In 1981, American Airlines launched a membership scheme called AAirpass which promised unlimited first-class travel for life. The cost? $250,000, with the option of adding a companion for an additional $150,000.
The initiative seemed ingenious, but it quickly backfired: About a hundred flights were enough to break even, and some customers sought to exploit the system to the max.
Among the first customers was Steve Rothstein, a Chicago banker who, in 1987 decided to make the sky his daily means of transportation. He flew to another city for a burger, attended sporting events from coast to coast, shopped in Canada, and returned for lunch.
Over 21 years, he accumulated over 10 million miles, with hundreds of intercontinental flights: 120 to Tokyo, 50 to Hong Kong, 70 to Australia. His 40 million frequent flyer miles translated into free trips for friends, acquaintances, and complete strangers.
Rothstein also exploited the companion option, often nominating a fictitious companion to secure a free seat next to him, or inviting anyone he met to fly with him.
Between 2005 and 2008, he booked more than 3,000 flights, actually taking off approximately 500 times. The cost to American Airlines?
Approximately $21 million.
The company, now aware of the financial drain these passes had caused, sought legal recourse to terminate the contract. The only effective clause was one prohibiting the sale of tickets or payment by companions. After questioning several passengers, suspicious incidents of money exchanges emerged.
In December 2008, Rothstein was stopped at Chicago's airport and informed that his AAirpass had been canceled for fraudulent behavior.
Rothstein filed suit, but in 2011, American Airlines declared bankruptcy. The lawsuit ended with an out-of-court settlement, the details of which were never made public.
After the crisis, the airline quickly recovered and is now among the largest in the world.
Rothstein's case remains a prime example of how a brilliant idea can turn into an accounting nightmare, and how individual ingenuity can undermine even the most ambitious strategies.