Soccer Saturday Sackings

[Blue Hefner]

Hart is terrible, happy with Micah and Scott.

I've only seen him a bit. Any critisism I had of him I put down to nerves but seen as though he can string a sentence togther(an ex-City) I think he may grow into the role but it's not a hill I'm going to die on

 

[The Light Was Yellow Sir]

If these aren't fair dismissals for good reasons we'll know in due course.

So, if the new pundits are Richards, Wright and Morrison, they won’t be sacked ‘for good reason’ but if they’re replaced by Warnock, MacManaman and Gareth Barry they will be?

 

[21silva]

So, if the new pundits are Richards, Wright and Morrison, they won’t be sacked ‘for good reason’ but if they’re replaced by Warnock, MacManaman and Gareth Barry they will be?

if I got sacked I’d like to know my successor is an improvement and deserved the role. If it was someone like Morrison who can’t speak and doesn’t know his arse from his elbow then yes it’s not for good reason. It did need a revamp it just feels forced to happen at this point. My hope is the replacements are well worth watching, provide great analysis and improves what was a stale show.

 

[Damien10]

The world we are living in is changing, and it's not for the better. I believe a divide is bigger now then it has ever been. It will all end horribly.

The only thing that matters in life is respect.

 

[Mad Eyed Screamer]

"Hello..... Is that Charlie / Le Tiss / Pinocchio? I am the director of Talk Sport and wondsring...... "

 

[jma]

The truth is neither of us know for sure so all we can do is take what we do know and form an objective opinion based on that.

Your 'objective opinion' is based on many more assumptions of the unknown and predictions about the future than someone else who is saying "3 poor pundits have been dropped - something that is not uncommon in tv. That is not a bad thing. Let's wait and see who replaces them and how they perform."

So the two are not equivalent in their assertions.

 

[Blue Hefner]

The world we are living in is changing, and it's not for the better. I believe a divide is bigger now then it has ever been. It will all end horribly.

The only thing that matters in life is respect.

Seems an overreation to 3 over the hill pundits getting their cards.....

 

[Damien10]

Seems an overreation to 3 over the hill pundits getting their cards.....

It's not just about Sky Sports decision...

 

[Blue Hefner]

It's not just about Sky Sports decision...

But this is a sky sports thread

 

[Ban-jani]

Really? I've not listended to Ashley Cole much but all Keane bangs on about is 'trying harder', 'getting closer to people' and 'this is Manchester United we are talking about..'

He's good for social media clips but I find whenver I see him that he offers very little actual insight

Oddly enough I do quite like Rio Ferdinand when he stops being a United fan and takes his job seriously. What he says about defending and striker movements I find pretty interesting

Rio is decent, Keane is absolute box office I think he’s great on there.

I am hoping Micah gets the job on Soccer Saturday, will be good to have a pro City pundit with energy.