Robhino vs Kinkladze

[Thaksins Love Child]

That was the most mesmerising performance I've ever seen from a City player.

I agree.

Add me to this. I had the MOTD highlights on tape for years. Used to watch it ever day at the time. Absolutely amazing, and Newcastle were top of the Prem at the time.

 

[Joycee Banercheck]

Kinky. The best footballer I have EVER seen. He made everything look so easy despite being in a team with a fair few crap players.

 

[The Fat el Hombre]

We've had this argument before

Robinho is on a whole different level to Kinky, only City fans would seriously compare the two. Do not let sentimentality cloud your judgement

I find the whole thing laughable to be honest

 

[droylsdenblue]

On his day Kinkladze was awsome,but not enough "days" for me. So its Robinho I say.

 

[Thaksins Love Child]

Haha I think 2 mins 13 secs on that you tube clip sums up the shite he had to play with.

Does everything, gives it to Buster-Phillips without any players near him and he hits the post from 6 yards. His reaction is the realisation!

 

[blue 1992]

Robbie. Would be nice to have them both tho!

i agree.

 

[Anonymous]

Kinkladze was the more talented one JUST. He was a genius.

Robinho is different class aswell. Proud to have seen both of them play for us.

 

[bluetoo]

whilst i was a big fan of Kinkladze, I don't EVER recall him grabbing a game by the scruff of the neck as he should have done

huh?

 

[bluetoo]

Kinky was the only reason to watch City in the dark days. Comparing him to Robbie is a little unfair given the fact that he was expected to carry the weight of the dross that surrounded him.

Skill on the ball: Robbie 8, Kinky 9
Eye for goal: Robbie 9 Kinky 7
Effectiveness: Kinky 8, Robbie 8
Work rate: Kinky 9, Robbie 7

Sheer entertainment: Kinky 10, Robbie 8

 

[wilf9]

11 Goals from a playyer whoclaims he isn't playing well says it all for me. Also robbie actually isn't affraid to work, whick i was worried about when we first signed him.