Penalty Taker

Who should take penalties if Haaland is not on the pitch?

  • Total voters
    387
aguerooooo said:
Oh for Mario couldnt be safe near a box of matches but deffo taking a pen I am one of those who cant bare to watch a penalty or even worse penalties I sat with fingers in my ears in my bedroom last week and against Gillingham i did the same enduring the old Wembley rancid stinky bogs But nothing of the sort with Mario it was taking candy from a baby. imho as much as love Serg the trust to take pens is diminishing each time he misses and he will lose confidence
Click to expand...
We replaced Mario easily.It is YaYa we are struggling to replace.
 
karen7 said:
What evidence have you got for bernie?
No-one wanted gundy after he missed his pre-season one,you are a fickle lot
Click to expand...
I've said Bernardo for some time. In the few he's taken in various shootouts he's been excellent. He's also a very cool character and got a cracking shot on him. I'd be happier if it was him than Sergio, because everytime he steps up these days I'm fearing the worst. Doesn't stop him from being the greatest forward in our history though Karen.
 
Posted in the thread yesterday has to be g.jesus or gundogan depending if they are on the pitch at the time,or get ederson to put his foot through them the opposition keeper would be shitting it facing him..
 
domalino said:
Mahrez has missed his last 6 penalties.

Jesus scores 57% - hes actually shit.

Silva has taken two and missed two.

Gundogan has taken 3 in the past 10 years.

Sterling? Really? Really?

Foden? Well I guess if we get a penalty in the last 5 minutes he could be on the pitch, but otherwise hes not even going to be playing for 90% of the penalties we get.


This is exactly what I'm talking about. We have evidence of what these people are like at taking penalties, but you're choosing to ignore all of it.
Click to expand...

I agree, and that’s exactly this threads’ problem.

“I don’t feel confident when Agüero steps up, so he shouldn’t take them” is the new rationale when his penalty taking stats are shown to be above average.

No one gives a fuck how you ‘feel’ when a select player steps up to take a penalty. Rave about Mário all you like, his record didn’t remain impeccable for long did it?

Jesus, Mahrez and David Silva have taken more than one shocker each which makes their record considerably worse than Sergio’s. Kevin, as pointed out, does not take them. Ilkay, again, hardly ever and his pre season penalty was garbage. Sterling appears to either perfect it or risk ballooning it over.

But we will keep going round and round and round in this debate, until either Pep changes based on decisions he would make based on evidence and practice, or the keyboard managers run out of sensible suggestions that could take on the duty. Which, so far based on Pep leaving it up to Sergio, and the constant shouting of the same names into the wind despite contrary evidence, should be soon.
 
Has Aguero had his run? he will take more so we will find out, but moving to the future...
Gabriel scored one in 16-17, then had two misses in 17-18, only 20 yrs. old
since 18-19 he is 3 out of 3 and %100 in shootouts for us, with the one copa miss.
on recent form, his confidence and ability, and most importantly his coolness, gives him the nod for me.
now only 22, no one can argue his playing time behind sergio, but when kun goes and if we can keep Jesus he is going to be massive.
already,
2x prem. titles, 2x league cup, fa cup, 2x shield.
copa america winner, brazil league champ, brazil cup champ, brazil player of the year, brazil golden boot winner, and an Olympic gold medal.
he's got more than enough experience to handle it.
 
I think if Sergio just changed his technique a bit it would be fine, as its been said he rarely hits them with much power so if the keeper guesses right then its a good chance its saved. We have seen ourselves in the recent shootout with Zinchenko that if you hit it hard enough then theres half a chance its going to deflect off the keeper and go in.

Sergio relies heavily on his placement which you could argue is the better technique but putting some force behind it wouldn't be a bad thing.
 
jimharri said:
Has to be someone other than Aguero. I have very little confidence in him scoring from the spot.
Click to expand...

Crazy to say it about an average 29 goal a season man in his time with us but completely agree.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top