Scottish independence

bellbuzzer said:
Henkeman said:
DavidSilvasLeftFoot said:
If they vote No then big changes will need to be made. The fact that up to 2 million people would vote to leave the Union says how bad things are. We need further devolution.

No, we need a change in the constitutional structure of the UK. Scottish MPs voting on English affairs is intolerable. The constitution is fundamentally unbalanced and needs changing quite substantially. The Westminster Parliament is caricatured as being English, when the English are the ones with the democratic deficit while every other other constituent country has an assembly.

That rebalancing is essential for Scotland as much as anywhere else. It's created the politics of resentment all round. And it's not healthy.

''politics of resentment'' is that another glib phrase from tory HQ , like ''politics of envy''?

Don't make assumptions.

The resentment is in both directions, that's why it's a problem. Assuming it is some kind of dig is your own perception.
 
DavidSilvasLeftFoot said:
https://twitter.com/AngrySalmond

This is more entertaining coverage than the BBC
Love the " in an independent Scotland all bus stops will have bartenders" line
 
Henkeman said:
bellbuzzer said:
Henkeman said:
No, we need a change in the constitutional structure of the UK. Scottish MPs voting on English affairs is intolerable. The constitution is fundamentally unbalanced and needs changing quite substantially. The Westminster Parliament is caricatured as being English, when the English are the ones with the democratic deficit while every other other constituent country has an assembly.

That rebalancing is essential for Scotland as much as anywhere else. It's created the politics of resentment all round. And it's not healthy.

''politics of resentment'' is that another glib phrase from tory HQ , like ''politics of envy''?

Don't make assumptions.

The resentment is in both directions, that's why it's a problem. Assuming it is some kind of dig is your own perception.

point taken, an over-reaction to a good post.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.