a good keeper no doubt

i know it probably wont happen, i would just like to see the extent to which panty's distribution would have on our team.

Give panty a run of 3-4 games see how benificail the increased distribution could be . Could be the difference you never know.

Where has this absolute fucking myth come from that Pantilimon is some kind of king distributor of the ball?

I take it you haven't watched any of the games Costel has played in? As that's where this fact is coming from. Even the people who don't agree that Panti should be put in for a run of games have noticed and commented on the fact that he has brilliant distribution.

theez only theez,

harts distribution : is run quickly to the edge of the box, bounce ball twice ,
look, see something, doubt himself,give some one a bollocking , safety first, boot to dzeko
or midget.

panty
, gets ball. looks left back ,right back. long arm swings round and we are on the counter 20-30 meters up the pitch, all in the blink of an eye

 

[sir baconface]

Is he really going backwards or just having a more erratic season - like some of his colleagues?

 

[Seosa]

Hart's distribution for us is appalling.

 

[sergiokun]

If we beat barnsley and get into the semi at wembley will he stick with Pantilimon or pick Hart

 

[Seosa]

If we beat barnsley and get into the semi at wembley will he stick with Pantilimon or pick Hart

Pick Hart, probably.