Pep's contract situation | 2 year extension confirmed! (pg1817)

peace frog said:
yeah but apart from that, you rally are a font of knowledge and if people actually read about the subject they state as fact this place would be better off for it, take hansi flick haha
Click to expand...

To be honest I had no idea about Flick's background until a few good pieces came out on him in the last few weeks in the buildup to the CL final.
 
MillsyTheMosher said:
Having a chat with my mate about this last night.

I was saying that for me it’s a no brainer to give Vincent the managers/head coach role when Pep decides to go.

Yes, he hasn’t got much managerial experience but what he has got is exceptional people skills, natural leadership, respect and authority which is more than half the battle. He also know the club and hierarchy inside out.

Experience is often over rated for me. Take Hansi Flick for example. Only ever been an assistant- he’s given an opportunity and wins everything.

It’s a big yes from me and I hope we can welcome Vincent home soon.
Click to expand...
Absolute no from me. you want him for the wrong reason. You even say he hasn't much managerial skills. Take the emotion out of the argument and you will see it would be for all the wrong reasons.

If we were considering him as a replacement, he would be best served sat alongside Pep now don't you think.
 
peoffrey said:
How do you get experience if nobody gives you a shot?
Click to expand...

Kompany has been given a shot. Now he has to do well at Anderlecht. Get them into the Europa/CL and do well there.

Get a more high profile job after that and do well there.
 
domalino said:
Kompany has been given a shot. Now he has to do well at Anderlecht. Get them into the Europa/CL and do well there.

Get a more high profile job after that and do well there.
Click to expand...

Doing well at Anderlecht should be enough. Frank Lampard at Chelsea is a fair comparison. I think they'll surprise people next season.
 
Christ I hear some rubbish spouted about Vinny not having enough experience or being unproven, well would those people rather have Ancelotti, Mourinho or even Benitez? All have experience, all have had previous success at times but none of them would guarantee us anything with regard to success nor would any of their like be desperate to succeed. For me Vinny is an absolute must and it would be much easier to accept any dip during a rebuild with him in charge rather than people who have zero affiliation to our club like all these new kids on the block.

There is a reason Barca have gone to Koeman and Madrid have Zidane, and it wasn't because Koeman won fuck all at Everton nor Zidane had no experience, it was because they understand and align their philosophies to their clubs.
 
The trend of throwing an ex player into a role too big for them seems to be gathering pace. As much as I love Kompany and hope it will happen some day it is far too much of a risk.
 
MaineRoadBlue said:
Christ I hear some rubbish spouted about Vinny not having enough experience or being unproven, well would those people rather have Ancelotti, Mourinho or even Benitez? All have experience, all have had previous success at times but none of them would guarantee us anything with regard to success nor would any of their like be desperate to succeed. For me Vinny is an absolute must and it would be much easier to accept any dip during a rebuild with him in charge rather than people who have zero affiliation to our club like all these new kids on the block.

There is a reason Barca have gone to Koeman and Madrid have Zidane, and it wasn't because Koeman won fuck all at Everton nor Zidane had no experience, it was because they understand and align their philosophies to their clubs.
Click to expand...

You use the word rubbish, that sums your post up perfectly.
 
B\connellblue said:
Well it's high time we had a good enough defence. What are our recruitment team at? People are far too forgiving as far as the champions League goes. I hope Pep is embarrassed by losing to Lyon ,if not he should be. He has not improved out fortunes one iota in that competition . had we went down all guns blazing fair enough but we didn't and the way Pep set us up was the main reason for that. Missed opportunity for me.
Click to expand...
Disagree about Walker imo one of the best right backs the club has had and still head and shoulders above Cancelo
 
Not a chance yet and if he was to take it it would be the first red flag that he’s not ready for it.

I’m not happy with Pep right now, but I struggle to see who fills that role right now. Nagelsmann and Tuchel will be the trendy picks but let’s sit back and see what the next year brings.
 
There's plenty of time for Vinnie to come back to the club. He needs to broaden his horizons first, get himself some experience and I'm sure eventually he'll return in some capacity.
 
MillsyTheMosher said:
Having a chat with my mate about this last night.

I was saying that for me it’s a no brainer to give Vincent the managers/head coach role when Pep decides to go.

Yes, he hasn’t got much managerial experience but what he has got is exceptional people skills, natural leadership, respect and authority which is more than half the battle. He also know the club and hierarchy inside out.

Experience is often over rated for me. Take Hansi Flick for example. Only ever been an assistant- he’s given an opportunity and wins everything.

It’s a big yes from me and I hope we can welcome Vincent home soon.
Click to expand...
Vinnie has had one (curtailed) season as coach of a mid table team in Belgium, and hasn’t even got his full coaching badges yet. There may well come a time, and I really hope there does, but not yet, for a few years
 
After a couple of (hopefully successful) years gaining experience at Anderlecht, I hope this happens. I get the feeling the club see this as the long term plan too

Don't forget, Pep had zero experience coaching at first team level when he took the big job at Barca... he hasn't done too bad
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top