Ref Watch

Yep, first one on Var, whats the point if they cant see the clear pen. Brooks bottled it also for 2nd one, putting it in Alti Hands
No he didn't, he has to refer it to the on field ref to make the final decision.
 
No he didn't, he has to refer it to the on field ref to make the final decision.
He does but the referee doesn't have to look at the replay. The VAR can tell the referee it's an obvious penalty and the referee can just give it.


  • For subjective decisions, e.g. intensity of a foul challenge, interference at offside, handball considerations, an ‘on-field review’ (OFR) is appropriate
  • For factual decisions e.g. position of an offence or player (offside), point of contact (handball/foul), location (inside or outside the penalty area), ball out of play etc. a VAR-only review is usually appropriate but an ‘on-field review’ (OFR) can be used for a factual decision if it will help manage the players/match or ‘sell’ the decision (e.g. a crucial match-deciding decision late in the game)
 
He does but the referee doesn't have to look at the replay. The VAR can tell the referee it's an obvious penalty and the referee can just give it.


  • For subjective decisions, e.g. intensity of a foul challenge, interference at offside, handball considerations, an ‘on-field review’ (OFR) is appropriate
  • For factual decisions e.g. position of an offence or player (offside), point of contact (handball/foul), location (inside or outside the penalty area), ball out of play etc. a VAR-only review is usually appropriate but an ‘on-field review’ (OFR) can be used for a factual decision if it will help manage the players/match or ‘sell’ the decision (e.g. a crucial match-deciding decision late in the game)
So, by your own definition, an on field review is appropriate. What is/isn't a foul comes under "subjective decision".
 
It was our decimated defence that meant we didn’t pick up all the points today. Not the referee.
Still in our hands.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.