Political relations between UK-EU

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ric
  • Start date Start date
Yours wasn’t particularly bad but there was a slight tone and it came after 3 abusive posts so got thrown in with them.

I am more than happy to have a calm conversation.

I understand it sounds daft, it’s not logically sound for the economy but the idea of the UK not being in the driving seat of its own trade arrangements doesn’t sit well with me. The economic impacts of Brexit don’t outweigh that for me.

I’d rather have just remained though.

I thought you were a local to me, in Saddleworth? I’m Oldham based and have played at Saddleworth golf club a few times, decent but very hilly and old man’s legs have gone.

Did you move?

I think the Scots will go and then NI to be honest, I happen to think it’s politically the most sensible thing as the division and hatred is too heated in the UK, it’s fractured and goes well beyond disliking Tories.
I moved a little time ago (55 years to be precise) I went to primary school in Uppermill which is when I fell in love with City. Haven’t been back since but thought that using a local area as my username would buy me some street cred. ;-). (It didn’t).
We aren’t in the driving seat though as we will be the smaller party in many meaningful negotiations Eu, Us, China etc. We might do some deals with Canada Australia and the like to bring in cheap meat and further fuck our farmers but I don’t really see that as a benefit.
 
You mean you weren't including me when called most of the posters on this thread a bunch of tossers?
You've been slagging people off on here left right and centre.
And nobody actually called you stupid. You were accused of making a stupid argument which is hardly the same thing. As I said, I'm not interested in having a discussion with someone who is so fucking sensitive that they take offence at people making robust points.
This is childish.

Have a good day
 
I moved a little time ago (55 years to be precise) I went to primary school in Uppermill which is when I fell in love with City. Haven’t been back since but thought that using a local area as my username would buy me some street cred. ;-). (It didn’t).
We aren’t in the driving seat though as we will be the smaller party in many meaningful negotiations Eu, Us, China etc. We might do some deals with Canada Australia and the like to bring in cheap meat and further fuck our farmers but I don’t really see that as a benefit.
Saddleworth is alright to be fair, compared to Oldham. I don’t think most blues care where people are from, a City fan is a City fan as far as I’m concerned.
 
God help us if you’re right.
I still think 5 years for NI/Ireland reunification is too soon, although I do think it is the most logical solution to the island and should never have been allowed happen in the first place.
However, Brexit has opened old wounds and shown that there is a ton of work to be done before coming up with a two strand solution that satisfies both of the major communities.
Oh it’ll be carnage if NI goes, the loyalist movement won’t go quietly, I know that.
 
Saddleworth is alright to be fair, compared to Oldham. I don’t think most blues care where people are from, a City fan is a City fan as far as I’m concerned.
;-) usually means you have your tongue in your cheek or are not altogether being serious.

My memory of Oldham is many many huge chimneys, I would have thought not many left now. Uppermill was a nice little village if i remember correctly, Whit walk up t' church, brass band competition on t' village green afterwards. The snow of 63 that was many times deeper than I was tall, folk walking back down the hill after searching saddleworth moor for one of Brady's victims. Funny the things you remember quite clearly.

anyhow, thats straying a bit off topic.
 
;-) usually means you have your tongue in your cheek or are not altogether being serious.

My memory of Oldham is many many huge chimneys, I would have thought not many left now. Uppermill was a nice little village if i remember correctly, Whit walk up t' church, brass band competition on t' village green afterwards. The snow of 63 that was many times deeper than I was tall, folk walking back down the hill after searching saddleworth moor for one of Brady's victims. Funny the things you remember quite clearly.

anyhow, thats straying a bit off topic.
I’ll just leave it as… it’s not great but it’s home
 
Oh it’ll be carnage if NI goes, the loyalist movement won’t go quietly, I know that.
The GFA is their greatest protection, I’ve always said, but some can’t see it.
It will be carnage and the selfish in me would say we don’t need that hassle down south.
But the truth is we owe it to the republican community who were left behind by no fault of their own, in a state that most down south logically feel should never have happened.

That’s not to forget all the mistakes and faults made on both sides, and I’m not talking of just the atrocities of the troubles. Ive made my point of view made countless times in the Irish thread about mistakes made by the Irish government and I’m no great fan of DeValera, so I won’t pollute this thread with more of that.
 
You made an 'observation' that was factually incorrect.

Whilst immigration was pushed as a reason for leaving the EU by the liars of the Leave campaign it was not valid. Much like the rest of the Leave lies that were swallowed hook line and sinker by much of the population.
Whilst you believe it's not valid millions of others believed it was and tbf we live in a 1 person 1 vote nation were all are equally valid.
 
Whilst you believe it's not valid millions of others believed it was and tbf we live in a 1 person 1 vote nation were all are equally valid.

You seem to be missing the point that we could have controlled our immigration within the EU but chose not to do so.

Thus making leaving the EU to control immigration an invalid reason.

That many believed this lie, along with the many others told, does not validate the lie.

I did not say anyone's vote was invalid, that is for the individual to decide.
 
Last edited:
God help us if you’re right.
I still think 5 years for NI/Ireland reunification is too soon, although I do think it is the most logical solution to the island and should never have been allowed happen in the first place.
However, Brexit has opened old wounds and shown that there is a ton of work to be done before coming up with a two strand solution that satisfies both of the major communities.
You mean Ireland should never have been split in the first place or the opportunity for N Ireland to reunify shouldn't have been allowed?
 
You seem to be missing the point that we could have controlled our immigration within the EU but chose not to do so.

Thus making leaving the EU to control immigration an invalid reason.

That many believed this lie, along with the many others told, does not validate the lie.
Not missing the point at all. I fully understand we could to a certain extent do that my point is if millions feel that we needed to pull out to effectively do that makes that point to them valid regardless of what you, I or anyone else may say.
 
Not missing the point at all. I fully understand we could to a certain extent do that my point is if millions feel that we needed to pull out to effectively do that makes that point to them valid regardless of what you, I or anyone else may say.
Yes it does. It doesn't mean they haven't been misled though.
 
Fuck me, another insufferable rude get.

I voted remain.

The reason being is I didn’t know enough so better the devil you know.

Think I’m done with this page unless I have to respond to any more abuse.

I didn't say a thing about the way you voted. You said in an earlier post that you didn't have a clue in 2016. Want me to find that post for you? So when I refer to 'people like you' I'm doing nothing more than rely on what you have yourself said.

Whether you voted leave or not, there was a very sizeable constituency of people who voted leave with as little understanding of the issues as you. Many voted leave thinking they would be getting things that they weren't. Or are you saying you were alone in not knowing what you were voting for in 2016? They are people like you, because they didn't know what they were voting for in 2016, and they bear a lot of the responsibility for where we are now as a nation and where they are going.

If you think it's insufferable for others to point to what you yourself said in an earlier post, good luck with the world.
 
Last edited:
I didn't say a thing about the way you voted. You said in an earlier post that you didn't have a clue in 2016. Want me to find that post for you? So when I refer to 'people like you' I'm doing nothing more than rely on what you have yourself said.

Whether you voted leave or not, there was a very sizeable constituency of people who voted leave with as little understanding of the issues as you. Many voted leave thinking they would be getting things that they weren't. Or are you saying you were alone in not knowing what you were voting for in 2016? They are people like you, because they didn't know what they were voting for in 2016, and they bear a lot of the responsibility for where we are now as a nation and where they are going.

If you think it's insufferable for others to point to what you yourself said in an earlier post, good luck with the world.

“The leave campaign just lied about it. If only people like you had taken the time to understand the arguments in 2016.”

This is what you said, don’t forget a second pretend you didn’t think I voted leave in you saying that.

I genuinely don’t believe anyone really knew, those leading either campaign included. I don’t think you knew what you were voting for either. Even people who were paid to know, in hindsight, were talking absolute waffle.

People can pretend they did and say now they knew exactly what was going to happen but very few were saying it in 2016.

Nobody who voted in 2016 is guilty of anything today and the voting booth is anonymous, so blaming anyone for the political situation 5 years later is wrong.

Even if people voted for Brexit, they didn’t vote for how it was going to be handled by the government.

And regarding the “mess” people are talking about, I think that’s being a little overplayed but we’ll see how it plays out.
 
You mean Ireland should never have been split in the first place or the opportunity for N Ireland to reunify shouldn't have been allowed?
Purely my own view, but the split shouldn’t have happened in the first place if democracy was being upheld, but there are a number of extenuating circumstances from that period which influenced the course of events.
 
“The leave campaign just lied about it. If only people like you had taken the time to understand the arguments in 2016.”

This is what you said, don’t forget a second pretend you didn’t think I voted leave in you saying that.

I genuinely don’t believe anyone really knew, those leading either campaign included. I don’t think you knew what you were voting for either. Even people who were paid to know, in hindsight, were talking absolute waffle.

People can pretend they did and say now they knew exactly what was going to happen but very few were saying it in 2016.

Nobody who voted in 2016 is guilty of anything today and the voting booth is anonymous, so blaming anyone for the political situation 5 years later is wrong.

Even if people voted for Brexit, they didn’t vote for how it was going to be handled by the government.

And regarding the “mess” people are talking about, I think that’s being a little overplayed but we’ll see how it plays out.
The 'mess' is still in its infancy, we are still currently in the amuse bouche stage. Every day it gets a little bit worse etc etc. and with a cabinet who is not serious about doing its job, that isn't going to stop any time soon.

As for people not knowing what they were voting for, a lot of us did. I voted remain as i didn't want the giant mega-cunts who were fronting the leave campaign to get into power, which it was obvious they would if leave won. I also thought it would be really stupid to tell our major trading partner to fuck off. It was. I also have technical knowledge regarding some of the customs arrangements that we had in place and was aware that extracting ourselves from that was going to be a complete shit show. Brexit voters need to grow some fucking balls and admit they fucked up when it becomes apparent to them that it's a mess. Saying it's 'no-one's fault' is bullshit.
 
The 'mess' is still in its infancy, we are still currently in the amuse bouche stage. Every day it gets a little bit worse etc etc. and with a cabinet who is not serious about doing its job, that isn't going to stop any time soon.

As for people not knowing what they were voting for, a lot of us did. I voted remain as i didn't want the giant mega-cunts who were fronting the leave campaign to get into power, which it was obvious they would if leave won. I also thought it would be really stupid to tell our major trading partner to fuck off. It was. I also have technical knowledge regarding some of the customs arrangements that we had in place and was aware that extracting ourselves from that was going to be a complete shit show. Brexit voters need to grow some fucking balls and admit they fucked up when it becomes apparent to them that it's a mess. Saying it's 'no-one's fault' is bullshit.
Well I’m not a Brexit voter, I voted remain because I didn’t have a clue.

Well done for knowing yourself though.

I don’t believe they need to answer anything though, voting is anonymous and it’s none of your business what other people vote for.
 
Yes it does. It doesn't mean they haven't been misled though.
Which is exactly what I said in my original post. Had to cut and paste quote not working.

Think you are right on the original arguments. Behind the misrepresentation there was a choice to carry on as we were or sacrifice on the financial front whilst controlling immigration it would appear that immigration is a big thing to the majority of Brits (that voted) although not on this forum hence the Victor Meldrew appreciation society are out in force
 
“The leave campaign just lied about it. If only people like you had taken the time to understand the arguments in 2016.”

This is what you said, don’t forget a second pretend you didn’t think I voted leave in you saying that.

I genuinely don’t believe anyone really knew, those leading either campaign included. I don’t think you knew what you were voting for either. Even people who were paid to know, in hindsight, were talking absolute waffle.

People can pretend they did and say now they knew exactly what was going to happen but very few were saying it in 2016.

Nobody who voted in 2016 is guilty of anything today and the voting booth is anonymous, so blaming anyone for the political situation 5 years later is wrong.

Even if people voted for Brexit, they didn’t vote for how it was going to be handled by the government.

And regarding the “mess” people are talking about, I think that’s being a little overplayed but we’ll see how it plays out.

Wrong.

The £350m on the side of the bus for the NHS was untrue.

The claim about recovering sovereignty was a lie. If you understood what sovereignty was, you knew we hadn't lost it. Those who said we needed to leave to recover our sovereignty either didn't know what sovereignty was or did know but were lying.

The claims that we needed to leave the EU to be able to curb immigration were untrue. We always had the ability to curb immigration, we just chose not to use it.

The idea that we could retain full free movement of goods and services whilst abandoning freedom of movement was a lie.

The idea that departure from the CU/SM was consistent with the Good Friday Agreement was untrue. Suggestions a 'technological solution' would overcome that problem were untrue because the technology didn't then and still doesn't exist.

The suggestion that we were powerless to prevent Turkey accessing the EU was a lie.

There are many more examples of things that were said by Leave at the time that were called out as being untrue. These things were out there in the public domain for those who took the time to understand the arguments. You, if your earlier posts are to be taken at face value, were one of the ones who didn't.

And since you mention me, I knew exactly what I was voting for. I wasn't sure what I was voting against, because some people said leaving didn't mean we would leave the Single Market, others said it did. Some said the vote would be purely advisory, which in law it was, others said it would be an instruction from the British people. But I recognise a crock of shit when I see one, and that's exactly what Leave were. And I recognised each of the above instances and many more as being a pack of lies.

I don't give a shit which way you voted. You voted from a position of ignorance. So did many others, and their votes, cast in ignorance, without a clue what they were voting for and without understanding what the consequences of leaving would be, are responsible for the biggest act of economic self-harm any nation has inflicted upon itself in peacetime. I do hold them responsible for that. You are free to forgive that ignorant act of economic vandalism if you want to, that's up to you, but don't you dare presume that you can tell me who I can and cannot hold responsible for the shitstorm that has been created.

'Biggest act of economic self-harm ever' is not, by the way, a forecast, it is a description of where we are right now. Already more than £1 trillion has quietly been moved out of the UK economy since the Brexit vote that would otherwise be in circulation within the UK. Try researching how much Mark Carney spent the day after the result to avoid the worst case scenario after the the vote to leave. We have cut ourselves off from being able to trade freely - as in without tariffs and quotas or not-tariff barriers - with the biggest single economic bloc in the world.

And why? Because people, like you, who didn't have a fucking clue what they were doing, voted for it.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top