Both, let them fight it out for the no 1 shirt, we need a back-up of top quality, the so called top four have suffered when they have had their no 1 out, Chelsea a prime example.
If we are to challenge on 4 fronts next season we need good cover.
Given is quality, but his distribution is poor and he struggles with crosses. Hart as improved this season, we shouldn't give anyone the benefit of having him on loan.