Should we recall Joe Hart?

[svennis pennis]

No way leave him where he is bring Joe Hart back and do what put him on the bench really do well for his confidence won't it?

Why stick him on the bench? He is part of a Birmingham team that just dont concede goals where as we look like shipping them everytime a ball nears our six yard box. I'd have him in our starting eleven to see what difference it makes to our team. We would soon find out if the rickety back line shores up.

 

[mat]

I would like to see mancini get an experienced back up on loan in jan. If we lose shay, we will be fucked.

 

[Blu KB]

Don't really understand why you would want him back, unless its to replace Given....our player of the month.

 

[Project]

In an ideal world we will grant another years loan, with Joe looking to come back in 2011-12. He should have ironed out most of his weaknesses by then and will be a reasonably experienced keeper. What would be the point in selling him? Seems like we have a perfect succession plan.

The only sticky point is if Joe demands a permanent move.

 

[hgblue]

Don't really understand why you would want him back, unless its to replace Given....our player of the month.

Q. What do we do if Given gets injured?
A. We're fucked.

 

[city51]

Yes


































in 4 or 5 years

 

[johnny crossan]

Utterly incomprehensible on so many levels, the first being we can't.

 

[Blu KB]

Don't really understand why you would want him back, unless its to replace Given....our player of the month.

Q. What do we do if Given gets injured?
A. We're fucked.

Q. What do we do if Given gets injured?
A. We're loaded.

 

[Bluemoonbaldboy]

Joe is doing exactly what is required he is showing his anger at being dropped by reminding the club just how good he is, I think Shay has been an amazing buy and do think he is a better keeper however Hart didn't deserve to be dropped the problem wasn't the keeper it was the defence at the time and that has been proved by just how brilliant Given has had to be so often due to the players infront of him.

 

[citytill1die84]

No way leave him where he is bring Joe Hart back and do what put him on the bench really do well for his confidence won't it?

Why stick him on the bench? He is part of a Birmingham team that just dont concede goals where as we look like shipping them everytime a ball nears our six yard box. I'd have him in our starting eleven to see what difference it makes to our team. We would soon find out if the rickety back line shores up.

SO now ur saying Joe Hart is better than Shay Given don't talk stupid mate he played in our back line last year we shipped goals till Shay Given took over I rest my case u TOOL