There’s a difference between voting against your own self-interest and thinking that you’re voting in your own self-interest but aren’t because you’ve been had by a crook.
I’ve spent many words here cautioning that putting all Trump voters down to being either stupid or evil is wrong, and that both party establishments underestimated the hopelessness, desperation and anger of poor rural whites as technology, the economy and altered moral standards passed them by.
Unfortunately Trump, like any good evangelical
preacher, accurately identified them as dupes, as means to an end, and exploited that by convincing them that he alone could ease their pain and fear by making those responsible suffer (remember — HIM, not an ideology — HIM alone).
I'm not a regular contributor to this thread, but I do read it and that's why I felt compelled to post, just to break the circular argument, but all I've done is start another one and your post encapsulates it.
You rightly point out here....
"I’ve spent many words here cautioning that putting all Trump voters down to being either stupid or evil is wrong, and that both party establishments underestimated the hopelessness, desperation and anger of poor rural whites as technology, the economy and altered moral standards passed them by."
That this constituency has been poorly served by both main parties, and that is undoubtedly true, but what they've really been poorly served by is an economic system, to quote Gore Vidal....
“There is only one party in the United States, the Property Party … and it has two right wings: Republican and Democrat. Republicans are a bit stupider, more rigid, more doctrinaire in their laissez-faire capitalism than the Democrats, who are cuter, prettier, a bit more corrupt — until recently … and more willing than the Republicans to make small adjustments when the poor, the black, the anti-imperialists get out of hand. But, essentially, there is no difference between the two parties.”
Both parties are just two cheeks of the same arse, the fact that Trump has been able to carve a constituency out of this chaos by lying, cheating and playing the white man card does not, as you imply, make him an aberration, he is in many respects the logical conclusion to this double bind of corporate Democrat or corporate Republican.
That does not mean you have to opt for socialism to escape the misery of a political class in hock to the rich and powerful, but what it does mean is that options beyond global capitalism, beyond Wall Street, beyond the 1% must be entertained and brought in to mainstream political discourse. Because if you don't then the downtrodden only have the colour of their skin and their sense of cultural identity to cling to, and as we've seen crooks like Trump know how to exploit that, hence my point that Trump is a product of the system and not a one off charlatan.
The Republicans are a lost cause, but the Democrats contain the possibility of re-invention, but what do they offer? What is their answer to the monumental challenges America faces, not only from Trump, but the power of global capital, climate change, and the growing power of Russia and China?......They offer Joe Biden.
Is it any wonder, given the scale of the challenges the USA faces, that some folk, with justification, throw up their hands and shout "fuck this for a game of soldiers!"