Rate the CWC transfer window /10 to date

[birchwoodgingerste]

Can't judge til we see them play hopefully it will be money well spent.

 

[Vester]

If it were September 1st today, I’d say 8. If we bring in a quality right back, it will be a 9 or 10.

It’s impossible not to be impressed by our transfer business thus far.

Would you still say its an 8/10?

 

[Dr Jacoby]

Would you still say its an 8/10?

Ask me tomorrow. ;)

 

[Columbia]

6/10 at best, great to sign a left back but rest of signings bang average players that literally no other clubs wanted.

 

[richards30]

7/10 imo. Started well but main areas not addressed still and we seem to have become sterile to signing world class

 

[Lkzerinho]

6/10.

Addressed some spots, but didn't really add anything that made us any better.

 

[Jimfv1]

6/10

Yet to see improvement on last season, wingers and midfielders look lightweight compared to other teams, can't see goals from anywhere but Haaland again...

Fullback's also looking poor.

Hopefully the can improve when they get used to the system and the passing needs to be quicker all over the pitch, all this holding onto the ball too long seems to indicate indecision and when they do speed up play they seem to lose the ball.

 

[Delphinho]

Started very good, ended horribly. Outgoings was just as important as incomings, and we’ve hardly done anything in that department

 

[Marvin.]

3/10.

So far we have brought in one decent player in Reijnders. That's not enough. We're further behind Liverpool and Arsenal than when we started.

 

[Damanino]

yes, there is one way to rate it if we just look at ourselves, but we cannot miss the rivals business and imo they got quality improvements in. especially Arsenal made their squad as deep as they can. Liverpool may have not spent last summer but now they took all the money they saved there and spending like there is no tomorrow. and still want Guehi and Isak.

 

[Giovinco]

Very very poor unfortunately.

 

[chris85mcfc]

Don't think we are any better off at the moment to be honest

Was hoping the January signings would have had plenty of bedding in time by now, but on the whole we don't see anything of them

Marmoush is a Spurs level player and wouldn't get in Chelsea, Arsenal or Liverpool teams

Hard to judge the summer signings yet, and given Wirtz has started slowly, we should really give our signings more time

On the whole though, I don't feel we've added any serious quality, and were still incredibly light at right back and on the wings

 

[madloaf]

Cherki will be class for Chelsea in 2 years. As will Nypan.

 

[Skrastins]

Window clearly is not closed, but
Good things
KdB replacement has been adressed - Cherki
8 which we needed - Rudolph
Specialist LB- RAN
How these players will turn out, time will tell, but i like them

Bad things
Trafford/ Donnarumma signing are bit random tbh
Squad thinning has not been done
RB has not been signed


All together. I would put it at 7 mark

 

[Mad 4 It]

3/10.

So far we have brought in one decent player in Reijnders. That's not enough. We're further behind Liverpool and Arsenal than when we started.

110% this, what’s worse is that we haven’t managed to move on any of the old guard

 

[Blackley_Blue]

We've been well and truly left behind.

I appreciate this might come across as a bit 'entitled' but we just don't act like an Elite club in the transfer market. We needed to go big and we've gone mid-tabled.

 

[decmancity]

We've been well and truly left behind.

I appreciate this might come across as a bit 'entitled' but we just don't act like an Elite club in the transfer market. We needed to go big and we've gone mid-tabled.

We don’t act like it or we can’t?

 

[Giovinco]

Window clearly is not closed, but
Good things
KdB replacement has been adressed - Cherki
8 which we needed - Rudolph
Specialist LB- RAN
How these players will turn out, time will tell, but i like them

Bad things
Trafford/ Donnarumma signing are bit random tbh
Squad thinning has not been done
RB has not been signed


All together. I would put it at 7 mark

You think Cherki is replacing KDB?

I would urge you to manage your expectations

 

[Lee the Blue]

Goalkeeping situation a mess

Right Back not addressed

Left back finally brought in - looks underwhelming

2 centre midfielders brought in - one hides when the going gets tough, the other is already injured.

2/10

 

[Gabriel]

Have to wait until all windows are closed to see who departs and then view the final result in conjunction with the January window. As the months have rolled by, it’s been increasingly difficult to see any coherent ‘plan’, however, no matter how much lipstick some have wished to apply.