Agree with a lot of what you've said but we often sell out early round FA Cup games as that's one area where the club get the pricing right - loads of local families who can't afford season tickets and match day prices for PL games tend to snap those tickets up. We actually sold more for the Liverpool semi than I expected, given the much publicised issues around that game. Funnily enough, although Liverpool are the miles better side these days I reckon if that semi had been against United then we'd have sold out no problem. Fact of the matter is that even though they're currently dogshit, games against United are still a bigger draw for City fans than any other opposition.