Damocles said:
Martin Edwards was the Sheik before the Sheik. United were known as mega-spenders all the way back in the early 20th century (if Gary James is reading, perhaps he can confirm or deny this). United's fanbase was always smaller than City's in the Manchester area, back when that sort of thing was important.
It's a difficult one to focus on because you can look at this from different angles. Apart from the 1980s-2000s City were always able to buy expensive players. We've broken the transfer record on several occasions (not just twice as the City website claims) and so our present situation is one that can be viewed as being on a par with our entire history (obviously the amounts are greater).
With United, they have also been a buying club at times. They certainly have inflated purchase prices. To me the early years of Ferguson's reign are more about expensive purchases (think about Utd's team for the 5-1 in 1989) than home grown talent and it is true that the money spent on players like Pallister in the 80s set the template for what followed in the Premier League era.
United should not get on their high horse about inflated transfer fees as analysis would prove that they are as guilty (if not more so) than City, Chelsea, Real Madrid or whoever.
To me City's recent ability to challenge for the best players is more typical of our entire history than the limited scope we've had in the last twenty or so years, so it'd be wrong for anyone in football to claim City have no history/heritage/right to make these bids.
At the time of Robinho's arrival I wrote a piece for the programme which pointed out that:
• We have beaten or equalled the British Transfer record in five separate decades
• City were the first British side to have bought two separate million pound players
• In 1981 the Blues purchased their third million pound man (Trevor Francis) – equalling Nottingham Forest, but this feat was not matched by any other club until United bought our present manager Mark Hughes from Barcelona in 1988
• Our own transfer record has been smashed twice within a few months on four occasions
• As early as 1904 the Blues were regarded as matching the British record and in that same year we also broke the record for winger.
Our history and heritage suggests we should be challenging for the best.