Should Roberto Mancini be sacked?

[olddirty]

Why get rid of the best manager we've had for 30+ years? (Pure madness and smacks of "Typical City").

To get better ?

 

[Bluemoon dan]

No, should be given one more crack at the Champions League. Fail to get out of the group stages again and he can have no complaints.

 

[Bazzmand Show]

Yes, despite the fact I really like him. I just think he has got what he can out of the team now and really don't think we have progressed much, since we started with him. Lets face it, we played football out of this world, for half a season - the rest of it hasn't exactly been great. If United hadn't fallen over last year, we wouldn't even be having this topic anyway, as he'd have been sacked much earlier.

 

[mad zab]

I have voted yes.

Just think it's time for a change with a less confrontational manager.

To me, Mancini being confrontational shows that he has passion for this football club.
Forza Mancini!

When it is the players or officials at the club he is confronting, it should be done in house and not through the media.

The constant carping about not signing RVP as imo undermined the other strikers at the club.

I appreciate everything he has done for us, but I still think it's better to shake hands and go our seperate ways.

 

[Mike D]

For finishing 2nd no.

But if he has lost the dressing room then yes I am afraid.

But I don't have the finger on the pulse of the squad like those tasked with making the decision and will trust their judgement.

How do you determine whether or not he has lost the dressing room that would be ambiguous to say the least?

For what it's worth I would say no and I suspect the decision will be down to Txiki Begiristain and whether he and Mancini share the same vision in the long term. I doubt very much winning the FA cup would have made any difference what so ever. If rumours are to be believed then this was a done deal a while ago.

 

[mad zab]

I have voted yes.

Just think it's time for a change with a less confrontational manager.

Would you count Fergie as confrontational? Sometimes confrontational is good.

The board handled the situation horribly.

He doesn't confront people within his club via the media.

 

[blueste41]

Given who it looks his replacement will be, the 89 of you who want him sacked should give your heads a wobble IMO.

 

[SWP's back]

How do you determine whether or not he has lost the dressing room that would be ambiguous to say the least?

That would be incredibly straight forward.

I would have (and I would be shocked if it hasn't happened) informal talks with the captain, vice captain and key senior members of the squad.

 

[Belfast_city]

No, should be given one more crack at the Champions League. Fail to get out of the group stages again and he can have no complaints.

i agree with this,for god sake the man deserves it,like it or lump it he is a city legend so why shouldnt he get on more season,you cant win every season its just not possible,a year ago today we were champs and mancini was a legend,a god,the saviour and now people want him gone????

 

[underneath the sky]

No simple as that we have a manager who has brought us the success we craved for years give him another season at least