LoveCity said:
yellamcfc said:
LoveCity said:
I'm not sure but we should have enough for this season, we can register Boyata and Nimely if necessary (over-21s), while Razak and Guidetti become eligible to register next year I think.
Only my personal view, but Boyata, Nimley and Razak will never be good enough for what we want to achieve, altough Guidetti might have what it takes to reach the next level.
No but we couldn't fill a 25 man squad last year (and that was with Hargreaves, Onuoha, and Bridge included) so we could register either Boyata and Nimely even if we don't intend to use them (but to fill a homegrown spot), unless Mancini decides to splash out on squad players, leaving no room in the squad.
I am sure it has been said before, but there is no requirement to have a full 25 man squad with the 8 homegrown quota, If you have no HG players you are allowed a maximum of 17 over 21's but as many under that age as you like, many teams in the league don't have a full 25, Chelsea were 3 or 4 players out at the start of last season IIRC, Arsenal's squad mas made up of a good few under 21 regulars. Whilst of the players you listed, Hargreaves is n't home grown he grew up in Canada, came through in Germany and his first experience of English domestic football was with utd. With the England team players plus Clichy we have 7 out of the 8 needed to have a full 25, Boyaya might be worth having if we are going to play him, but otherwise there is no point, and as we are likely to add another CB, he would have little chance of football even in the league cup. The only space I could see for those players is if we need them to make up a CL squad, but even in that scenario they may be useless as I am sure you can enter with a less than full squad and very rarely do you see a full 25 CL feature.
There only reason I could see for players to stick around with no playing time other than for the reserves, (have n't we opted out of that league anyway?)
is if they are on wages that another club is unlikely to pay them, so they hang about for a year, knowing they will get another contract some where else but happy to pick up a good wedge until they do. An example perhaps is someone like Gavin Hoyte, only just left Arsenal at 22; made 1 appearance in 2008-9 nothing since, as had a few loan spells but none where he made an impact, he may have had injury problems which may have had an impact on a move way or made his mind up to collect the good wages Arsenal pay their kids, he is now in league 2 with Dagenham. Our boys will end up that low if they are left to hang around like spare parts, either give them loans to establish themselves as footballers, or sell them on. If we want to get a good return on them now is the time;we might get 0.5-1 mil for Nimely and could squeeze as much as 3 or 4 for Boyata.
If we put them in the squad we need to have a use for them, other wise it makes much more sense for us to save costs, try to get a good fee for them and say good luck and good bye, and it makes sense for them to try an establish playing regularly at a club as high up as possible.