Pep Guardiola - 2024/25

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ahhh, good old hindsight.
Im still behind this but we were overall better than against crystal I Must admit. Bournemouth was shite yesterday. And still we were lucky that evanilson strikes the post + we didnt conceded the brain farts at the back except the last minute one.
 
Needs to trust his so called fringe players because if he did we’d have an fa cup and probably a second place finish .
To be fair he prioritised last night's game. Why else start with 2 wingers on Saturday and then ditch both last night. Why else have a young Argentinian on the bench in the Final for the first time.
 
I agree with Guardiola on reducing the size of the squad, but that also means he’ll need to be more flexible, too. The League Cup, for instance, should not be prioritised, and he’ll need to start going to his bench earlier and more often. This season has been unique in terms of injuries, but we lost out on two trophies last season because the squad was already fatigued. Reasoned, in-house discussions should see a compromise.
Interesting comments by him and I wonder if this is where the rifts have come from, leaving 6 players at home not getting even in the squad would start to piss you off, on the flip side had we had a bigger squad when all the injuries started we ma ight not have been in this situation now. He seemed to hint that him and the club may disagree on this so who will win? If he does go for a smaller squad he need to be prepared to use the younger players in the league cup but not whole sale changes and also introduce them more so they can step up, Oreily is a great example of this, he’s looked great since he’s started and there must be more like him.
 
Interesting comments by him and I wonder if this is where the rifts have come from, leaving 6 players at home not getting even in the squad would start to piss you off, on the flip side had we had a bigger squad when all the injuries started we ma ight not have been in this situation now. He seemed to hint that him and the club may disagree on this so who will win? If he does go for a smaller squad he need to be prepared to use the younger players in the league cup but not whole sale changes and also introduce them more so they can step up, Oreily is a great example of this, he’s looked great since he’s started and there must be more like him.
As I’ve said elsewhere, flexibility is needed. Guardiola’s use of substitutions, for example, could be improved. The fear of needing a three-goal cushion before changing means young players are starved of opportunities and others stay on far too long. The home game against Ipswich was a perfect example of our problems and set the tone for the season. However, I fear that his mindset is unlikely to change, particularly post-Feyenoord.

There will undoubtedly be more disagreements between Guardiola and Viana, but these should be kept in-house.
 
Pep has to accept that his first team squad cannot play a potential 63 games a season, and that's not even coupled with the numerous internationals, friendlies and replays, and expect them to be able to perform at the highest level at the close end of the season.

People ARE going to start doubting you if you come out with statements that effectively say "I don't know how to do squad rotation of so many players", It's a long season now, players NEED rest, otherwise they will tire, the team suffers as a result and results themselves suffer. We got these players for him so City could fight on all four fronts, but prioritising the Premier League and Champions League. Don't look a gift horse in the mouth Pep.
 
Last edited:
Some of the post in last few pages is showing that some fans doesn't know what they talking about.

If you have already experiences in leading and managing a group of people (not necessary have to be in football to know that feels), then the ideas of Pep wanting to have small squads is not really surprising.

Some people will pointed about insane schedules, that's not Pep fault FFS. The blame should be put on the football federations and governing bodies for being too greedy wanting to add more match in calendar year regardless the wellbeing and health of the players.
 
Last edited:
As I’ve said elsewhere, flexibility is needed. Guardiola’s use of substitutions, for example, could be improved. The fear of needing a three-goal cushion before changing means young players are starved of opportunities and others stay on far too long. The home game against Ipswich was a perfect example of our problems and set the tone for the season. However, I fear that his mindset is unlikely to change, particularly post-Feyenoord.

There will undoubtedly be more disagreements between Guardiola and Viana, but these should be kept in-house.

I wonder if your last line is why Txiki is staying on until the transfer window is over? To maybe talk to Pep, try and keep him calm etc? He`s not bigger than the club though and shouldnt be allowed to dictate beyond his position.
 
I wonder if your last line is why Txiki is staying on until the transfer window is over? To maybe talk to Pep, try and keep him calm etc? He`s not bigger than the club though and shouldnt be allowed to dictate beyond his position.
Perhaps. No individual is bigger than the club, including Viana and Guardiola, but they all share the same end goal. Consensus will be reached, but you’d better brace yourself for incremental change. ;-)
 
Some of the post in last few pages is showing that some fans doesn't know what they talking about.

If you have already experiences in leading and managing people, (not necessary have to be in football to know that feels) then the ideas of Pep wanting to have small squads is not really surprising.

Some people will pointed about insane schedules, that's not Pep fault FFS. The blame should be put on the football federations and governing bodies for being too greedy wanting to add more match in calendar year regardless the wellbeing and health of the players.
No, it isn't Pep's "fault" for the volume of games, you're right, but it IS a reality of the game now and Pep has to accept his players are not robots, not machines and they will tire and tired players will put in subpar performances and this will happen at the crucial point of the season; semi-finals, title run-in etc.

This wouldn't be an issue if the board didn't want City to compete at the highest level; they do, so they've given Pep many options to rotate and manage his squad to keep his first team healthy and fit for the crucial stage of the season. If Pep is now saying he cannot do this then naturally it's going to raise questions about his ability to continue having the club competing for honours, because if he thinks a squad of 16 can compete throughout the entire season and not see a major drop off in performances, like we have done this year, we can forget about seeing a repeat of our dominance era.
 
No issues with a smaller squad - Pep has always worked that way. However a small squad requires high class players in each position.

What has fucked us over is we havent secured our first choice targets in the transfer windows of late, Throw on top a huge injury list and an ageing squad and we were left with the season we have witnessed.

Yes we will clear out the players no longer deemed good enough to perform at the level Pep needs - but we have to make sure we replace with actual quality
 
Perhaps. No individual is bigger than the club, including Viana and Guardiola, but they all share the same end goal. Consensus will be reached, but you’d better brace yourself for incremental change. ;-)

They will of course share the goal of winning mate but Pep cant be allowed to throw his toys out of the pram?
 
Some of the post in last few pages is showing that some fans doesn't know what they talking about.

If you have already experiences in leading and managing people, (not necessary have to be in football to know that feels) then the ideas of Pep wanting to have small squads is not really surprising.

Some people will pointed about insane schedules, that's not Pep fault FFS. The blame should be put on the football federations and governing bodies for being too greedy wanting to add more match in calendar year regardless the wellbeing and health of the players.
He’s managed in La Liga and Bundesliga those leagues are less punishing on players than our league so a small squad can be utilised, this season has shown you reach a breaking point and the Rodri injury I’m surprised didn’t happen earlier or to more players. KDB has really only played half a season for past 3 seasons due to injury, is it possible we could’ve had more from him if he had the chance to rest with a bigger squad, who knows now, Stones is another. Lots of the players over the last 4 years have played around 200 games plus international competitions without a serious break and now we go to the club World Cup that’s nearly 5 years, you cannot stay at the top of your game with that sort of schedule. Yes players maybe unhappy not been in the squad but then Pep should have maybe 18 top players and then get the youngsters in and give them minutes by using 5 subs so if called on they are ready to step up.
 
Nailed the starting line up today, didn't see the pre-match thread but I bet the usual suspects weren't happy when he named the OAP's.

Bar Southampton (A) and United (A) he's done well this calendar year. His team on Saturday should have got the job done too but let him down with the finishing (and the officials).

Get the first choice targets this summer, Rodri fit and we'll be back at it next year.

In 2025 we actually have picked up results:
View attachment 157064

I know there are different circumstances for other clubs etc...but the form has been better. I'm confident it'll be much better next season.

I see the rags are very consistent
 
Anyone feel could be tensions between Pep and Vianna? The timing was all wrong tbh. It should of been pep and txixi leaving together whenever that may be, and Vianna and a new man who are aligned building a new team
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top