Penalty Taker

Who should take penalties if Haaland is not on the pitch?


  • Total voters
    387
In all fairness most City fans including me were happy with Gündoğan taking the penalty due to his normally a very good conversion rate.

Lloris was actually off his line before the penalty was taken & should have been retaken but got lost in the aftermath.
 
Why didn't Aguero shoot? He scored the last 4. Whatever let's Make another Problem out of nothing. Everything needs to be discussed i guess.
Aguero's last 5 penalties:
1. Atalanta (H)
2. Watford (H)
3. West Ham (A) - missed but retaken due to Rice clearing the ball and scores
4. Tottenham (A) - missed
5. Swansea (A) - pen saved, scores on the rebound

Gundo's last 9 penalties before today: Literally all straight forward goals.
 
Aguero's last 5 penalties:
1. Atalanta (H)
2. Watford (H)
3. West Ham (A) - missed but retaken due to Rice clearing the ball and scores
4. Tottenham (A) - missed
5. Swansea (A) - pen saved, scores on the rebound

Gundo's last 9 penalties before today: Literally all straight forward goals.

You can't really argue with Gundogan's conversion rate but his technique is very poor. He doesn't put enough power on them & a good portion of the penalties he has scored for us the keepers have got hands on them & should have stopped them. The one at home against Leicester this season for instance Schmiechel would have been really annoyed with himself for not saving it, he got a full hand to it & pushed it into he's own net.

Gundogan won't shoot when given the chance in general so he was never going to be the answer.
 
Imagine we are 1 down at Wembley to Grealish worldie and get a pen in the last minute to take us to ET, only one man can save us.
120082669790638673.jpg

But bravo will probably be in net
 
87.09% Aguero (27/31) - all time record in league games
92.30% Aguero (12/13) - PL games under Pep

Not missed one in a league game under Pep since October 2016. It's now February 2020. YaYa excepted, his record in league games more than stacks up against the best.

Better than:
86.36% Kane (19/22)
85.86% Ronaldo (79/92)
85.41% Lampard (41/48)
83.07% Messi (54/65)
82.75% Mario (24/29)
80.43% Shearer (37/46)
(Stats at Nov18 - cba looking it up for those still playing)

Sure, Champions League hasn't been plain sailing where he is 10/13 which is just about the average conversion rate for penalties.

Pissed off he didn't take it today.
 
Imagine we are 1 down at Wembley to Grealish worldie and get a pen in the last minute to take us to ET, only one man can save us.
120082669790638673.jpg

But bravo will probably be in net

Bravo has already scored one league goal.

 
Last edited:
Why do people keep saying KDB? Hasn't he expressed a reticence in the past towards taking them? Plus, the one he's taken for us, he's missed.
hey, I thought so as well, but in the last while on one thread, and i'm not searching for it, iirc there was a quote from KDB about taking pens where he basically said,
"I haven't been asked, if he asks me to take them , I will"
 
87.09% Aguero (27/31) - all time record in league games
92.30% Aguero (12/13) - PL games under Pep

Not missed one in a league game under Pep since October 2016. It's now February 2020. YaYa excepted, his record in league games more than stacks up against the best.

Better than:
86.36% Kane (19/22)
85.86% Ronaldo (79/92)
85.41% Lampard (41/48)
83.07% Messi (54/65)
82.75% Mario (24/29)
80.43% Shearer (37/46)
(Stats at Nov18 - cba looking it up for those still playing)

Sure, Champions League hasn't been plain sailing where he is 10/13 which is just about the average conversion rate for penalties.

Pissed off he didn't take it today.

Yes, we tend to think that being awarded a penalty is tantamount to a goal ... asthough 99% of penalties are converted.

But actually many more pens are missed than we imagine ... I think overall about 1 in 5 pens are missed even at the very top level.

PS: scary that Ronaldo has taken nearly 100 penalties in league games alone !
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.