Pep Guardiola - 2022/23

Status
Not open for further replies.
Can't get my head around that. Clearly wasnt working from the start yet nothing changed. Slow sideways shite then spamming crosses and hoping. Bernardo needs to be in the middle
Bernardo was in the middle for the last 20 min and we were still poor.

I don't know if it's the WC or the energy level fluctuation during a season, but today we were just poor. I think people are overreacting and if we have to criticize somethkng it would be the 10 onfield players and Pep for not using the bench equally. Ofc this place has zero logic and all is Pep's fault today apparently
 
His game management is bad quite often, usually gets brushed under the rug by a late winner here and there.

Also how inform players get dropped for no reason. Foden after 4 goals and an assist in 2 games, dropped. Grealish everytime he plays well and you think he could start building something, bench. Alvarez scoring everytime he starts, 85th min sub.
Gomez potential to take up the width and allow forward players to shine, Cancelo automatic choice despite being utterly terrible recently.
Same with all cbs, we have too many. Ake is the only one that is actually a decent fullback yet it's Stones and Akanji keep being the ones put out wide and they are shite there, but he keeps doing it. I assume he does it at the cost of younger fullbacks simply to keep our senior cbs happy.

Needs to improve in areas this season, we've been ok as we have had Haaland bailing us out quite often, cant happen every game as seen today.
Very well said. We have ran Cancelo to ground but Wilson Esbrand hasn't seen minutes. He potentially cannot be worse than Cancelo at present. Haaland has covered our cracks this season and has taken all the limelight but other wise this has been weakest we have looked in long time. Also earlier we knew a long winning run was around the corner but this season it doesn't look like it will come. Break has come at right time. Pep has 6 weeks to rethink bcoz his planning on next weeks will define our rest of season. Once club football returns, time won't be there to rethink then as games will come thick and fast. Also young fullbacks will have to br trusted over senior Cbs
 
The wingers being so wide just does not work that welk with this current group.

Foden being wide to let Cancelo inside who is in bad form for a while is not working.

I hope Pep sees the fast wingers in the academy we have for a bit more over the world cup time and tries to let them take the width. And let Cancelo do that on the right side more with Mahrez or Palmer cutting in (or Mebude out wide).

Currently a waste to have Foden, Bernie or even Kev so wide.
 
Last edited:
Starting lineup wasn't what I wanted but it was fine, more than good enough to win, the players simply didn't look up for it. I commented at the match as he made the sub he's asking for us to lose this, mental decision to chase the game so hard when we wasn't losing, gundogan for alvarez was the obvious and still attacking sub, he got that wrong.

Don't blame him for not making more subs though, who's coming on and changing that? Grealish with less goal involvements than John Stones isn't coming on and doing anything to change the game. mahrez, perhaps but hasn't exactly got the form behind him to suggest he would have done something. We needed pace on the wings to help change it from the bench, we don't have any. Today is firmly on the players not Pep.
 
Fucking hell some of the posts on this thread, what a load of bollocks. The players didn’t perform pure and simple.

only last week peps tactical tweaks won us a game with 10 men. The players clearly weren’t at it today and It’s hardly surprising given the World Cup is a career high for most players
 
Awful tactics & selection yet again, why does he continue to select players in roles they can't play? Why does he continue to ask certain players for things they aren't capable of doing?

He's a great manager but these are the reasons we won't win the champions league with Pep.
 
His game management is bad quite often, usually gets brushed under the rug by a late winner here and there.

Also how inform players get dropped for no reason. Foden after 4 goals and an assist in 2 games, dropped. Grealish everytime he plays well and you think he could start building something, bench. Alvarez scoring everytime he starts, 85th min sub.
Gomez potential to take up the width and allow forward players to shine, Cancelo automatic choice despite being utterly terrible recently.
Same with all cbs, we have too many. Ake is the only one that is actually a decent fullback yet it's Stones and Akanji keep being the ones put out wide and they are shite there, but he keeps doing it. I assume he does it at the cost of younger fullbacks simply to keep our senior cbs happy.

Needs to improve in areas this season, we've been ok as we have had Haaland bailing us out quite often, cant happen every game as seen today.
This. This team does not need 5 CBs and none of them (Stones, Akanji, Ake) are good enough at FB.

Go back a while and we had Stones and Dias regularly at CB and noises were Laporte was unhappy. Pep rotated to make sure Laporte got games and stayed. IMO this was worth it because we had 3 top-class CBs and losing Laporte would have been a mistake. It is not the same for Ake and potentially Akanji.

Stones can’t get a game in his best position so that Pep can accommodate this nonsense. The reality should be that if Ake and Akanji don’t like being 4th and 5th choice CBs and the lack of game time that brings…go elsewhere. It sounds harsh but Ake is 100% not world-class level and Akanji has plenty to do to show he should be benching Dias and having Stones being punted out wide. The team is suffering.
 
Starting lineup wasn't what I wanted but it was fine, more than good enough to win, the players simply didn't look up for it. I commented at the match as he made the sub he's asking for us to lose this, mental decision to chase the game so hard when we wasn't losing, gundogan for alvarez was the obvious and still attacking sub, he got that wrong.

Don't blame him for not making more subs though, who's coming on and changing that? Grealish with less goal involvements than John Stones isn't coming on and doing anything to change the game. mahrez, perhaps but hasn't exactly got the form behind him to suggest he would have done something. We needed pace on the wings to help change it from the bench, we don't have any. Today is firmly on the players not Pep.
Love the caveats about the possible changes.
 
Fucking hell some of the posts on this thread, what a load of bollocks. The players didn’t perform pure and simple.

only last week peps tactical tweaks won us a game with 10 men. The players clearly weren’t at it today and It’s hardly surprising given the World Cup is a career high for most players
Indeed why have a manager
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.