Spurs (A) | FA Cup | Post Match Thread

[Vic]

Maybe there should be a margin for error that should be allowed, as there supposedly is in speed cameras. I don't see how var can actually measure offside to millimetre accuracy as they pretend.

So 1mm, 2mm, 3mm - measured from where? Obviously from the same lines as drawn now.

In the still image from last night, there was "daylight" between the lines...

 

[BringBackSwales]

They were the home team (who haven't won a trophy in the last 16 years, despite being a "big club"), and they had one shot in the whole game. And two corners.

And were playing for an away replay, how shit is that?

 

[Eds]

I am still struggling to remember their one shot. Anyone care to tell me when it was? Surely it’s not when Ortega dived at the feet of someone.

 

[Bluearmy]

I am still struggling to remember their one shot. Anyone care to tell me when it was? Surely it’s not when Ortega dived at the feet of someone.

Must be that

 

[Bluearmy]

I’m talking generally.. VAR should not be used for off sides where someone’s nipple is deemed to be offside as it’s not clear and obvious. I’d bin VAR personally as it’s not brought many if any but if it has to be used then not for marginal offside decisions

No clear and obvious on line calls. Its either on/off or over the line/not. If you muddy the waters here we all know which teams would benefit

Having said that the semi-automated offsides need to be brought in asap. Stop this 3 min wait for a decision!!

 

[Bluearmy]

This all day

This was never a law (daylight), the Wenger Law which is being proposed currently is close tho. With below example (Sterling) being onside under these proposals.

However there would still be lines and decisions would still come down to millimetres either way

 

[Pezzer2]

What a fantastic away trip. Didn't get back in my house until 6am but worth every moment. Its the best stadium I've been to but the infrastructure around the ground is a shambles. Our coach was parked at the Tesco over a mile away , a lot of elderly City fans were struggling walking that far.
Atmosphere inside the ground was superb, City fans on top form. We was in 117 just under that Spurs section, over zealous stewarding nearly caused a riot at the start of 2nd half.
Great performance special mention to Kovacic and Ake both colossal

 

[Tolmie scores]

Maybe there should be a margin for error that should be allowed, as there supposedly is in speed cameras. I don't see how var can actually measure offside to millimetre accuracy as they pretend.

They can't half of the pics with lines an all that are not taken at the exact moment the ball leaves the passers foot so it's pointless and rife for manipulation...how did they really define that Bobb's foot was 3 mm further ahead at the exact moment the ball bounced off the keeper...rubbish..get rid

 

[Big Jonjo]

The ball had not left Fodens foot on the still that was used for the offside last night. It would have been interesting to see the next frame.

 

[Fordyboy46]

one of my work colleagues who is a spurs fan claims we weren't all that last night ha

We very rarely are coming back after a two week break, but still outplayed his shit Spurs