POLL ....... Hart or Given

[johnny on the spot]

Given. Though in terms of distribution it's as if Andreas Isaksson never left.

 

[PSmyth07]

If Hart is happy to go out on loan and to come back to us, then i'd go for Given.

If he isn't happy to go on loan and wants a pernament move instead, then i'd keep Hart.

 

[Chippy_boy]

Hart

Given is very overrated imho. Keep hearing what a great stopper he is. True. But so are most goalkeepers.

What differentiates them more is their command of their area, how they deal with crosses and their distribution. Given is poor to crap at all of this.

 

[DontLookBackInAnger]

I would go with Hart

 

[billy_big_spuds]

Joe Hart, definately.
Given has done nothing but go backwards all season. He's getting worse with each game.
There was a heart stopping moment on monday at the south stand end when Wigan floated one across goal that should have been a tap in for them. Shay didn't even attempt to go for it. They should have scored that really....

 

[MadchesterCity]

If we reach Champions League we will need both Hart and Given

They will then fight it out to see who is first choice!

They both have different strengths and weaknesses

 

[ShaunyWrightWright]

Joe Hart.

 

[Bill]

Hart

Given is very overrated imho. Keep hearing what a great stopper he is. True. But so are most goalkeepers.

What differentiates them more is their command of their area, how they deal with crosses and their distribution. Given is poor to crap at all of this.

shay has saved us on countless occasions, we would have conceded had joe be in goal at the time.

 

[migmanc]

Given

 

[Lrrr]

Hart, he may just be able to kick a ball to one of our own players and reach the crossbar.