Post Match Thread - United (h)

Quite strange really. I don't know whether it's because I am going off football generally because of VAR etc, or maybe because Liverpool is the now the club to hate.

But in my 53 years of watching City, I can never remember being so un-bothered by a derby defeat. We were bloody useless again and I just sat and watched it quite emotionless. I get more wound up on the political forums.
On the VAR element of your post, in the first 10 mins yesterday I knew we were going to get fucked by it. There were a couple of instances where Taylor made a big point of holding up the game whilst putting his hand to his ear, even for innocuous bollocks. Immediately I said to the guys around me that they were setting us up for it, it was so bloody obvious.
 
Yes, I posted on the night that the team’s performance on Tuesday at Burnley made me feel a little ashamed that I’d doubted them. But it seems to be a case of one step forward, one step back at the moment. (And a derby defeat does intensify the hurt.) I agree completely about the players we have and about the woeful officiating that is screwing us but we made it too easy for the Rags yesterday. Of course, it might all look a lot more rosy after the Arsenal and Leicester games!

We do make it easy for teams. There isn't a game where I don't think that every opposition attack, sparse as they might be, will not yield a goal, and once inside the area the slightest tumble will deliver them a penalty courtesy of VAR. At the other end I am convinced that with every attack we will score. But derby matches are up for grabs. Sooner or later the crappier team will win. It took us 35 years didn't it, to win a Swamp derby. I keep telling my ERO the same thing - sooner of later they will beat The Dippers. As for the Arse and Foxes game, I expect the latter will be a repetition of yesterday, woeful officiating and appalling VAR decisions.
 
Can't agree that we've been poor all season because, if that were the case, we'd be nowhere near top four and already qualified for the CL knock-out stage. It just doesn't square. What is clear is that since the beginning of November there's been a terrible decline in the team's performances.
Two or three remarks, though. Not bringing on Foden from about minute 60, when it was crystal clear that neither Merlin nor Kev had been functioning from the beginning of the match, is simply incomprehensible. Bringing him on right at the end is simply an insult. What on earth is Pep thinking? What must the lad be thinking?
Our inability to vary our tactics is worrying. Teams have got us sussed. The pretty passing in an arc from side to side outside their box, waiting for a gap to appear which simply did not appear, was repeated over and over in the most sterile way. One thing we're barely doing, which we executed well during Pep's first season, and brilliantly during the Centurions season: the overlap on both touchlines, and the angled cut-back along the ground right into the opposition box. Walker did it once yesterday in the first half, it didn't get through, but it was beautiful to see. Sane's out, so it's not really an option on the other side (it's unfair to ask either Angeliño or Zin to do it, they just don't have the pace, and in Mendy's case both his pace and confidence are shot). But Pep must have told Walker not to do it, presumably because he doesn't have the legs to get back any more. Whatever it is, we're missing it, direly, as a way of mixing it up, and alternative to the probing through the middle, which absolutely was not working yesterday. High crosses: forget them. They are meat and drink to the opposition, and that is true of virtually everyone we play. Laporte scored the crucial goal at Brighton in the final game last season. Otamendi, yesterday. Two central defenders. That tells you everything you need to know.
And now, something else. A friend I met in the car park afterwards said something that I have to hold my hands up to. We as supporters are really not great. If things are going our way, it's all fine and dandy. It's normal that things should have gone flat after United's second. But I expected us to give the team more in the second half. Even in the south stand, nothing much was happening. A bloke in my row left at half time! I mean, what the actual? Another bloke in my row - a good blue, who I know and like - left fully twenty minutes before the end. Now it's not for me to police other fans' behaviour, but it leaves me very puzzled indeed. I don't care about other club's fans, that's neither here nor there for me. We criticize the players – legitimate – we criticise the manager – legitimate – we might take a good long look at ourselves sometimes. Are we becoming entitled? I hope not.
Oh and one more thing. Two seasons ago, we accumulated a never before seen 100 points, and won two trophies. Last season, we achieved a never before seen domestic treble. These are things I never expected to see, even after the takeover. It is right that we as fans should not forget too quickly. But for any truly great team and manager, these things should be ancient history. Only the current season counts. Only the next match is real. Otherwise, you're already sliding towards a mindset where you've put your slippers on, you've lit your pipe, and you're sitting by the fire reminiscing. I'm a grandfather, but I don't fucking want that! Because there's only one stop after that one...
Yesterday hurts, and will carry on hurting for days, like a burn, but the rags are essentially an irrelevance. Our title challenge is over. The season isn't even half over, and there are trophies to be won. Be critical – that's our prerogative – but let's get behind the fucking team on match days! Otherwise, I mean really, what's the point?
 
We do make it easy for teams. There isn't a game where I don't think that every opposition attack, sparse as they might be, will not yield a goal, and once inside the area the slightest tumble will deliver them a penalty courtesy of VAR. At the other end I am convinced that with every attack we will score. But derby matches are up for grabs. Sooner or later the crappier team will win. It took us 35 years didn't it, to win a Swamp derby. I keep telling my ERO the same thing - sooner of later they will beat The Dippers. As for the Arse and Foxes game, I expect the latter will be a repetition of yesterday, woeful officiating and appalling VAR decisions.

to be honest I think Leicester are the only hope of stopping Liverpool now, however slim that is.

we are gone this season. We will limp to 3/4th. Hopefully get players back for the CL and have a go at that. Need to buy in Jan though whatever the cost.
 
not much else to add that's already been said really ?

i did fear this before the game and warned of this johnny big bollocks going into the derby, with them in mid-table and us retaining champions, it had the stink of them wanting it more and there biggest game of the season there cup final feel, if there was a time and place to play us at the moment then united could not have picked a better time, with the injury hit city squad and the players knowing the title for this season has gone long before the derby kicked off, also add all the eggs in the champions league basket this season then it was coming

lets call it right here its could have been a lot worse ? it could have been 5 or 6 for them if not for ederson 3 major saves before they score from the spot, am not even talking about VAR anymore because what is the point and we all know whats going on and can do nothing about it ??

the idiots in the corner should be banned for life and united will milk it for all its worth, why give them something to rubbish our name again, when one idiot does something like this the whole club takes the blame but this was a group of idiots and a racist and the book should be thrown at all of them
 
Hope I'm wrong but cant see Pep staying after this season
He doesnt look interested at times neither do a lot of the team currently.
 
I know no team will win every game. Did VAR affect the Norwich, Wolves, Utd defeats and Newc draw?No they didn't. Our performances did. There's nothing wrong in admitting our faults because the players and staff will be doing exactly the same. We are below par and that is obvious.

But champions grind out results. We would clearly be a lot better off were we to have put together finer performances, but having said that, how do you translate a better performance into points. You can be the better team and still lose, you can have greater possession, more shots on target, give teams a statistical battering but you accept that as part of the game. It's the nature of the sport. But when we see how VAR is applied there cannot be a clearer example of sporting theft for some teams or sporting largesse for others - clear, obvious, and, I would suggest, quite deliberate in seeking a specific outcome.
 
We massively miss the leadership qualities and passion of the likes of Vinnie and Zabba. They would not have stood for that abject, pathetic, spineless display yesterday.
tbf I watched a few pathetic displays that included vinnie and zabba .imo were fucked from the last two years intensity plus injuries and teams sussing our achilles heel of quick counter attacks
 
Can't agree that we've been poor all season because, if that were the case, we'd be nowhere near top four and already qualified for the CL knock-out stage. It just doesn't square. What is clear is that since the beginning of November there's been a terrible decline in the team's performances.
Two or three remarks, though. Not bringing on Foden from about minute 60, when it was crystal clear that neither Merlin nor Kev had been functioning from the beginning of the match, is simply incomprehensible. Bringing him on right at the end is simply an insult. What on earth is Pep thinking? What must the lad be thinking?
Our inability to vary our tactics is worrying. Teams have got us sussed. The pretty passing in an arc from side to side outside their box, waiting for a gap to appear which simply did not appear, was repeated over and over in the most sterile way. One thing we're barely doing, which we executed well during Pep's first season, and brilliantly during the Centurions season: the overlap on both touchlines, and the angled cut-back along the ground right into the opposition box. Walker did it once yesterday in the first half, it didn't get through, but it was beautiful to see. Sane's out, so it's not really an option on the other side (it's unfair to ask either Angeliño or Zin to do it, they just don't have the pace, and in Mendy's case both his pace and confidence are shot). But Pep must have told Walker not to do it, presumably because he doesn't have the legs to get back any more. Whatever it is, we're missing it, direly, as a way of mixing it up, and alternative to the probing through the middle, which absolutely was not working yesterday. High crosses: forget them. They are meat and drink to the opposition, and that is true of virtually everyone we play. Laporte scored the crucial goal at Brighton in the final game last season. Otamendi, yesterday. Two central defenders. That tells you everything you need to know.
And now, something else. A friend I met in the car park afterwards said something that I have to hold my hands up to. We as supporters are really not great. If things are going our way, it's all fine and dandy. It's normal that things should have gone flat after United's second. But I expected us to give the team more in the second half. Even in the south stand, nothing much was happening. A bloke in my row left at half time! I mean, what the actual? Another bloke in my row - a good blue, who I know and like - left fully twenty minutes before the end. Now it's not for me to police other fans' behaviour, but it leaves me very puzzled indeed. I don't care about other club's fans, that's neither here nor there for me. We criticize the players – legitimate – we criticise the manager – legitimate – we might take a good long look at ourselves sometimes. Are we becoming entitled? I hope not.
Oh and one more thing. Two seasons ago, we accumulated a never before seen 100 points, and won two trophies. Last season, we achieved a never before seen domestic treble. These are things I never expected to see, even after the takeover. It is right that we as fans should not forget too quickly. But for any truly great team and manager, these things should be ancient history. Only the current season counts. Only the next match is real. Otherwise, you're already sliding towards a mindset where you've put your slippers on, you've lit your pipe, and you're sitting by the fire reminiscing. I'm a grandfather, but I don't fucking want that! Because there's only one stop after that one...
Yesterday hurts, and will carry on hurting for days, like a burn, but the rags are essentially an irrelevance. Our title challenge is over. The season isn't even half over, and there are trophies to be won. Be critical – that's our prerogative – but let's get behind the fucking team on match days! Otherwise, I mean really, what's the point?
Well said. Why I love the going up and going down chant. Reminds us where we were oh but a blink of an eye ago.
 
He has not done a tap for the last month, world class my arse.

Teams know that if you crowd any player, two or three blocking any run into the area then you negate the strength that player has. He needs to be given a little more support, or our Catalan genius needs to come up with a definitive tactic that overcomes the defensive crowding.
 
to be honest I think Leicester are the only hope of stopping Liverpool now, however slim that is.

we are gone this season. We will limp to 3/4th. Hopefully get players back for the CL and have a go at that. Need to buy in Jan though whatever the cost.

We can't get any quality in Jan. We might get a little nugget who can add the dimension that Laporte or Sané brought to the team but I think the overwhelming feature of our play is that few are operating at the level they did last season, noticeably Sterling, Bernardo, and no matter how effective Ferny is at CB he needs to be at the pivot.
 
We have tried to carry on for too many seasons without proper a left-back. The one we thought we`d bought got injuries soon after that have reduced him when fit to not half the player he was. His replacement then got a serious injury Zincenko. To add to our fullback woes we compounded it further by not replacing Vincent Kompany.
Was his decision know too late and events conspired to hinder our search I dont know but we didnt. This left us with 3 experienced C/H`s. Unluckily our best one got a serious injury leaving us with at times a rash Otimendi and John Stones who Struggles for fitness and form.

This as we all know leaves us with a youngish leftback who`s abilities are better going forward especially and he doesnt have a fit Laporte to protect him.



You think we look good enough to beat a Brendon Rodgers Leicester. You have true faith my friend.

Not sure I do, really, bud!
 
We got beat fair and square yesterday. No complaints with the result or their penalty decision... and yet I’ve still come away angry at VAR. Bernardo’s foul was similar to Van Dykes in midweek (the Dutch lad’s being far more blatant) and yet we get two very different outcomes. As last man Van Dyke would have been sent off leaving his team at 2-2 with 10men for an hour.
It seems, as many have suggested, the League are determined to have a Scouse parade. The daft thing is they would have probably won it without any VAR assistance, now they’ll win it at a canter and make the league look very boring except to the plastic hordes who ‘follow’ their glory club.
 
@Roachy
And as sure as eggs are eggs you turn up when we get beat.
I've looked at your postings mate and not one post in a post match thread when we win.

Strange that!

All you do is moan, slag players off, slag the team off, criticize the manager, the tactics.
Your name pops up every time we lose or draw.

Just thought I'd point it out as the board is awash with these posters who only post when we lose.
As you were.
Bore off fella.
 
Yes I agree, Rodri in particular is very one paced and although looking quality at times Pep needs to find his most effective position. I am not sure he's Ferna' s natural replacement.

We are without three of last season's first choice back four and have also lost our best DM as a result of him having to fill in there. We are bound to suffer defensively but how often and easily they got behind us yesterday was alarming. I am just glad they were wasteful or hit most shots straight at Eddie, who really should have done better with Martials goal.

Jesus was easily contained, Sterling and Bernardo huffed and puffed but rarely looked like scoring, De Bruyne was off the pace and David Silva is sadly showing age catches up with everyone, even el magico. The false dawn of the Burnley game proved just that. Our comfortable win was more down to how woeful the opposition was, as proved by their hammering at Spur's.

Pep is making the right noises and defending his players in public but I'm sure inside he is pretty angry. He has proved ruthless in his career in the past and a few players don't know he has probably put a big cross through their names for next season. He isn't above blame himself and as in his first season here if we don't have the personnel to play his game due to injuries etcetera he has to tweak it until we do. We played right into the rags hands yesterday.

Long term there is a bigger revamp needed than any of us would have dreamed after the magnificent season we had last year. I am sure plans are afoot already regarding that and of course Laporte and Sane coming back will strengthen us for now, unfortunately that isn't for a couple of months.

Good post and I agree about most of it. But Pep is a stubborn old sod and sometimes cannot seem to accept what's right under his nose. Why on earth did he not being in a centre back when Kompany left??? We're still lacking even when Laporte is back. Why
not much else to add that's already been said really ?

i did fear this before the game and warned of this johnny big bollocks going into the derby, with them in mid-table and us retaining champions, it had the stink of them wanting it more and there biggest game of the season there cup final feel, if there was a time and place to play us at the moment then united could not have picked a better time, with the injury hit city squad and the players knowing the title for this season has gone long before the derby kicked off, also add all the eggs in the champions league basket this season then it was coming

lets call it right here its could have been a lot worse ? it could have been 5 or 6 for them if not for ederson 3 major saves before they score from the spot, am not even talking about VAR anymore because what is the point and we all know whats going on and can do nothing about it ??

the idiots in the corner should be banned for life and united will milk it for all its worth, why give them something to rubbish our name again, when one idiot does something like this the whole club takes the blame but this was a group of idiots and a racist and the book should be thrown at all of them

Agree with all of that mate.

Something I will add as well - and may get shot for. I remember many previous derby games before the takeover when various United supporters would say that we are unimportant to them and that they tegarded Liverpool as their rivals.

I always thought they were talking shite, but you know what, I don't think they were - I was wrong.

Because this is exactly how it is now the tables have turned. Normally I'd have been nervous all week before a derby, but this time, it was my wife asking me who we're playing at the weekend and me casually saying "oh yeah, I almost forgot, it's United".

But for United it was like their bloody cup final, running around like on steroids, heroic defending and looking for every moment like they wanted it much more than we did.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top